Doctors Can Now Refuse Treatment out of "Religious Freedom"
Start writing a post
Health and Wellness

Doctors Can Now Refuse Treatment out of "Religious Freedom"

It is unacceptable, unprofessional, and immature.

Doctors Can Now Refuse Treatment out of "Religious Freedom"
Al Jazeera America

Last weekend, a U.S. district judge ruled that doctors may refuse to treat women who have had a past abortion or transgender people. The claim was that forcing a doctor to treat these patients may be denying the doctors their religious freedom.

Yes, I am extremely upset that people still care what changes others make to their own bodies. But there is an even bigger problem here that can set an extremely dangerous precedent for both medical professionals and patients.

Everyone has heard of the Hippocratic Oath doctors take in medical school. Contrary to what you saw on Grey’s Anatomy, the Hippocratic Oath is hardly used anymore, and when it is, a modernized version is recited. (Fun fact! The guy who wrote the modern version was named Louis Lasagna!). More relevant today is the American Medical Association’s Code of Ethics. They are not "laws" per say, but more of guidelines that medical professionals are expected to follow. Let’s look at some aspects of the AMA’s code:

Section 1.1.1 Patient - Physician Relationships: “The relationship between a patient and a physician is based on trust, which gives rise to physicians’ ethical responsibility to place patients’ welfare above the physician’s own self-interest or obligations to others, to use sound medical judgment on patients’ behalf, and to advocate for their patients’ welfare.”

A physician needs to be able to drop their religious or political beliefs at the office door. Patients deserve the right to an environment which they feel safe and comfortable to talk about any medical concerns. As a doctor (or any health care worker), you are expected to put patients before yourselves. That is why you are willing to check on a patient at 3 a.m. or perform an emergency surgery on Christmas Day. Your patients come first, and if you are not willing to set aside your own ego for them, you shouldn’t be in this career field.

Section 1.1.2 Prospective patients:“Physicians must also uphold ethical responsibilities not to discriminate against a prospective patient on the basis of race, gender, sexual orientation or gender identity, or other personal or social characteristics that are not clinically relevant to the individual’s care.”

I cannot give you a more cookie cutter, basic, written out ethical theory violated than this one. I learned from an early age that if I became a doctor, I would not be allowed to judge who I treated. Doctors have a responsibility to even treat terrorists and serial killers with the same amount of respect. So you’re telling me transgenders and women with past abortions are now below serial killers on the social ladder?! COME ON PEOPLE.

The same section notes, “A physician may decline to establish a patient-physician relationship with a prospective patient, or provide specific care to an existing patient, in certain limited circumstances” which include:

  • The physician does not adequate skills to meet the patient’s needs (Obviously an Ob/Gyn can respectfully decline to perform a heart surgery)
  • The physician does not have the resources to safely, competently, and respectfully treat the patient (Ex. Don't perform an elective surgery in the front yard with muddy instruments)
  • The patient provides a danger to the physician
  • The patient keeps a physician from tending to his other patients (if he/she takes up too much of the physician’s time and resources)

Transgender people and women with abortions obviously do not fit into any of these categories. Note that the Code explicitly follows the second point with “Physicians may not decline to accept a patient for reasons that would constitute discrimination against a class or category of patients.” Refusing to treat those two groups of patients obviously breaks this guideline.

Section 1.1.7: Physician Exercise of Conscience:“Physicians are expected to uphold the ethical norms of their profession, including fidelity to patients and respect for patient self-determination. Yet physicians are not defined solely by their profession. They are moral agents in their own right and, like their patients, are informed by and committed to diverse cultural, religious, and philosophical traditions and beliefs. For some physicians, their professional calling is imbued with their foundational beliefs as persons, and at times the expectation that physicians will put patients’ needs and preferences first may be in tension with the need to sustain moral integrity and continuity across both personal and professional life.

“Physicians’ freedom to act according to conscience is not unlimited, however. Physicians are expected to provide care in emergencies, honor patients’ informed decisions to refuse life-sustaining treatment, and respect basic civil liberties and not discriminate against individuals in deciding whether to enter into a professional relationship with a new patient.”

Refusing to provide treatment for these groups clearly disrespects “basic civil liberties”. Can a doctor say “I personally am opposed to abortion, so I will not perform one on you”? Absolutely. Can a physician deny care for Crohn’s disease because a woman had an abortion 20 years ago? Absolutely NOT. It is unacceptable, unprofessional, and immature.

After reading the news article that inspired this post, I was absolutely disgusted that some of my future colleagues would even think of refusing care based on a person’s past. When did doctors become divine moral agents who could decide that a person isn’t “worthy enough” to receive their care? Will this become a slippery slope? We’ve already seen employers refuse to provide health insurance coverage for contraception (see Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc.). Can I then refuse to treat patients because they love avocados and I think it’s a slimy, tasteless excuse for a fruit? THIS IS INSANE.

What I find funny is this whole "religious freedom" thing. Based on this Judge's logic, could I claim I don't want to treat a prisoner because my religion doesn't approve of his murder? Obviously that would be unethical. So then why are only women and transgenders targeted? This is just another way for religious conservatives to try to repress the people they don't like and claim "religion" as their reasoning. Can I pull the religious freedom card to refuse treatment for those who oppose evolution? Of course not.

To any readers considering a health profession, let me just give you a little bit of an eye opener. You will have patients that you love. Adorable little kids. Cute old men who swear a lot. A mother who just beat cancer. You will also have patients that you cannot stand. Rude men who ask if you’re as competent as a male doctor. Murderers. Rapists. Famous politicians who champion every single platform you oppose.

But guess what? You have to walk into that patient’s room with a smile on your face and give him or her every single ounce of respect in your being. You will shake their hand, you will look them in the eye during conversation, you will brush off any nasty remarks they make, and you will be the best possible doctor for them. We are here to provide help, not to judge. So if you want to be able to “hand pick” who you give your time and services to, get the hell out of the my profession.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.

21 EDM Songs for a Non-EDM Listener

Ever wanted to check out EDM music, but didn't know where to start? Look no further! Start here.

21 EDM Songs for a Non-EDM Listener

If you have been following me for a long time, then you know I write about two main things: relateable articles and communication media based articles. Now, it is time for me to combine the two. For those of you that don't know, I am a radio DJ at IUP, and I DJ for a show called BPM (Beats Per Minute). It is an EDM, or electronic dance music, based show and I absolutely love it.

Keep Reading...Show less
A man with a white beard and mustache wearing a hat

As any other person on this planet, it sometimes can be hard to find the good in things. However, as I have always tried my hardest to find happiness in any and every moment and just generally always try to find the best in every situation, I have realized that your own happiness is much more important than people often think. Finding the good in any situation can help you to find happiness in some of the simplest and unexpected places.

Keep Reading...Show less

6 Things Owning A Cat Has Taught Me

This one's for you, Spock.

6 Things Owning A Cat Has Taught Me
Liz Abere

Owning a pet can get difficult and expensive. Sometimes, their vet bills cost hundreds of dollars just for one visit. On top of that, pets also need food, a wee wee pad for a dog, a litter box with litter for a cat, toys, and treats. Besides having to spend hundreds of dollars on them, they provide a great companion and are almost always there when you need to talk to someone. For the past six years, I have been the proud owner of my purebred Bengal cat named Spock. Although he's only seven years and four months old, he's taught me so much. Here's a few of the things that he has taught me.

Keep Reading...Show less

Kinder Self - Eyes

You're Your Own Best Friend

Kinder Self - Eyes

It's fun to see all of the selfies on social media, they are everywhere. I see pictures with pouty lips, duck lips and pucker lips. I see smokey eyes, huge fake lashes and nicely done nose jobs, boob jobs and butt lifts. Women working out in spandex, tiny tops and flip flops. I see tight abs and firm butts, manicured nails and toes, up dos and flowing hair. "Wow", I think to myself," I could apply tons of make-up, spend an hour on my hair, pose all day and not look like that. Maybe I need a longer stick!"

Keep Reading...Show less

Rap Songs With A Deeper Meaning

Rap is more than the F-bomb and a beat. Read what artists like Fetty, Schoolboy Q, Drake, and 2Pac can teach you.

Rap artist delivers performance on stage
Photo by Chase Fade on Unsplash

On the surface, rap songs may carry a surface perception of negativity. However, exploring their lyrics reveals profound hidden depth.Despite occasional profanity, it's crucial to look beyond it. Rap transcends mere wordplay; these 25 song lyrics impart valuable life lessons, offering insights that extend beyond the conventional perception of rap music.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments