The Repatriation Of "Stolen" Art: Who Does Art Belong To? | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
News

The Repatriation Of "Stolen" Art: Who Does Art Belong To?

What determines ownership of a piece of art? Should it be returned to its origin country or kept safe in a western museum?

449
The Repatriation Of "Stolen" Art: Who Does Art Belong To?

Places such as The Louvre or The British Museum are seen by many as centers for cultural appreciation and allow us to view art from around the world preserved for public display. Objections have arisen surrounding how the artwork was acquired and whether or not ownership of these pieces belongs to the museums that display them, or the countries where they were created.

The argument made by many supporters of repatriation is that these works were taken through conflict or stolen without consent of the people who created the art. An article on the History website lists multiple examples, like sculptures from the Kingdom of Benin and the Gwaegal shield, which were taken by the British through force.

Their stance is this: how can a country "own" something it obtained through forceful means against the will of the people who lived there?

In an article posted by Artnet News, the removal of Parthenon sculptures by Lord Elgon, a British aristocrat, is called into question. He originally made a deal with the Ottoman Empire to remove these sculptures from the neglected Parthenon. The issue is that the Ottoman Empire was there because of their violent occupation of Greece meaning the permission to take these sculptures wasn't given by the native people, but outsiders that conquered them. Another position is that art is many times split into pieces, as shown in the National Geographic video regarding the Parthenon Frieze, which isn't the way it was meant to be displayed.

The other side of this argument is that art should be shared around the world so people can learn more about the many different world cultures.

To many art historians, preserving the art is of the utmost importance. The majority feel that pieces should only be returned to countries that are able to preserve them. An article by the New York Times states that although it's risky transporting ancient art and splitting up pieces, "[...] it can also be risky to leave everything in one place, particularly if the country is in turmoil or can't afford to excavate or guard all its treasures." People who support keeping art in the museums housing it currently, are worried that unstable countries riddled with war would jeopardize the safety of these artifacts. The Parthenon itself was damaged by a bombing during the conflict between the Ottoman Empire and Venice.

When considering whether pieces should be returned, it's important to discern whether the art is a part of a bigger piece.

Regarding the Parthenon Frieze, Greek representatives think that it should be displayed together because the missing pieces take away from the artist's intention. There is always the idea that art should be shared, carefully, around the world, and that museums should loan pieces to other countries in a free exchange of knowledge and culture. Neither side is ready to concede just yet but hopefully in the future art can be appreciated from around the world for the sake of the art itself-not as a piece of stolen property.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
how to adult
Twitter

It is the time of our lives that we are beginning to enter the adult world and most of us, if not all of us, have no idea what we are doing. It's like starting a video game, but skipping the tutorial. We're all just running around aimlessly hoping we accidentally do something right that moves us along the right path. Now that graduation has just happened, or is right around the corner for some of us, it's time to start thinking about how we are going to take care of ourselves once we are on our own.

Keep Reading...Show less
Lifestyle

7 Signs You're A Starbucks Addict

I'll be the first one to admit I'm addicted to Starbucks.

344
drinking coffee
Tumblr

If you’re anything like me, you love a good cup of coffee. My coffee always comes from Starbucks; I refuse to drink it from anywhere else. Over the years, it’s become one of my biggest addictions. So, if you are aware that you’re a Starbucks addict as well, or maybe you need to check to see if you’re an addict, here are seven ways to tell.

Keep Reading...Show less
people  in library
Photo by redcharlie on Unsplash

College involves a whirlwind of emotions, whether it’s from the stress of an assignment (or twenty), or from fighting with your roommate. It can be overwhelming at times and it’s important to take a step a back and calmly think things over. Maybe gain some perspective. The following aren’t foolproof tips and may not apply to you, but I was able to find success with them (hope you do too!)

Keep Reading...Show less
Lifestyle

How The Holidays Have Changed

It all started when we learned the truth about Santa.

3401
best wishes for Christmas
Pinterest

It is no secret that many American traditions have changed over time. As we grow older we change in so many ways that it only makes sense that we also change the way we celebrate special occasions. Of course when it comes to the holidays there are some family traditions that many of us still excitedly look forward to, whether it is eating your favorite dish or seeing favorite cousin. However, we all know that the holidays have overall changed a little from what they used to be.

Keep Reading...Show less
theatre cast

Everyone who has done musicals knows that once you go there you can never go back. It's like a virus. It never leaves and you find yourself attracted to all types of theater things. You're drawn to it like a moth to a flame. There are certain things you know to be true, whether you did a musical once or have done them your entire life.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments