Women's March For Arkansas Chokes On Diversity
Start writing a post
Politics

Women's March For Arkansas Chokes On Diversity

Thousands gathered in Little Rock this past weekend to protest in wake of Trump's inauguration---but the march has raised concerns about intersectionality and exclusiveness

41
Women's March For Arkansas Chokes On Diversity
Renea Goddard

On January 21, nearly 7,000 people participated in the Women’s March For Arkansas at the Arkansas State Capitol in Little Rock.

The demonstration was intended to serve as a sister march to the Women’s March On Washington, which was the first major Women’s March protest planned as a direct response to the presidential election and inauguration of Donald Trump. On January 21st, Women’s March protests occurred in multiple locations around the world, with global participation at an estimated 4.8 million.

These protests were intended to be a response to misogyny, racism, ableism, and xenophobia espoused by both Trump himself and the Trump campaign, as well as an acknowledgment of the already existing structural oppression of women that allowed for the election of Trump to the White House. Donald Trump is currently the only U.S. president to have ever admitted to committing sexual assault on record, as well as the only U.S. president to have ever been formally accused of raping a minor. His other acts of misogyny include a long history of publicly humiliating and degrading women. In addition, the marches are also intended to be a response to the Trump administration’s jeopardization of the rights of women of color, immigrant and undocumented women, transgender women, gay and same-gender loving women, and gender nonconforming individuals, as well as any woman affected by the new administration’s anti-immigration and Islamophobic rhetoric.

The Women’s March in Little Rock proceeded two blocks from the corner of Pulaski St. to the Arkansas State Capitol where a rally took place on the steps of the Capitol building. The rally featured a number of speakers ranging from Arkansas political representatives to members of the Little Rock public school system. Crystal C. Mercer, activist, artist, and sole proprietor of the Columbus Creative Arts + Activism and Merchant served as the emcee. The lineup included Ana Claudia Aguayo, Development Officer of Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art and a community activist for the rights of immigrants and the undocumented, as well as Sophia Said, the Programs Director for the Interfaith Center of Arkansas and a distinguished community organizer, among several other speakers. The Vice Mayor of Little Rock, Kathy Webb, drew the speaker portion to a close with a brief speech.

Following this, organizers led the rally into chanting a variation of the presidential oath to “commit to be an active participant in the future of our country.” as stated on the Program page.

The oath followed, “I do solemnly swear that I will faithfully execute my role as an American and will to the best of my ability, preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States.”

A look at the event’s Facebook page comments and other social media traffic associated with the rally indicates a large number of attendees who felt that the program was able to foster empowerment and unity; however, a highly overlooked but certainly still crucial voice that also appeared in response to the march was dissatisfaction with the ‘whitewashed’ demographic of the rally, the centering of the rally on cisgender women and cissexist standards, and the inclusion of nationalistic and patriotic elements to the program.

Be The Change Alliance, founded by Gwendolynn Combs, sponsored and organized the Women’s March For Arkansas. The platform of the march and rally was intended to be an intersectional one that would amplify the voices of marginalized women in various communities, as indicated by the Facebook page:

[rebelmouse-proxy-image https://media.rbl.ms/image?u=%2Ffiles%2F2017%2F01%2F24%2F636208499335687307-616766782_15977909_10208037547439121_5072853005566881236_n.jpg%3Foh%3De30b2e3e7b87778dc42e7eaf7fb3e93a%26oe%3D59224DC6&ho=https%3A%2F%2Faz616578.vo.msecnd.net&s=216&h=52f618af48b647be372a01634b6230f1c1437099e32d9050302724d9d579d324&size=980x&c=2657904360 crop_info="%7B%22image%22%3A%20%22https%3A//media.rbl.ms/image%3Fu%3D%252Ffiles%252F2017%252F01%252F24%252F636208499335687307-616766782_15977909_10208037547439121_5072853005566881236_n.jpg%253Foh%253De30b2e3e7b87778dc42e7eaf7fb3e93a%2526oe%253D59224DC6%26ho%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Faz616578.vo.msecnd.net%26s%3D216%26h%3D52f618af48b647be372a01634b6230f1c1437099e32d9050302724d9d579d324%26size%3D980x%26c%3D2657904360%22%7D" expand=1 original_size="1x1"]

“We support the advocacy and resistance movements that reflect our multiple and intersecting identities. We call on all defenders of human rights to join us. This march is the first step towards unifying our communities, grounded in new relationships, to create change from the grassroots level up. We will not rest until women have parity and equity at all levels of leadership in society. We work peacefully while recognizing there is no true peace without justice and equity for all.”

However, a significant number of responses from women of color and trans women, many who attended the rally and many who deliberately chose not to, may reflect a different reality.

Like the vast majority of the Women’s March events that happened throughout the world on January 21, the Women’s March For Arkansas featured a large number of signs using vaginas and uteruses as feminist symbolism/imagery---a recurring motif in feminist art and feminist movements that center on cisgender women. Many of the signs that had phrases like “Pussies grab back!” were intended to be a direct response to Donald Trump’s misogynistic comment from a video of his private conversation on the set of Days Of Our Lives where he says about women, “Grab ’em by the pussy. You can do anything.”

However, many of the signs featured phrases such as “No Pussy No Power” and “Uteruses Before Duderuses”, which can easily be perceived as promoting a limiting, objectifying, and inaccurate perspective on womanhood and actively alienating transgender women from the movement. Though there have been many arguments made on the importance of reproductive justice, responses from communities of color and the transgender community have asserted that the reproductive rights movement should move from focusing largely on the reproductive organs of cisgender women, to broadening the definition of what is considered “reproductive justice”.

#WomensMarch activist remember
-not all women have vaginas
-not all women have periods
-not all ppl with vaginas are women
-cissexism is bad
— a trans™ (@CommonTransKid) January 22, 2017

Not only that, but Trump’s “pussy” comment highlights his objectification of women, sexual predatory behavior, and his promotion of sexual assault---none of which are exclusive to only women with vaginas. Transgender women, particularly transgender women of color, face a higher risk for sexual violence than their cisgender peers, as well as the highest risks of homicide compared to other marginalized groups.

[rebelmouse-proxy-image https://media.rbl.ms/image?u=%2Ffiles%2F2017%2F01%2F24%2F636208499335384961528974266_ncavp_5.png%3Fitok%3DuuOGh1y-&ho=https%3A%2F%2Faz616578.vo.msecnd.net&s=148&h=60891e02695a8e40783bb1fdee93343c70c2585cdf612964eeb0e2ec2d250d18&size=980x&c=96831231 crop_info="%7B%22image%22%3A%20%22https%3A//media.rbl.ms/image%3Fu%3D%252Ffiles%252F2017%252F01%252F24%252F636208499335384961528974266_ncavp_5.png%253Fitok%253DuuOGh1y-%26ho%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Faz616578.vo.msecnd.net%26s%3D148%26h%3D60891e02695a8e40783bb1fdee93343c70c2585cdf612964eeb0e2ec2d250d18%26size%3D980x%26c%3D96831231%22%7D" expand=1 original_size="1x1"]

Other criticisms of the Women’s March in Little Rock were concerns about overtly pacifist and patriotic overtones, with concerns that the march would not serve the function of a protest--that is, to create a disruption in order to call attention to a cause or demand. The inclusion of the oath appeared to cause discomfort in some protesters who saw cognitive dissonance in a rally that is in opposition to the Trump administration encouraging the crowd to swear loyalty to the United States constitution.

In addition, some of the supporters of the Trump administration include the KKK and the modern white nationalist movement (often referred to as the “alt-right”), and the promotion of racist fear-mongering was one of the major reasons that Trump was able to snag the presidency. This and the fact that the Women’s March For Arkansas, like the majority of other Women’s Marches that took place in the United States, appeared to be overwhelmingly white, indicates a disparity between the largely white mainstream liberal feminism movement and the actual pressing issues affecting American women. In addition, the majority of the rally's attendees were Little Rock residents; however, black residents make up 42% of the population of Little Rock, while black attendees of the rally didn't make up even close to that amount. Exclusion, whether willful or accidental, appears to be the only explanation for many.

It is a well-known fact that the statistics ultimately point to white supremacy as the deciding factor in the 2016 election, which has continued to complicate solidarity between white women and women of color during the Women’s Marches--including the one here in Little Rock. It was, after all, 53% of white women who voted for Donald Trump, compared to a staggering 94% of black women who voted for Hillary Clinton, and an overwhelming Clinton majority in every non-white demographic.

[rebelmouse-proxy-image https://media.rbl.ms/image?u=%2Ffiles%2F2017%2F01%2F24%2F636208499335687307292677112_16114418_10210192448860915_6754614164299176091_n.jpg%3Foh%3D8b6807c45e766cbc05de60b520fb9f56%26oe%3D5922A412&ho=https%3A%2F%2Faz616578.vo.msecnd.net&s=30&h=ec1333af27537fb405413f26b57bf35bc25cd50bd252fd494a1736a61b395b46&size=980x&c=918086522 crop_info="%7B%22image%22%3A%20%22https%3A//media.rbl.ms/image%3Fu%3D%252Ffiles%252F2017%252F01%252F24%252F636208499335687307292677112_16114418_10210192448860915_6754614164299176091_n.jpg%253Foh%253D8b6807c45e766cbc05de60b520fb9f56%2526oe%253D5922A412%26ho%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Faz616578.vo.msecnd.net%26s%3D30%26h%3Dec1333af27537fb405413f26b57bf35bc25cd50bd252fd494a1736a61b395b46%26size%3D980x%26c%3D918086522%22%7D" expand=1 original_size="1x1"]

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Student Life

College 101: How To Ease The Back To School Blues

Getting back into the school groove when you just can't seem to let go of summer.

4012
Beyond The States

With fall classes just beginning, many of us find ourselves struck with summer withdrawals. Especially for those who refrained from taking courses over the summer, it can be quite difficult to get back in the swing of things. Fortunately, there are various ways to help make the transition back to college as smooth as possible.

Keep Reading... Show less
Dating Apps

We Met At A Bar

Salvage what you can; if you can't, it's alright to walk away.

3560
We Met At A Bar
Anne Waldon

We met at a bar.

Keep Reading... Show less
Sports

The Mets And Me

They may be the worst sometimes, but this baseball team has given me more than I could ask for.

3120
Rich Schultz/Getty Images

On September 3rd, 2001, a sea of children littered my home's navy-carpeted den to watch baseball during my dad's 40th birthday extravaganza. A baseball game flickered on the TV, and a red and blue bubble of a scoreboard sat in the bottom right corner of the screen. The New York Mets and the Philadelphia Phillies were in a wild game at Veterans' Stadium. As I, a five-year-old boy with a jumble of curly blonde hair, sat in the back of the kid clump, I wondered which team I should root for. After a long debate with myself, I decided that I should root for the team that's winning (duh). But, as the ninth inning rolled around with the Phils maintaining a 7-5 lead, some magic occurred. The Mets put up five runs in one frame, stunning the Phillie fans in the room and winning the game 10-7.

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

Which BTS Member You Are Based On Your Star Sign

If you love BTS, I'm sure you relate to one or many of them in several ways. This star test will help you learn more about which member you are most connected to.

2448
Which BTS Member You Are Based On Your Star Sign

Astrological signs tell a lot about a person. Do you ever wonder what your BTS bias star sign is? Is it the same as yours, or or are you more like one of the other amazing members? Take a look and find out what yours (and the members of Bangtan) says about you.

Keep Reading... Show less
Relationships

Hittin' the Road Playlist

With the end of August approaching more quickly than many of us would like, the preparation for school is happening in more ways than just one.

4612
http://cdn1.theodysseyonline.com/files/2014/08/11/635433794713320635180099351_road%20trip%20playlist.jpg

The car is all packed. The money you saved (and didn't spend online) from your summer internship is secured quietly in your bank account. The immediate reunion with your long-distance college friends is set. The real question on everyone's minds is: do you have the perfect melody to jam to as you journey back to school? 

Keep Reading... Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments