Stop Talking About The 'Race Card'
Politics and Activism

Stop Talking About The 'Race Card'

Why this phrase and associated attitudes are the biggest obstacles to progress on racial issues

Stop Talking About The 'Race Card'

Racial discussions have dominated public sphere in the news and on social media recently. Personally, I think they should have been more prominent sooner, but that's beside the point. One major statement I keep seeing from, mostly white, individuals is that bringing up racial issues or calling out instances of racism is "playing the race card." This is perhaps one of the least helpful and least productive responses that can be made when a group claims racism or oppression, and in fact it's this devaluing and denying of problems that leads to consequences such as riots and resentment.

Let's unpack the phrase, "playing the race card." First, it positions race as some sort of "token," something that can be used to gain an upper hand. This hasn't been true for minorities since the beginning, that they can use their race as some sort of valuable hand in the poker game of life. They have been enslaved, legally and then socially oppressed, and they experience racism every day in a world where they are "other." Though the law has removed a way to be upfront with discrimination and racism, and we have Affirmative Action (which is simply aiming to level the playing field, not give minorities an advantage as some people like to think), there is what is often called "subtle racism" today. That can be much harder to single out, but is very present and real to those groups which confront it in their daily interactions. I have already addressed some statistics associated with institutional racism and how it shows itself still in this society, but stats are only half of the story.

When we talk about racism, it is a very social and cultural concept. It involves people relating to the "other," or what they construct as "other." Therefore, to fully understand and recognize the presence of racism today, one would need to interact with affected groups, actively seek out information, listen to/ read about experiences or have encountered it themselves. For many white individuals, their privilege prevents them from seeing such issues, and therefore they are able to doubt their existence, significance in a larger context, and to lash out instead at the person pointing it out, telling them they are overreacting or looking for attention. Privilege does not mean people are given everything and don't work hard and have it easy, instead it means here that these people have the blessing of not having to consider how their skin color will affect how people see and treat them on a daily basis. White privilege varies when intersected with class and gender, as well as other identities, but a status as poor, for example, does not negate white privilege. Just as being wealthy and having rich privilege does not negate being a minority (Colin Kaepernick). Everyone's aspects of identity are at play at the same time, and they affect how one goes about life. It's unlikely that they can be separated out from experience. It's a privilege of those who do not experience the effects of generations of targeted racial, institutional mistreatment and abuse to say that a certain occurrence or incidence does not have anything to do with race. It is a privilege to see things as "color blind" and "not involving race." When there's people involved, particularly people of color, race is involved by virtue of them just being present. That is an effect of our still-segregated society today.

Because white individuals in general have this privilege, this leads to another part of the phrase, "race card." One concept I have encountered which explains why "race card" is almost always directed toward a minority as an accusation and not a white person is white purity. This is the notion that "white" is not a race. That it is somehow above race. That white people do not have a "race card" to play, mainly because this phrase was created by whites as backlash to racial social/ activist movements. One simple presentation of this concept in daily life, in our very language, are the phrases "white" and "non-white." People use these phrases to delineate between what is white and what is not white. The implication is that any drop of "color" contaminates whiteness and shoves a person into the "non-white" group. This might explain some of the reason why biracial individuals experience criticism from both races, particularly when they are partially white, and why individuals between cultures in the United States also experience conflict, tension and mistreatment.

Finally, the employment of this phrase has almost one essential purpose: to silence. This phrase is to minimize, deflect and redirect conversation about racial issues. It takes the attention away from the situation itself and points it instead toward the speaker themselves, trying to discredit them as over-dramatic, attention-seeking whiners. It is a personal attack of sorts that not only denies the issue, it denies the credibility and the grounds on which someone can call out racism. This is counterproductive, as it once again silences minorities as they have been for centuries, further incites resentment and anger toward the oppressing group, and upholds long-standing systematic racism. Not to mention that it is simply a shameful action to dictate to groups, who have issues you know absolutely nothing about and can't imagine being in their position, what is and is not problematic. Not only is it not something you have the ability and experience to decide, it may perhaps be extremely assumptive and arrogant to believe your experience is universal. To believe that because you don't see something as a racial issue and you don't see or experience racism, or that no one has "proven" it to you, that it somehow then doesn't exist. Or, even more absurd, that pointing out racism somehow makes the speaker racist against whites. This is essentially saying any labeling of something as "racist," is an attack on all whites, which basically admits whites are the main ones, and have been the main ones, exhibiting this racism.

Maybe, just maybe, "stop playing the race card" is a phrase that should be phased out of this discourse on race, racial issues and racism. It seems not to generate discussion or solutions in the least, but instead it serves as a verbal roadblock which further frustrates and oppresses the groups trying to call attention to important issues within this country and society. It ends discussion and pushes the problem aside. Though the United States has come a long way, there is still much work to be done. It will be much easier if everyone works together.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.

119 People Reveal How The Pandemic Has Affected Their Love Lives, And Honestly... Relatable

"I haven't been able to get out of the 'talking phase' with anyone."

The reality is, there's no part of life the pandemic hasn't affected. Whether it's your work life, your home life, your social life, or your love life, coronavirus (COVID-19) is wreaking havoc on just about everything — not to mention people's health.

When it comes to romance, in particular, people are all handling things differently and there's no "right way" of making it through, regardless of your relationship status (single, taken, married, divorced, you name it). So, some of Swoon's creators sought out to hear from various individuals on how exactly their love lives have been affected since quarantine began.

Keep Reading... Show less

I oftentimes (excessively) use the excuse of my job as a writer to justify my excessive spending habits.

I needed the new Huda Beauty palette before anyone else in the name of journalistic integrity. It was my job to test out the new Francis Kurkdjian fragrance to make sure I could tell people whether or not it was truly worth the splurge (it was).

Keep Reading... Show less

I remember the days where closet drinking before going to a party or bar was part of the night's itinerary. It was a requirement to have a good buzz flowing before calling the Uber to take you to that bar where you see everyone from your high school at. The pregames were the best part of the night, but it wasn't ever because of the alcohol, it was because of the atmosphere and those who were in it. The number of times I've heard "Wait, why aren't you drinking tonight? C'mon, get drunk with us" is endless, but think about it. Where were you when you were asked that? You were at the goddamn pregame and being there doesn't mean you need to be ripping shots. Being social doesn't require alcohol.

I asked 20 people how they cut back on alcohol while still being social.

Keep Reading... Show less

This Viral Miami University Instagram Page Features Stories Of The Victims Of Discrimination On Campus

There's a new wave of battles for change on Miami University's campus, and Dear Miami is at the root of the fuel to the fire.

There's a lot going on right now, and everything is extremely uncertain. Some of the largest and time-old issues we're facing heavily right now are the ones around human rights.

Keep Reading... Show less
Erikka Chowdhury

To all of those who don't know me, I'm an American girl with South Asian parents who have carved their own niche as immigrants in the USA.

Keep Reading... Show less

Listen, you can do whatever you want with your free time. It's yours to spend and you have free range. However, I hope you recognize that there are a ton of proactive things you can do right now instead of stalking your man's ex – yes, I know you do it becuase we are all guilty of it.

Take this time to research your privilege. There are always new things to learn and ways to deepen your understanding of yourself, this world, and your surroundings. We live in a multi-dimensional, ever-changing society that needs your help and your time. By that, I mean there are so many layers to each and every one of us, and with our physical, mental, spiritual, or emotional selves, we can create real, positive change.

Keep Reading... Show less

Whether you are quarantining away from your significant other because of coronavirus or separated by the country lines at this time, it's fair to say that long-distance relationships are tough no matter what. However, there are ways to show love from a distance whether that's through daily FaceTime calls, cute Snapchats, or sexy pics sent to them on their phone. You can brighten up their day even more with some of these unique gifts that can fit any price range and a variety of interests.

Keep Reading... Show less

Preview These Top Nordstrom Anniversary Sale 2020 Picks — From Luxury Purses To Skincare

Currently 3 million people viewing the Stella McCartney purse I absolutely must have.

Online shopping has been a guilty pleasure of ours for years, but now more than ever it's been a shopping lover's outlet for all our home redecorating projects and resort wear we're purchasing for that trip we had to cancel.

One of my favorite places to (virtually) window shop has always been Nordstrom. I admittedly can't afford to go on sprees there often, but I still get a high off of adding things to my cart I know I'll never actually end up buying. But sometimes, that's not enough — that's when I, like the masses of luxury-, beauty-, fashion-, and decor-lovers around the world count the days down to the annual Nordstrom Anniversary Sale.

Keep Reading... Show less

Rihanna is known for many things: her music, fashion, makeup, and now skincare. As a makeup artist myself, I can confidently say that she rocked the makeup world when she released her makeup line in 2017 and has been influencing the beauty world ever since.

Trying some of her makeup products myself, I know that she doesn't skimp on quality, and even though some of her products may be a little pricey, trust me, you get what you pay for.

Keep Reading... Show less
Facebook Comments