My Reaction To Autumn On Abortion
Start writing a post
Politics

My Reaction To Autumn On Abortion

"Planned Parenthood's Worst Nightmare" refuted.

56
My Reaction To Autumn On Abortion
http://studentsforlife.org/this-is-autumn-shes-planned-parenthoods-worst-nightmare/

I am writing this piece in response to a video that Students for Life of America made regarding an article published by Teen Vogue titled “What to Get a Friend Post-Abortion.” In the video, Autumn, 16, explains how sickening the article is and points out some of the most insensitive parts. You don’t need to watch the video or read the magazine article to understand my article, but I press you to, all the same.

I am writing directly to Autumn.

I agree with you. I agree that abortion is scary and ending a pregnancy is traumatizing. And of course, if your friend has an abortion, you should definitely comfort her and be there for her. And yes, it is understandable that she might need counseling because abortion is traumatizing and should never be taken lightly. I agree that Teen Vogue should not have posted that article in the lighthearted manner that it came across.

However, I also vehemently disagree with you. I disagree with word choice. I disagree with your fallacies. I disagree with you.

To begin, you are wildly incorrect to call the aborted fetus a baby. It is just false. From weeks 4-10, it is just a cluster of cells called an embryo. After that, it is called a fetus. Not until 37 weeks is the baby actually considered a baby and no state with restrictive abortion laws allows abortions after 28 weeks, well before the fetus is considered a baby.

Because you specifically said “baby” multiple times, you are deceiving your audience and yourself. You continue this as you refer to the “aborted babies” to be girls, and specifically, try to guilt the women who had the abortion using that explicit language.

They are not babies. They are fetuses, if not embryos.

Similarly, you call abortion the act of “destroy[ing] the most helpless of people” and consider the legality of abortion to be a human rights issue.

You’re right. It is a women’s rights issue. The women who are pregnant are the people. They have the right to end a pregnancy that could hurt them or end the pregnancy because they cannot support the child and they understand that there are 400,000 children in the United States already in foster care.

A fetus is not a helpless person. A woman who has had an abortion is a helpless person who just had to make a very, very hard decision.

Equally, you call abortion “the most invasive and degrading thing that could happen to a girl.” A woman can choose to have an abortion for many reasons, but one of them is rape. Rape can lead to one of the many, many reasons to have an abortion. Have you considered how extremely “invasive and degrading” rape is for a woman or man?

I cannot speak for those who have been raped or those who have had abortions, but I would be much less angry if you phrased your words more carefully, maybe calling abortion one of the most invasive and degrading things. A simple addition of three words would help your argument tremendously and cut out a fallacy or two.

And, one quick question: How does wearing an “F Uterus” pin make it clear that you had an abortion? How does a pin, with a Fallopian Tube in the shape of the middle finger, shout “I had an abortion and you should shame me!”?

Furthermore, you mention that this specific pin donates its funds to Planned Parenthood and then you move to comment that you cannot both support Planned Parenthood and your friend after she has had an abortion.

I will use your carefully chosen words to assume that you mean that Planned Parenthood is a corporation who makes money off giving abortions to helpless women who don’t know any better.

In reality, it is a nonprofit organization committed to helping women with their sexual health by giving STD tests and prescriptions for birth control.

You are quick to say that women should feel guilty for their abortions and regret them. You also claim that the reason they do not feel guilty post-abortion is because our society has desensitized abortions.

How is that possible when you are speaking about abortions like that? Our president has openly stated that there should be punishment for abortion and he has not spoken against the idea that abortion is murder.

We are not desensitized. We live in a society that will make you into a villain if you are open about having had an abortion. You are part of the reason that we are not desensitized to abortions. You are part of the reason that women feel guilty.

Women should not feel guilty after an abortion because it is an extremely hard decision to make. The process is not easy and the decision hurts, but any women who has an abortion is perfectly within her human rights to do so for the sake of herself, her family, and ultimately, the fetus.

Autumn, I disagree with you.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Sports

The Mets And Me

They may be the worst sometimes, but this baseball team has given me more than I could ask for.

204
Rich Schultz/Getty Images

On September 3rd, 2001, a sea of children littered my home's navy-carpeted den to watch baseball during my dad's 40th birthday extravaganza. A baseball game flickered on the TV, and a red and blue bubble of a scoreboard sat in the bottom right corner of the screen. The New York Mets and the Philadelphia Phillies were in a wild game at Veterans' Stadium. As I, a five-year-old boy with a jumble of curly blonde hair, sat in the back of the kid clump, I wondered which team I should root for. After a long debate with myself, I decided that I should root for the team that's winning (duh). But, as the ninth inning rolled around with the Phils maintaining a 7-5 lead, some magic occurred. The Mets put up five runs in one frame, stunning the Phillie fans in the room and winning the game 10-7.

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

Which BTS Member You Are Based On Your Star Sign

If you love BTS, I'm sure you relate to one or many of them in several ways. This star test will help you learn more about which member you are most connected to.

533
Which BTS Member You Are Based On Your Star Sign

Astrological signs tell a lot about a person. Do you ever wonder what your BTS bias star sign is? Is it the same as yours, or or are you more like one of the other amazing members? Take a look and find out what yours (and the members of Bangtan) says about you.

Keep Reading... Show less
Relationships

Hittin' the Road Playlist

With the end of August approaching more quickly than many of us would like, the preparation for school is happening in more ways than just one.

2827
http://cdn1.theodysseyonline.com/files/2014/08/11/635433794713320635180099351_road%20trip%20playlist.jpg

The car is all packed. The money you saved (and didn't spend online) from your summer internship is secured quietly in your bank account. The immediate reunion with your long-distance college friends is set. The real question on everyone's minds is: do you have the perfect melody to jam to as you journey back to school? 

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

20 Quotes That Will Make You Smile Today

Everyone could use more self-care and without the judgement...

4840
20 Quotes That Will Make You Smile Today

Welcome to a new day and a new opportunity to be our best selves. Here's a list of 20 quotes about self-care, self-love, positivity, and finding inspiration. Carry these quotes with you throughout your day for positive upliftment!

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

10 Small Reasons To Smile​

There's always a reason to be happy.

3864
10 Small Reasons To Smile​

It doesn't cost a thing - so smile.

Keep Reading... Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments