Wondering How Police Get Away With Murder?
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

Wondering How Police Get Away With Murder?

Why can police shoot rubber bullets and canisters of tear gas into unarmed crowds? Why don't police see consequences for the violence they use against unarmed civilians? The answer to all of these questions is qualified immunity.

Wondering How Police Get Away With Murder?
Photo by Life Matters from Pexels

The Supreme Court created qualified immunity in 1967, "describing it as a modest exception for public officials who had acted in 'good faith' and believed their conduct was authorized by law."

Harlow v. Fitzgerald expanded the protections offered by qualified immunity. Harlow was a White House aide during the Nixon administration and Fitzgerald was a former Air Force contractor, who claimed that he was fired for giving a whistle-blowing testimony to Congress.

The Supreme Court opinion was in favor of Harlow, expanding qualified immunity from an exception that protected public officials who had acted in good faith to an extensive shield for public officials that had purposefully violated constitutional rights.

This change requires that those who have had their rights violated by public officials must prove that their rights were "clearly established." The Court says that this means the victim must use a previously decided case with similar circumstances as precedents, making a victim winning a suit against police close to impossible.

Application of Qualified Immunity

In 2004, Malaika Brookes was pulled over for speeding while she was driving her son to school. The officers that pulled her over issued her a speeding ticket, which Malaika refused to sign, later saying that she was under the impression that signing would be an admission of guilt when she didn't believe she had done anything wrong.

A police sergeant arrived and told Malaika that if she did not exit her vehicle, force would be applied. The officers demonstrated a taser shock, and Malaika informed them that she was pregnant. She was then tased three times within a minute.

Malaika sued for emotional and physical scars, leading to a split decision issued by a San Francisco federal appeals court, "finding excessive force was used, but saying the officers could not be sued because 'it was not sufficiently clear' in the law at the time that what they were doing was a constitutional violation."

In 2014, Melanie Kelsay was at the pool with her children and a friend. While there, her friend came up behind her and pretended he was going to throw her into the pool. Onlookers interpreted this as a domestic assault and called the police.

When the group left the pool, officers were waiting for them. Melanie repeatedly attempted to tell the police that no assault had occurred. The police arrested her friend and Melanie was arguing with Officer Ernst when she saw that her daughter was having an argument with a bystander.

Melanie moved to check on her daughter and Ernst grabbed her arm. He released her and she told him she needed to check on her daughter. She moved toward her daughter again and Ernst ran up behind her, grabbing her and slamming her into the ground. This knocked Melanie unconscious and broke her collarbone. She was then arrested and handcuffed, despite complaints of pain.

Melanie sued Officer Ernst and an appellate court decided that Ernst was covered by qualified immunity, "holding that it was not 'clearly established' that using a takedown maneuver on a suspect who walks away was unlawful -- simply because there was no prior case with sufficiently similar facts."

Qualified immunity has been developed by the courts into a shield that protects public officials from being sued for their violations of constitutional rights. This shield allows police to repeatedly tase a pregnant woman, because it was not clear to them that the action was unconstitutional. It allows police to cause significant bodily harm to an unarmed woman trying to check on her daughter, because there was no prior case with similar facts.

Qualified immunity allows police and other pubic officials to get away with any crime against civilians that they haven't been punished for in the past.

What Can You Do?

If you want to take action to encourage the end of qualified immunity, you can sign petitions like this one and this one.

If you want to go further, you can find your representative here and tell them that you support the Ending Qualified Immunity Act through an email or call.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Student Life

College 101: How To Ease The Back To School Blues

Getting back into the school groove when you just can't seem to let go of summer.

Beyond The States

With fall classes just beginning, many of us find ourselves struck with summer withdrawals. Especially for those who refrained from taking courses over the summer, it can be quite difficult to get back in the swing of things. Fortunately, there are various ways to help make the transition back to college as smooth as possible.

Keep Reading... Show less
Dating Apps

We Met At A Bar

Salvage what you can; if you can't, it's alright to walk away.

We Met At A Bar
Anne Waldon

We met at a bar.

Keep Reading... Show less

The Mets And Me

They may be the worst sometimes, but this baseball team has given me more than I could ask for.

Rich Schultz/Getty Images

On September 3rd, 2001, a sea of children littered my home's navy-carpeted den to watch baseball during my dad's 40th birthday extravaganza. A baseball game flickered on the TV, and a red and blue bubble of a scoreboard sat in the bottom right corner of the screen. The New York Mets and the Philadelphia Phillies were in a wild game at Veterans' Stadium. As I, a five-year-old boy with a jumble of curly blonde hair, sat in the back of the kid clump, I wondered which team I should root for. After a long debate with myself, I decided that I should root for the team that's winning (duh). But, as the ninth inning rolled around with the Phils maintaining a 7-5 lead, some magic occurred. The Mets put up five runs in one frame, stunning the Phillie fans in the room and winning the game 10-7.

Keep Reading... Show less

Which BTS Member You Are Based On Your Star Sign

If you love BTS, I'm sure you relate to one or many of them in several ways. This star test will help you learn more about which member you are most connected to.

Which BTS Member You Are Based On Your Star Sign

Astrological signs tell a lot about a person. Do you ever wonder what your BTS bias star sign is? Is it the same as yours, or or are you more like one of the other amazing members? Take a look and find out what yours (and the members of Bangtan) says about you.

Keep Reading... Show less

Hittin' the Road Playlist

With the end of August approaching more quickly than many of us would like, the preparation for school is happening in more ways than just one.


The car is all packed. The money you saved (and didn't spend online) from your summer internship is secured quietly in your bank account. The immediate reunion with your long-distance college friends is set. The real question on everyone's minds is: do you have the perfect melody to jam to as you journey back to school? 

Keep Reading... Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments