A Review on Martha Hall Kelly's 'Lilac Girls'
Start writing a post

A Review on Martha Hall Kelly's 'Lilac Girls'

Motives, Emotions, and 'How?'

A Review on Martha Hall Kelly's 'Lilac Girls'

A relative of mine had been raving about this book to me for weeks and finally lent it to me about a week ago. I love historical-fiction and history in general, which many of you may have guessed from reading my previous book reviews, so I took the suggestion (and the book). While the title and cover photo may have you thinking this is some sort of sweet little tale about three gal pals during WWII, the inside flap doesn’t even cover the true darkness of this story.

The plot centers around three female characters: Caroline, an American socialite, Francophone and charity-organizer extraordinaire; Herta Oberheuser, a German doctor who experiments on prisoners at Ravensbruck, an all-women’s concentration camp; and Kasia, a Polish teenager who once worked for the Underground, but was caught and taken to Ravensbruck with her sister and mother. The novel is based on events that really did happen, with characters like Caroline Ferriday and her parents, and Herta Oberheuser and her mother who had actually existed. Kasia and her sister were not flesh and blood women, but they were based on two sisters who had been imprisoned at Ravensbruck during the time period.

The novel focuses on motives, which brings an interesting perspective to the plot. Especially Herta, who is simply someone you want to see in jail for the rest of her natural born life, however her reasoning is so strange, that sometimes I found myself wondering ‘how?' instead of 'why?'. This aspect is what I love most about this novel. It forces you to think about the decisions people made at the time, the possible factors that may have had had something to do with their actions, and the consequences of those choices years after the damage has been done. It's not just that Caroline is an upper-class woman obsessed with charity work and can never seem to find 'the one', but that she has been born into a longstanding legacy of active, independent women who aren't into simply sitting around and doing nothing. It's not just that Kasia has become increasingly angry and resentful after being rescued from Ravensbruck, but that she is suffering from invisible wounds that refuse to heal from a nightmare brought to life. And it's not just that Herta is a horrible human being, but that she has her own dark experiences that have contributed to her cold and seemingly robotic frame of mind, worsened only by her acceptance, and even support, of the atrocities and prejudices committed and perpetuated by her country's leaders and citizens. Do not, however, think that the author is making excuses for her. You'll go from a slight disdain of Herta, to just absolute loathing. The focus on motives gives nuance to this novel that typical 'war stories' often lack.

I have to admit, this novel was hard to read at times. I do not recommend this for anyone who is squeamish, especially early on in the book, there are scenes that may be very uncomfortable for some readers. It's a bit of a trigger read, for lack of a better term.

The story is very interesting, however, and very well done. It isn't just about war, but also about what comes after it, after the terror and the pain and the horror of it all. It isn't just 'and they all lived happily ever after when the war ended,' like many novels about the time period, but rather about the process of healing, of finding what you really want in life, and that nothing truly stays in the past. And besides, the ending is pretty dang satisfying, so even if you don't exactly love the characters, you'll at least love the ending of "Lilac Girls.”

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.

Panic! At The Disco Announces Breakup After 19 Years

Band Makes Breakup Announcement Official: 'Will Be No More'

panic at the disco

It's the end of an era. Originally formed in 2004 by friends in Las Vegas, Panic! At The Disco is no more.

Brendon Urie announced on Instagram that the band will be coming to an end after the upcoming Europe tour. He said that he and his wife are expecting a baby, and the life change weighed heavily in his mind to come to this decision. "Sometimes a journey must end for a new one to begin," he said.

Keep Reading... Show less
Content Inspiration

Top 3 Response Articles of This Week

Odyssey's response writer community is growing- read what our new writers have to say!


Each week, more response writers are joining the Odyssey community. We're excited to spotlight their voices on as they engage in constructive dialogue with our community. Here are the top three response articles of last week:

Keep Reading... Show less

To Mom

There are days when you just need your mom

To Mom

There really is no way to prepare yourself for the loss of someone. Imagine that someone being the one who carried you for 9th months in their belly, taught you how to walk, fought with you about little things that only a mother and daughter relationship could understand. You can have a countless number of father figures in your life, but really as my mom always said, " you only get one mom."

Keep Reading... Show less

The Way People In Society are Dating is Why I Don't Date

I need someone to show that they want me for me, not that they're using me to chase the idea of being in a relationship.

The Way People In Society are Dating is Why I Don't Date

You hear your phone go off. He's asking you to hang out. Then, of course, you get the advice of your friends to decipher this text. Is it just hanging out or is it more than hanging out? You've probably done this at least once in your life or at least seen a tweet where someone posted their screenshots with a potential love interest.

Keep Reading... Show less
Student Life

Winter Break As Told By 'Friends'

Is a month at home too much to handle?


If you're anything like me, winter break is a much-needed light at the end of the tunnel after a long, stressful semester. Working hard for 15 weeks can really take a toll on a person mentally, physically AND emotionally. It's a nice change of pace to be back at home with your family and friends, but after a couple weeks, it can get, well... boring.

Keep Reading... Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments