Disney Musicals Ranked From Worst To Best

Disney Musicals Ranked From Worst To Best

Bringing the Disney magic to a whole new world

The Stunning Post

I was raised on two things-- Broadway and Disney. When those two things combine, I’m extremely happy. Disney Theatrical Productions has taken several of the most popular Disney movies to the Great White Way, creating a whole new genre of Disney magic for die-hard fans to enjoy. While the newest Disney trend is taking the animated classics and re-creating them as live action movies, I’ll always have a special place in my heart for Disney on Broadway.

I’ve ranked this list based on the following criteria-- success of the musical, staying power, reviews and awards and how true the musical stayed to the original movie. I’ve been fortunate enough to have seen some of these shows on Broadway or on tour and I’ve been especially lucky to have participated in a local production of one of these shows as a child, so some have made more of a lasting impression on me than others, but I’ve tried to keep my personal thoughts on the show as neutral as possible.

7. Tarzan

Tarzan opened on Broadway on May 10, 2006 at the Richard Rodgers Theatre. It is the only Disney Theatrical Production to open on Broadway without an out-of-town trial run. Many of the beloved Phil Collins songs are reprised for the stage version, with a few tweaks, and Collins wrote nine new songs for the musical as well. While the show was not nominated for any Tony awards, a Dutch production of the musical was nominated for nine awards over the course of three years and won three of them.

The musical was able to stay true to the original movie, but left many audiences wanting more depth out of the music and lyrics. Phil Collins' traditional pop style did not translate well to the stage, especially his lyrics. Critics and audiences felt that the lyrics were cliché and bland, and gave more of an Adult Contemporary feel than a Broadway musical. Personally, I liked moments from Tarzan, but as a whole, it felt like a pop album with a story line as opposed to a Broadway musical. I’ve placed Tarzan this far down on the list not because it was necessarily “bad” but because it was nowhere near as successful, charming and magical as the rest of the musicals on this list.

6. The Little Mermaid

The Little Mermaid opened in 2008 to replace Beauty and the Beast. Disney Theatrical Productions closed Beauty and the Beast for fear of having two competing Disney Princesses on Broadway at the same time, as well as having three other Disney shows running during the same period. The musical was based on the 1989 Disney movie and featured Sierra Boggess as Ariel, Tituss Burgess as Sebastian and Sherie Rene Scott as Ursula. Ten new songs were added for the stage and many of the famous songs from the musical were given a facelift for the Broadway version. The Little Mermaid was nominated for two Tonys in 2008.

All in all, The Little Mermaid did well, but did not live up to the success of other Disney musicals. The Little Mermaid had a short run and was closed, almost preemptively, because of historical trends and financial difficulties during the fall months of the year. However, the short run of only 685 performances has not left a bad stain on the original success of the story or movie-- The Little Mermaid continues to be one of the most memorable and magical Disney movies in history. Overall, not a huge success, but not a huge loss either.

5. Aladdin

One of the most recent additions, the story of Aladdin made its Broadway debut in 2014. The original Broadway production was praised for its individual songs, like “Friend Like Me” and “A Whole New World.” It was nominated for five Tonys and won for Best Performance by a Featured Actor in a Musical for James Monroe Iglehart’s performance as the Genie.

As much as I loved the music in the movie, there were too many changes for me to ignore in the Broadway version. One of the most memorable songs, "Friend Like Me," got a huge overhaul. Robin Williams originated the voice of the Genie in the 1992 movie and was one of the driving forces behind the movie’s success. While Iglehart does an amazing job of breathing new life into this iconic character, "Friend Like Me" tries to top itself in too many ways, adding different gimmicks to get laughs, like a lounge singer style medley of Alan Menken’s biggest Disney hits and a hoedown. While some of the original ideas from the movie might have been impossible to translate to the stage, I felt like the creative team gave up on themselves in this number. Some of the new numbers introduced characters and ideas that were cut from the original movie. I do love parts of this show, but overall, I felt like Aladdin tried too hard to bring the Disney magic to a new level.

4. Mary Poppins

I’ve been a huge fan of Julie Andrews for as long as I can remember, so anything that has a connection to her is something that I want to check out. Although I never really loved the Mary Poppins movie, the musical is a nice trip back in time to the things that made Broadway so wonderful in its early years-- huge dance numbers, fun music and sweet stories. Disney Theatrical did a wonderful job bringing a timeless movie to the stage with Mary Poppins. The musical ran on Broadway for six years and was nominated for seven Tony Awards, including Best Musical.

The musical, though based on the 1964 film, brought in inspiration from the original books, including new characters and rewriting some of the backstories of the Banks family. Many new songs were created for the musical and some were moved or re-imagined to incorporate new parts of the story or new characters. While Mary Poppins flew under the radar in comparison to other Disney Theatrical Productions, it was very successful on Broadway and ran for 2,619 performances. I’ve placed it this high on the list because of its success and its ability to remain true to the original books while still reminding us why we fell in love with the movie that first brought Mary Poppins to life.

3. Newsies

My personal favorite on this list, Newsies was based on the movie from 1992 directed and choreographed by Kenny Ortega, who is most famous for the High School Musical movies. Although I wasn’t thrilled with the changes to the plot and some songs, the dancing alone makes this musical top notch. The male-dominated original ensemble is made up of extremely talented dancers, including some So You Think You Can Dance finalists. I was a dancer for eight years, so I’m always drawn by choreography and Newsies did not disappoint. The set was also very clever and well-designed. Imagine a three-level, metal jungle gym that you can dance on, swing from and climb all over. I personally love these kinds of sets because it allows your actors a lot of freedom and creativity, and the cast of Newsies took full advantage.

Newsies was nominated for 8 Tonys in 2012 and won two, Best Choreography and Best Original Score.While the Broadway run only lasted 1,005 performances over the course of two years, it was the quickest Disney musical on Broadway to turn a profit and got rave reviews before it even opened. I’ve placed Newsies in the third place spot because it was extremely popular and successful, even though it had a short run on Broadway-- it’s almost the “underdog” of Disney Theatrical Productions.

2. Beauty and the Beast

Another Alan Menken masterpiece that made an excellent transition from the screen to the stage, Beauty and The Beast debuted on Broadway in April of 1994 at the Palace Theatre. It was the first adaptation from film to stage for a Disney movie. Where the movie brought dishware and inanimate objects to life with a little bit of animation, the Broadway show utilized costumes and confetti cannons. The Beast’s costume is breathtaking and several of the castle’s residents, like Lumière and Cogsworth, have special effects wired into their costumes to add a little flair and put the magic in the details. New songs added to the show are beautiful, heart-wrenching and add to the story without altering it. My personal favorite additions are the Beast’s solo, "If I Can’t Love Her" and the ensemble number "Human Again." Another piece was written specifically for Toni Braxton’s run as Belle to accommodate her R&B style and highlight her voice in it’s own special way. It has now become another staple of the musical.

I saw Beauty and the Beast on Broadway when I was about 12 or 13, and then again when the tour came to our local theatre. In the tour version, Gaston’s song was extended and included a mind-blowing dance break involving acrobatics and clanking mugs together. Usually when a show goes on tour, the show is downsized to account for transportation limitations and smaller stages in smaller cities, but Beauty and the Beast was able to make the show just as magical on tour as it was on Broadway.

1. The Lion King

The second Disney Theatrical Production-- first performed on July 8th, 1997 and moving to Broadway on October 15th 1997. Many of the original songs from the movie were kept during the transition to the Great White Way, but several new pieces were composed specifically for the Broadway version, mostly to incorporate more of the African rhythms and languages. Some songs that were cut from the original movie were added back into the musical as well. The Lion King was praised for its creativity and ability to bring the movie to a new medium in such a successful way. It has been one of the highest-grossing Broadway shows every week and is one of the most beloved productions of all time. It is currently the third longest-running show in history, topped only by The Phantom of the Opera and Chicago. The Lion King won six Tonys, including Best Musical.

The Lion King was my first Broadway show that I ever saw in NYC and it blew my little third-grade mind. Puppet animals like zebras, giraffes and elephants are brought to life by actors, and the costumes used to create the lions and lionesses are extremely detailed and creative. I don’t like to see the same musical too many times because the appeal wears off a little, but The Lion King is one of the few shows that I would see as many times as possible because of the Disney Magic that made me fall in love with the movie as a child is just as present on stage as it is in animation.

Bonus - The Hunchback of Notre Dame

While The Hunchback of Notre Dame technically hasn’t made it to Broadway (and unfortunately, doesn’t look like it will) it made huge waves at the La Jolla Playhouse on October 28, 2014. It was originally produced in Berlin and ran from 1999-2002. I managed to find a bootleg copy on YouTube that was absolutely enchanting. The original movie has some of my favorite music-- I’ll eat up anything that Alan Menken writes, but “Out There” never fails to send shivers up my spine. The La Jolla staging and casting is just beautiful. While I usually don’t enjoy huge plot changes, I loved the expansion on the original movie to be truer to the Victor Hugo novel, while still being a familiar and heartwarming story. Several relationships between characters were fleshed out in a way that would have been too much in the movie. Michael Arden’s performance as Quasimodo is extremely nuanced and clever-- after reading the novel and learning that the character of Quasimodo is half-deaf because of the bells, Arden created a series of signs that Quasimodo uses to communicate. I strongly recommend getting your hands on this soundtrack through either YouTube or Spotify.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Health and Wellness

This Survey Shows How Quarantine And Drinking Relate, And I Can't Say I'm Surprised

"5 o'clock somewhere" is more of a guideline now than ever.

As it stands, and my friends and I are finally 21. We're extremely excited to be able to go out to bars and "get lit" as the kids say, but due to the pandemic, all of our plans have been put on hold. We'd rather wait and go when it's safe than risk spreading the infection and hurting our loved ones. So, we've all been quarantining apart, getting on the occasional wine zoom call. This made me wonder if anyone else our age were doing the same thing.

Then, I discovered this survey: We Surveyed Millennials And Gen Z About Their Quarantine Drinking Habits — Cheers. Here are 3 things that I discovered through the survey results.

Keep Reading... Show less

5 Easy Summer Mocktail Recipes You Can Make With Items You Probably Already Have On-Hand

Keep these drinks in mind next time you're visiting your local farmer's market — you might want to grab some extra mint and limes.

With Summer 2020 in full swing comes the addition of many fresh fruits and vegetables to brighten up your dinner plate, but also your glass! Farmers markets are my personal favorite place to look for produce that is in season to make fun mocktails with.

Keep Reading... Show less

5 Ways To Celebrate The 4th of July — Without Fireworks Or Social Gatherings

We created a list of things to do since social distancing may create a dent in our typical, planned traditions.

With the Fourth of July on Saturday, the usual tradition of popping fireworks, grilling out, and being surrounded by family has been modified due to the pandemic. Whether you're a loner or surrounded by family, there will most likely be some changes to your celebrations.

For weeks on social media, people across the country have been complaining that they have been subjected to fireworks going off at all times of the night into the early morning. This has sparked concern and questions about why this is happening and how are people even obtaining the fireworks.

Keep Reading... Show less

Carb And Cheese Lovers, Unite — These Are The Best Mac And Cheese Recipes On The Internet

Whether you need to get through the current pandemic or want to spice up your Fourth of July celebrations, these mac and cheese recipes will do just that.


My favorite food is mac and cheese, and it always has been. All it requires is noodles and cheese — it's so simple to make. Although it's my favorite, it can also get kind of mundane because it's such a simple recipe. This, of course, has led to many people all over the world experimenting with the American staple.

With our lives currently being turned upside down due to the pandemic, a lot of people are seeking comfort. These are scary times, and in order to make it day-to-day, we need to have our favorite foods as a standby. These recipes can also be used during your celebration of the Fourth of July.

Keep Reading... Show less
Health and Wellness

17 Things To Make You Feel GOOD This Week

Because some purchases are just necessary.

Y'all, we're struggling. You don't even have to tell me, I know. What a mess we're all in, right? This year is not going how we planned and the world has turned into one giant struggle bus. I guess you could be super philosophical about everything happening for a reason, but sometimes life is just hard.

There are plenty of ways to bring yourself out of whatever rut you're in. You could go for a run, have a snack, or read a book. Or, if you're really looking for an adrenaline rush, go shopping. This is obviously not going to solve the world's problems with one swift click of the "checkout" button, but hey, it may just give you the little boost you need today.

Keep Reading... Show less

- Blissfully unaware that butt-care beyond squats was even something I should be considering in my self-care routine, I tried one of Bawdy Beauty's butt masks for the first time a month ago.

- I've never really given my butt a second though till I took a look at improvements that could be made with the mask — if one of the hydrating, firming, detoxifying, or brightening masks in the kit I received could either smooth out cellulite or tone my skin a bit more, I wasn't going to complain.

- Each Bawdy Beauty sheet mask comes in an individually-packaged sheet, soaked with a serum I massaged into my skin after removing said sheet. The clay butt mask comes in a convenient stick format I simply draw on to my skin and leave to set for about 10 minutes before hopping into the shower.

- I set a goal of committing myself to butt-care every day for one month. Between the regular use of sheet masks, clay masks, and their CBD Butt Balm in between, I didn't have many expectations.

- I thought the whole concept may just be a gimmick, but my butt has never looked so toned in my life, and the cellulite I had is almost completely gone. I wear one every single day when I get the chance.

I'm incredibly skeptical when it comes to marketing ploys and gimmicks in the beauty world. I'll be the first cynic to try out the latest serum on the market every influencer is raving about just to negate every grandiose claim it makes.

Keep Reading... Show less

Friends, you don't have to be quarantined to use a personal massager, you know? Because, sure, quarantine made for a lot of extra quality time with yourself, but no matter what phase of the reopening process you're in, it's normal and actually healthy to take care of your sexual needs on your own.

Keep Reading... Show less

5 Books I Didn't Realize Are About Gay Women

If you read primarily LGBTQ fiction, then this list might help to expand your TBR list.

Photo by Ketut Subiyanto from Pexels

Frequent readers of LGBTQ fiction might feel like they're reading the same book over and over again, with few exceptions.

Most of these books were on my TBR list for months and I didn't realize they were about gay women until I was reading them, hopefully, this list of books can interest you in expanding your reading material and seeking out different stories.

Keep Reading... Show less
Facebook Comments