The Dangers Of Politicizing Justice Scalia's Death | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

The Dangers Of Politicizing Justice Scalia's Death

“These are responsibilities that I take seriously, as should everyone. They’re bigger than any one party. They are about our democracy.”

7
The Dangers Of Politicizing Justice Scalia's Death
CNN

The Supreme Court’s outspoken conservative voice, Justice Antonin Scalia, died in his sleep last week at age 79. This leaves a vacancy in the high court that must be filled.

President Obama immediately commented on the Justice’s sudden death. His remarks were terse—mostly noting Justice Scalia’s character and accomplishments. He praised the Justice as a “brilliant legal mind” and as someone who “influenced a generation of judges, lawyers and students.”

The president did briefly address the judicial and political aspects and implications of Justice Scalia’s passing. He announced his intention to nominate a successor and asserted, “There will be plenty of time for me to do so [appoint a successor] and for the Senate to fulfill its responsibility—to give that person a fair hearing and a timely vote.”

If the previous remark was a loving nudge to Senate Republicans, then the subsequent sentences were blatant jabs: “These are responsibilities that I take seriously, as should everyone. They’re bigger than any one party. They are about our democracy.”

Here’s the president’s full (yet succinct) statement on Justice Scalia’s death:

Since the president said he would nominate a successor, it will be up to the GOP-led Senate to either confirm or reject President Obama’s nominee.

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) has stated, “The American people should have a voice in the selection of their next Supreme Court Justice. Therefore, this vacancy should not be filled until we have a new president.”

Since Mitch McConnell is the Senate majority leader, he sets the schedule for Congress’ upper chamber. Considering his statement—along with the congressional Republicans’ history of recalcitrance toward President Obama—the prominent Republican seems to be foreshadowing a manufactured vote delay, essentially putting off the confirmation vote until a new president takes office. Thus, that president would make the nomination instead.

The problem here is that it will take 11 months for the next president to fulfill that responsibility. During that time, the Supreme Court will have 8 Justices—four leaning liberal and four leaning conservative. This makes 4 - 4 decisions seem rather plausible.

In the case of a 4 - 4 Supreme Court decision, the ruling from the lower court is upheld and no precedent is set. The law remains unsettled. Decisions resulting in unsettled law are likely to clog up the legal system and keep legislation on shaky ground.

There are several upcoming consequential cases for the high court to hear, which could have drastic consequences if no precedent is set. These cases involve issues such as abortion rights and immigration, among others; Vox has a brief, yet informative article outlining these cases and their implications.

When one can virtually predict Supreme Court decisions based on Justices’ ideologies, it’s evident that Washington’s polarization has leaked into our high court. This is especially disconcerting since the Judiciary is generally seen as the institution that should be above politics.

While the GOP contends that the timing of an election year precludes a Senate vote, don’t they recall that Justice Anthony Kennedy was confirmed in 1988? An election year. So what makes this different?

The GOP argues that President Obama has already chosen two Supreme Court Justices, essentially imposing an imaginary quota.

Guess what? Elections have consequences. If the president were a Republican, would the GOP really relinquish the right to choose another Justice because they felt it was unfair?

You’re damn right they wouldn’t.

I understand that I seem a bit harsh on congressional Republicans right now, but this should be a nonpartisan issue. If a Republican were in office with nearly a year left in his or her presidency, they would be just as justified in appointing a successor as President Obama. This is about the final arbiter on legislation in our country. Not partisanship.

Congressional GOPers can reject President Obama’s nomination if they wish. But it would be an insult to the American people and to our republic if they simply table the matter and allow the high court to hang dry with only eight Justices for 11 months.

It would also reinforce the hazardous precedent that politics come first, country second.

Even in our high court.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Health and Wellness

10 Hygiene Tips For All College Athletes

College athletes, it's time we talk about sports hygiene.

1981
Woman doing pull-ups on bars with sun shining behind her.

I got a request to talk about college athletes hygiene so here it is.

College athletes, I get it, you are busy! From class, to morning workouts, to study table, to practice, and more. But that does not excuse the fact that your hygiene comes first! Here are some tips when it comes to taking care of your self.

Keep Reading...Show less
Jenna Pizzi and her mom smiling by a waterfront with a historic ship in the background.
Jenna Pizzi

There is always a time in the semester when you have about three papers, four tests, five assignments and two projects due within the same time period. Isn't that just the best?

It's almost as if the professors all plot against you just to make college even more stressful than it already is. No matter how many people try to make you feel better, no one ever compares to your mom. Moms always know exactly what to say.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

7 Jobs Your Roommate Has

She's got your back with everything that college throws at you.

1919
Cristina Yang and Meredith Grey in scrubs sit against a wall, smiling and enjoying a break.

If you are anything like my roommate and I, you have a friendship with your roomie. You’re lucky to have gotten a roommate that is easy to get along with and more importantly cool to live with. Whether you found her on Facebook or went random, a roommate is a big part of life in college. This list goes through some of the jobs that a roommate has that help you get through college.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

35 Things I Wish I Learned In My Freshman Year Of College

Just some relatable college student advice! Yes, you aren’t the only one!

1591
Towson University
YouTube

Freshman year can either be the greatest year, or the roughest year. It depends on your transition and how you adjust. For me, freshman year in college was one of the best years of my life. However, looking back, there are a few things that I wish I learned.

Now that I am a sophomore, I can finally do things a little differently. Here are a few things that I wish I learned my freshman year of college!

Keep Reading...Show less
Woman in field with a red heart-shaped balloon under a colorful sky.

Being single can be great and awful at the same time. Yeah, it's awesome to have time to yourself to figure out who you are and make your own decisions. It would also be nice to have someone to go through life with, but it needs to be the right person. I haven't found that person yet and here's a few reasons why.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments