America Was Never Meant To Be A Direct Democracy
Start writing a post

The Problem With American Democracy Is That It Was Never Meant To Be A Democracy

The United States, along with a variety of other Western countries, suffers from a problem inherent within any representative or direct democracy.

The Problem With American Democracy Is That It Was Never Meant To Be A Democracy

The United States has had a number of names for its political system. Most recently, it's been "representative democracy." Interestingly enough, 200 years ago, when crafting the Constitution and Declaration of Independence, the Founding Fathers were struck with terror at the thought of a democracy. The most egregious element of popular democracy was "tyranny of the majority."

Tyranny of the majority is a philosophical argument used primarily in the formation of the United States government. After the failure of the Articles of Confederation, a delegation was tasked with drafting a new guiding document for the country, what we now know to be the U.S. Constitution. During the ratification process, three notable Founding Fathers — Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay — wrote a series of articles arguing to ratify the Constitution. These articles are commonly known as The Federalist Papers. These papers lay down the philosophical framework for the American constitutional system. They are meticulous, detailed, and explore the deep ends of governmental philosophy.

These Federalist Papers also outline tyranny of the majority. Federalist No. 51, written by either Alexander Hamilton or James Madison (historians are unsure of which founder wrote which exact articles), states, "If a majority be united by a common interest, the rights of the minority will be insecure." What they meant was that allowing the majority to rule (i.e. how rule is done within a democracy) allows the oppression of the minority. Ironically, at the time, the Founding Fathers weren't talking about racial, cultural, or ethnic minorities. Rather, they were defending the wealthy.

They believed that allowing majority rule would create votes to take from the wealthy, destroy what the wealthy had, and effectively oppress their rights. It is likely that Madison and Hamilton were right. They used this logic to argue against a democracy and instead for a system of checks and balances and delegation. This system of checks and balances would limit each branch of government. Moreover, they believed that delegates would limit the influence of majorities in two ways: (1) centering the vote of geographical areas to one representative, and (2) the expectation that elected representatives would be the best of people (most intelligent, honest, driven, etc.).

The government created by the Federalists is known as a Republic, not a democracy. The Founders instituted numerous controls to limit the power of the people. Some of the founders even believed that the people should have even less of a say due to their lack of experience and intelligence.

But with the initial passing of the Constitution came a third limit to majority power: Senators. At the time, Senators were not elected through the popular vote, rather by state legislatures. This meant that the House of Representatives was elected by the people, and the United States Senate was chosen by the State governments. The Senate, the Federalists thought, could be an effort to block ridiculous bills that may originate in the House from the people. Another example of a defense mechanism against "mistakes by the people" is the electoral college.

But in the 19th century, with the Progressive movement gaining traction, the 17th Amendment was instituted, leading to the direct election of senators. The power was stripped away from state legislatures and instead given to the people. While this may sound merry, it has been a turn for the worse.

Because the Federalists were right: the general public tends to be uninformed, the general public tends to lack knowledge on critical issues, and frankly, the general public is not suited to deal with the growing problems of this country. The Senate exists to serve as a check on the House, to ensure that the people and the representatives do not get out of hand with legislation. But with the direct election of Senators, that is no longer the case.

This, along with efforts to eliminate the electoral college brings us closer and closer to become a democracy. As a country, we have already strayed from the principles of a Republic. The term "representative democracy" has only recently been coined. It did not exist at the time of the founders because there was almost no democracy. The Progressive Era changed that for the worse. The ultimate problem with American democracy is that we were never established as one, becoming one would hurt us, and yet we are getting closer and closer to being a democracy.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Health and Wellness

I Sat Down With An Endocrinologist To Ask All My Questions About Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome

There are so many moving parts of hormonal health, so I went to an expert.

Anjanette Tan

Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome (PCOS) is an autoimmune disease that impacts approximately 1 in 10 women. Any woman who has PCOS can attest to the fact that no two cases are the same — there are so many aspects of hormonal health that can impact a woman's reproductive health! For many, PCOS is a trial and error condition, with many doctors' appointments depending on the stage of life the woman is in.

This week I sat down with Dr. Anjanette Tan to get the expert opinion on all my PCOS questions. Dr. Tan is a board-certified endocrinology who's worked in private practices since 2004. She currently works at the Diabetes and Thyroid Center of Fort Worth, one of the largest all-endocrine practices in the area, where she is the managing partner and head of clinical research.

Keep Reading... Show less

- Since I can remember, I've always been a light sleeper, with the quietest sounds waking me up, and I regularly wake up with the sun.

- While talking to a gynecologist friend of mine, she mentioned the importance of using an eye mask for quality sleep, which regulates hormonal levels.

- I was serendipitously sent the Crane & Canopy Silk Sleep Mask almost right after that conversation and was honestly reluctant to try it after testing other sleep masks that felt uncomfortable and irritated my skin.

- This sleep mask was extremely comfortable, and for the first time in nearly a decade, I slept in far past when I usually do on the weekends and woke up feeling more refreshed than I can remember — I've worn it nearly every night since then.

The older I get, it seems that sleep becomes an increasingly important topic of conversation amongst my friends and me. Yes, of course we complain about how tired we always are, but the pattern seemed to be a lack of sleep on the weekdays followed by late nights and sleeping in on the weekends without any solution.

Keep Reading... Show less

I'll never forget the day that someone told me these words: "Madison, I think you're a good friend to everyone but yourself." I stood there completely in awe of that statement. Before that day, I never really thought about being a friend to myself, and at the time, I didn't really know what it meant. Now, I realize that you can't fully be there for other people unless you're there for yourself, too. You can't show up for others until you're willing to show up for yourself.

Here are five things everyone should learn in order to be a better friend to themselves. These steps are hard, but they're so worth it.

Keep Reading... Show less

It's no secret that social media can be harmful to our mental health. The barrage of heavily edited photos of Instagram models that we see every day only fuels our insecurities. There is a good side to social media, though. It allows us to keep up with friends and family across the globe. Plus, it provides a platform for mental health experts. Listed below are five therapists on Instagram who will fill your feed with motivational quotes and positive infographics.

Keep Reading... Show less

Last week, Netflix released its original film "The Devil All the Time," based on the 2011 novel of the same name. Directed by Antonio Campos, the film boasts an all-star cast including Bill Skarsgard, Robert Pattinson, Riley Keough, and Tom Holland.

Keep Reading... Show less
Health and Wellness

In Honor of PCOS Awareness Month, I Researched 25 Things About The Autoimmune Disease

Ongoing research is further promoting the fact that engaging in a proper diet and exercise regimen can alleviate many symptoms!


Polycystic Ovary Syndrome (PCOS) is a common endocrine disorder that affects young women, especially those of reproductive age. Women with PCOS often exhibit symptoms ranging from increased levels of the male hormone androgen along with cysts in their ovaries. However, ongoing research is further promoting the fact that engaging in a proper diet and exercise regimen can alleviate many symptoms! Here are 25 things I found out about PCOS.

Keep Reading... Show less
Health and Wellness

To The Boy Who Said I Was 'Unlovable' Because Of My Back Rolls, My Body Is NOT A Problem

I realized I need to stop blaming myself for staying single. The problem wasn't me. It was you.

Photo by Artem Kovalev on Unsplash

I told you I was going to be okay if you said what was on your mind, but honestly, nothing could've prepared me for the words that came out of your mouth. After getting off of the phone with you, I burst into tears. Those words shattered my heart and continuously repeated in my head.

Keep Reading... Show less

Whether the stress of adjusting to online school or losing a job is getting you down, we all know that the effects of this pandemic have been nothing but stressful. While everyone is focusing on not getting sick, finding a job, and keeping up with school, no one has really found time to decompress. High levels of continued stress can not only lead to physical health issues but mental health issues as well. To make it a little easier, here are some ways you can de-stress during a time like this while staying safe and socially distanced.

Keep Reading... Show less

I used to regard loneliness as this misshapen emptiness — one that existed for the sole purpose of being temporarily filled by other human beings, ones who we convince ourselves to make some curious, broken, part of us a bit more normal. A bit more whole. As simple as A + B, to evade loneliness, be incessantly social.

Keep Reading... Show less

6 Jhene Aiko Songs You Need To Add To Your Playlist ASAP

There's nothing toxic about knowing your worth and Jhene proves that.

@jheneaiko on Instagram

These are some songs that give you a good idea of what type of artist Jhene is from all four of her respective albums.

Keep Reading... Show less
Facebook Comments