What Gaslighting Isn't
Start writing a post

You may have seen the term 'gaslighting' being thrown around lately, perhaps attached to an article that warns of the dangers of this phenomenon. This term has it's origins in a play from 1938 called "Gas Light". Since we are going to examine what gaslighting isn't, you could click here and get a decent enough explanation for what it is. Gas-lighting as a specific phenomenon of long-term manipulation among romantic partners is being interpreted more broadly to be something that occurs even in short-term social interactions. The purpose of this article is to make sure we understand what gaslighting isn't and to put to rest many of the biased and skewed interpretations of it.

If you read enough gaslighting articles or scroll through the search results of a simple google search for gaslighting, you quickly begin to see a trend. If we are to trust the majority of perspectives in these articles, women seem to be the primary victims of gaslighting, with narcissistic men being the victimizer. Part of this is because studies have shown that narcissism tends to show up in men more than women, and narcissism is the primary trait that fuels gaslighting and other manipulative behaviors. However, men clearly do not have a monopoly on narcissism or rewriting reality to suit our selfish needs. Women indeed have their own subjective realities just as men do, and women can indeed be narcissistic. However, there's a difference between pathological manipulation and honest disagreement between two human beings.

Almost all arguments between human beings are because someone has a different point of view about something, it's the clashing of two subjective interpretations of an event. The fact is, everyone has a subjective truth they want to convince others to believe. This is why religious people go out and minister to non-believers. This is why debates are important in understanding societal issues. Varying subjective realities are the truth of human interactions. Persuading others to understand and believe our subjective truths is an unspoken fact of every social interaction. It is one of the primary reasons why we communicate with one another. Having a genuine, different opinion about an issue or an event is not gaslighting, even though many articles have begun to argue just that. Disagreeing about social justice issues does not necessarily mean that you are pathologically invalidating someone's subjective experience in order to make them doubt their own experience. Labeling disagreement in this context as gaslighting seems to be another method of shutting down conversation and smearing social justice skeptics as pathological social deviants.

Gaslighting is a type of long-term manipulation that seems to mostly be talked about as a pop-psychology topic. I think if I were to give my own quick, and concise definition for gaslighting, I would say it is the conscious manipulation and control of another person's perspective for unethical reasons over a long period of time. However, manipulation itself isn't necessarily a bad thing. Manipulation has a negative connotation but education, therapy, and parenting are all forms of manipulation. Manipulation becomes a bad thing if your reasons are ignoble, this is the most important distinction. If you suspect your partner is gaslighting you, then you have already "won". Gaslighting that is recognized isn't gaslighting at all. Since gaslighting is a conscious manipulation designed to warp your perspective of reality, if it's recognized, then it is unsuccessful. This is assuming that you are actually correct in your assessment. With the broadening definition for what gaslighting is, I suspect the false positive rate has increased exponentially. People forget that they themselves are often the ones that are wrong.

Do you want to avoid gaslighting? Be skeptical, and hold true to what you believe. Consider other people's perspectives if they offer clear and convincing evidence and a persuasive argument. If you shape your understanding of reality on anything other than these standards, then you are probably going to be a target for manipulation one day by someone. Accomplished liars always take into consideration how you think, and will exploit that. They take notice of the things that you have a soft spot for and will no doubt use that against you. However, it should probably make you feel better that most people aren't smart enough or motivated enough to really pull off gaslighting with any real success, because it is such a long-term process. True narcissistic personality disorder is also quite rare, with probably no more than 1% of the general population fitting the actual diagnostic criteria. Having said all this, however, victims of abuse are a more delicate matter. I recommend seeking professional help in actual traumatic cases such as an abusive relationship where such manipulation occurred. Don't go to the internet for help, please seek a professional with a specialty in abuse and trauma.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.

My obsession with country music is easily one of my best personality traits.

I've grown up on country music, and it's always been a huge part of my life. I remember the day that my mom bought me my first country CD. Since that day, I've been hooked. I still watch the Country Music Awards faithfully each year. My fun fact for syllabus week is almost always related to my love of country music.

Keep Reading... Show less
Swoon

The Definitive List Of 6 Cartoon Animal Men You Can Find Attractive Without Being A Furry

And no, Kovu isn't on this list because "The Lion King II" shouldn't really be a movie.

48916
Disney

It's the age-old question: why did they make this cartoon animal so attractive?

OK, so maybe not age-old, but if you claim haven't been attracted to at least one of these characters (and you're attracted to men), you're lying. Each one was given a personality and characterization that makes viewers at home reevaluate their standards. But then comes the follow up: cartoons aside, does this make me a furry? And girls, gays, and theys I am here today to relieve you of that question, because if he is on this list, your answer is simply no, you are not.

Keep Reading... Show less

Breakfast is my favorite meal of the day. When I'm craving something sweet in the morning, my go-to is Ethan's vegan pancake recipe.

Keep Reading... Show less
Adulting

Ask Your BFF These 20 Questions To See If They Know You As Well As You THINK That They Do

Ask your best friend these basic questions to see just how well they know you.

19784

My best friend has been in my life since we were 3 years old, now that we are adults now, I'd like to ask her these questions to see how well she knows me.

Keep Reading... Show less
Entertainment

8 TV Shows To Binge On Netflix Over Thanksgiving Break

These 8 shows will make your Quarantine-Friendly Thanksgiving break fun!

13487

As assignments are piling up and stress is getting to everyone, thinking of the silver lining of Thanksgiving Break looms in the distance. A time to recharge, eat some good food, and get those Black Friday sales (online of course) is just what we all need right about now. And since the pandemic is spiking again people are going to need to find something to do while not going out. So, since I've watched an unhealthy amount of television I thought I'd compile a list of some of my favorite Netflix shows that you can binge over break!

Keep Reading... Show less
Lifestyle

Let's Not Let Black Friday Overlook Thanksgiving

Oftentimes, Thanksgiving gets overpowered by Black Friday sales. This year, let's make an effort to appreciate what we are grateful for.

9616

November 26 is a day dedicated to being grateful for the things in your life that you appreciate. It can be easy to forget the true meaning of holidays since the decorations and events are fun yet distracting nonetheless.

Keep Reading... Show less
Swoon

77 Questions To Ask The Other Person Before Getting Into A Relationship With Them

Know what you're getting yourself into first. You won't regret it.

6925
Photo by René Ranisch on Unsplash

Surprises are great in a relationship. They keep things interesting. For example, when your partner says, "Surprise! There's a warrant out for my arrest," or "My crazy ex sent me a death threat and drained my bank account," or "I wake up at 5 am... every morning. "

Keep Reading... Show less
Facebook Comments