Is Utilitarianism A Silent Killer?
Start writing a post

Has man always sought the knowledge to tell the difference between right and wrong? Humanity never started off with such knowledge, but yet we have evolved into a being of intellectualism. From a beast on all fours, to a morally just being on two feet. As the human race, we can clearly tell how far man has come. But does every man, woman and child understand the differences of good and evil? Or do we blindly assume that everything is okay in the world and go on living our lives because nothing else matters? Each and every person on this big blue planet has a moral compass telling them what to do, even though most of these compasses have our travelers lost.

John Stuart Mill is a philosopher who brought Utilitarianism to the light of the world in the late 1800’s. We could describe this as one of the moral paths a person could possibly take in their life time. Here is why most people chose this over any of the other ethical choices. Utilitarianism is the moral theory that an action is morally right if and only if it is productive of the most utility (happiness, pleasure) for the greatest number of persons. To most, that sounds like something every typical person should do at any given time; especially when it involves a large number of people being happy.

Now, let us take a couple of steps back and talk about the father of Utilitarianism. Jeremy Bentham founded this term years before Mills took the reins. He was also the man who created the Hedonistic Calculus. A system to calculate the most pleasure in any given outcome and makes it easier for Utilitarian’s to make a decision in any situation. Therefore, making this moral term to be more priceless. Having two famous philosophers and a calculation system should be enough to make this path a moral gold mine, even though you’ll lose all sense of emotional attachment to people by doing so. Most people are now questioning the last statement they read and are now trying to figure out any flaws with being a Utilitarian. Well, let us break this entire thing down even further, so we can get to the root of evil.

First, we can start by breaking down the true meaning of what a Utilitarian really is. It's fine to want the most good for humanity, but what they really want is to only count every person as a number. As a whole they don’t see people as human beings, but as living digits that tell them what they can and can’t do to make them happier. Doesn’t that seem a little weird that they want to bring about the most good for people, but can only see you as a pool of numbers and calculations?

Secondly, they can’t and will not do anything that doesn’t bring about the most pleasure in a group. Meaning, they couldn’t kill an ex-convict who was going to kill again; if it meant the family of that person would be mortified and sad for the rest of their lives. Which is a huge flaw and contradiction to the whole backbone of what Utilitarianism is all about. Most people would be concerned if someone who followed this ethical path took matters into their own hands and tried to save a group of people from a serial killer. The outcome could be any unknown and maybe even a harmful answer. Especially when they only see you as a number of pleasure and pain and nothing more.

Lastly, the Hedonistic Calculus is a tool that aids them when they need to figure out which path has the most pleasure at the end. Even though that could take minutes and maybe even hours to calculate for any given event or moment. Shouldn’t the answer to any given disaster be to do what is good and nothing else? Why do you need to calculate what everyone wants and hates to understand what should be done for a situation? At any given moment innocent people can be in harm’s way, but you are crunching the numbers and trying to figure out what you should do.

We could even add insult to injury by saying that robots do this kind of work all of the time. Inventors have created AI that processes different scenarios and events, then it crunches the numbers and looks for a good outcome to that same event. One of these robotic beings is Apple’s (Siri), why do I need a human being to crunch the numbers; when my phone seems capable of doing it for me? There are even more robots that use the same category, one for instance, are robots in healthcare. They give doctors routes to go and different ideas on how to do a procedure accurately, which is still something that doesn’t need to be done to get a great outcome.

If you care enough about your well-being or you want to choose outcomes for the greater good, I would suggest that this is not the philosophy you want to live by or die by for that matter. If you choose this moral path, get ready to waste your precious time calculating people as numbers and not enough of it saving the people you care most about.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Photo by Jonathan Borba on Unsplash

I love listening to Christmas music just as much as the next person, but when I turn on my local holiday radio station each year, it just feels repetitive. No hate to musicians like Burl Ives or Nat King Cole, but Christmas music needs an update. Personally, I'm tired of the same "Let It Snow" and "Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas". So plug in your Christmas tree, make some hot cocoa, and listen to these amazing (and updated) holiday songs.

Keep Reading... Show less

With the holidays right around the corner, there are many things to look forward to. Time with family, friends, great food, overall seasonal joy... And now the fragrances from Jennifer Lopez.

Keep Reading... Show less

10 Christmas Songs For Your Festive Playlist

I have no shame in starting to feel festive super early.


All of these songs are definitely popular. However, I have the strong opinion that having the songs on your Christmas playlist be popular is extremely important. Having everyone sing to the songs is most of the fun; it adds to the festivity of whatever you're doing.

Personally, I love to bake cookies and hum along as I cannot sing and no one should ever hear me. Whatever you do for the holidays, enjoy your festive time and the season!

Keep Reading... Show less

10​​ Songs That Made It Onto My November Playlist

Another month of finding new music during unusual times


A new month means new music! Like each month, I've collected my top 10 new songs or discoveries into a playlist. This November didn't have too many new releases, however, I did find a few and a couple of new discoveries.

Keep Reading... Show less

7 Christmas Ideas For Couples That You Can Still Do In The Middle Of A Global Pandemic

The holidays are such a fun time to celebrate with loved ones; here are a few activities to consider being a part of during this Christmas season.

Photo by Hannah Busing on Unsplash

Whether it is a night in at home baking sweet Christmas themed goodies for Santa, or a night out exploring lit up neighborhoods, the holiday season should always be taken advantage of for cute activities!

Keep Reading... Show less

Every Track On Ariana Grande's 'Positions' Album Ranked

Ariana Grande has achieved major success with her new album and we're ranking every track.


Ariana Grande surprised fans in October, tweeting that her new album was being released. What followed was yet another number one peak on the Billboard 200 albums chart. The album's title track and lead single, "Positions," also hit number one on the Billboard Hot 100 chart.

With "Positions," Grande took a much more light-hearted approach than the confessional nature of its predecessor, "Thank U, Next." It was a welcome and refreshing change of pace. Now that the album has been out for a solid month, it's the perfect time to see how the songs rank.

Keep Reading... Show less

In the four Christmas' that I have spent with my boyfriend, I have realized one thing: boys are hard to shop for. Each year I have to rack my brain for gift ideas because when I ask my boyfriend what he wants for Christmas, he always says something along the lines of "nothing," which as a girl is hard to fathom since I literally give him a list each year before Black Friday.

After hours each year scouring the internet for the perfect Christmas gifts to get my boyfriend, I have come up with a pretty long and inclusive list. To help those girlfriends going through the same thing, I decided to put together some of the best gifts I have come across.

Keep Reading... Show less
Health and Wellness

10 Ways You Can Safely Enjoy The Holidays During The Pandemic

Even with a pandemic, there are still ways to celebrate.


It's almost December, which means that it's almost time for the biggest holiday season to arrive! However, it doesn't mean that COVID-19 has decided to disappear. According to the CDC, 147,840 new cases of COVID have been recorded in the last seven days.

States such as Kentucky have closed all of their restaurants, schools, and businesses until December. Some governors have started to advise caution when celebrating the holidays, too. You may be thinking, 'is there any way to really enjoy Christmas during the pandemic?' In fact, there are ways to still celebrate the holiday safely. Here are 10 ways that you can still enjoy the holiday season without canceling any of your plans.

Keep Reading... Show less
Facebook Comments