Everyone has that same memory in which you have to flush your beloved pet fish down the toilet. We’ve all been there – whether the fish was purchased from the store or won at a fair, everyone has had a pet fish in their lives at some point, especially during childhood.
It’s a sad thing when a fish passes away, although it’s a bit hard to be sure why. Yes, they were a pet, but do bonds with fish ever really grow as strong as the bonds humans create with cats, dogs or other creatures that people can actually pet and hold or communicate with in some way?
Growing up, just like many others, my house was always full of pets. Not all at once, but my eldest sister always had dogs and usually the dog was named after a Yankees player by my father. My other sister, the middle child, had a cat Jojo who lasted pretty much our entire suburban childhood until we moved to New York and I swear, our neighbors poisoned our pets because they all passed away within the year of the move. There was more than just Jojo though, as we had many cats come and go throughout our lives before moving. There were the fish as well; never enough to justify a big aquarium, but one or two goldfish in a small tank. We also had hamsters and even a chameleon. It’s very easy to have a multitude of pets living in a New Jersey suburb but after moving to New York City, after the remaining pets were most likely poisoned by some cruel, heartless neighbors, we didn’t have any pets for a while.
Several times my family had moved around in the same city and just four years ago we were able to get pets again. By this time, my eldest sister had moved out, living with a family of her own making, and she was able to fulfill the pet-owner trait, now ingrained into her with her, with owning pit bulls. My middle sister and I, however, needed to fulfill that hole in our lives that could only be caused from a lack of a pet bond.
We found some sick stray cats while visiting some family up in the Pennsylvania mountains. Sadly, these cats would clearly be sick forever as no amount of medical care would save them or enable them to live a longer, normal house-cat length life. We fed them, not being able to leave them with nothing. We rescued the kittens--the ones who still had chances to live long, healthy lives. Each of them were given to a home that we knew would take great care of them but two of them stayed in our home with us. Mew became and still is, my best cat friend.
My middle sister, however, has not seemed to have the same luck with pets, which is something truly sad. Everyone should have close pets. Pets bring joy that other humans don’t. When Mew joined our home, so did Bert, who was considered my sister’s cat. Bert was such a great cat--so friendly, always happy, always purring. However, one day, Bert and Mew both discovered the outdoors world. They always went out and came back in. Mew continued to come back and she still always comes back from her excursions outdoors. The whole neighborhood knows our cats in this house and this neighborhood has so many pet cats that I swear, they all meet up down at the beach every night to hang out. In Bert’s case, he changed. After we got him fixed, he just never came back. It was and still is sad, because he was so relaxed all of the time. We had been through so much with these two cats to make sure they wouldn’t be sick like the others, and he just left. He can still be seen around the neighborhood from time to time, hanging out with his cronies, but those moments are rare and fleeting.
My sister was in the pet-less void once again. There was a period of time in which she moved out and had a cat where she lived, but when she came back here, the cat stayed there. It was last year when she decided to get herself some fish. At that point, one of my cousins had adopted a black cat from the shelter as a gift for me, so I’m sure it must have felt unfair to my sister, that I had two close pets and she had none. So she went and adopted two small fish, Oreo and Bentley.
Again, I don’t know how people really bond with fish. They are cute but they just swim around all day. They don’t look you in the eyes, you can’t pet them or take them for walks or anything. The fish seemed to make my sister happy, though, so that was good. She had to keep her door shut, though, or else Wednesday would creep into her bedroom and taunt the fish, waiting to make a meal out of them. In the end, though, neither of my cats were the reason for her fishes’ demise.
Bentley had this habit of jumping out of his tank. When my sister would be replacing the water or cleaning the tank out, or really in any situation where the lid had to come off, she told me he would jump out of the water and she had to quickly pick him up and put him back in. We have no idea why he would do this, especially since Oreo never did anything of the sort. One night, it happened.
My sister called me into her room, the worry in her voice was strongly noticeable. My anxiety got worked up, my mind was racing, I was thinking, “What’s happening?! Was World War III declared?! Are we in a police state?! Are we going to die?!” I walked into her room and asked what was happening, and she told me she was worried because Oreo wasn’t moving and she was worried he had passed away. She said she couldn’t take him out of the tank and flush him, she was too sad to do it. I had to do the job.
I walked over to the tank in my new socks and in the back of my head I was thinking, “Is the floor wet or is my foot sweating?” as there appeared to be moisture now on the bottom of my foot where there wasn’t any before. I didn’t say anything about it because I didn’t think anything of it, I just shrugged it off and took the fish scooper from the shelf to catch the floating body of Oreo. It was hard for me to do, honestly. I knew the fish was dead and wasn’t going to spring back to life and hit me in the face, but for some reason, I feel so taboo about dead bodies. I feel like I’m violating this formerly-living creature’s space by picking up its body and disposing of it however, since my sister couldn’t do it, I knew I needed to.
We were both wondering where Bentley was, though, as I scooped up Oreo, held the net extended so far away from me, and carried him to the bathroom where he was flushed away into oblivion. That was when the reality of what happened crashed down upon us.
“I found Bentley.” I heard my sister’s voice call out from her room, so I walked back to find out where the second fish was hidden. She pointed out his lifeless, now flattened form to me: right where I had been standing. The moisture I felt under my foot was most likely a mix of the water that coated his body as he jumped to his doom, and the life force inside of him. I was sickened. I had to use the scooper to pick him up and flush him down, as well, but all I could think about was how I had stepped on his lifeless fish body and flattened him. I ripped that sock off as fast as I could and scrubbed layers of skin off of my foot, but it still doesn’t feel clean. It was a sad day to be a fish, and my sister was once again pet-less.
When you’re a kid and your fish dies, it’s your parents who handle the corpse and performs the act of flushing it down the toilet. My sister and I were no longer kids, though, we were already adults at that point. It was our job to handle the remains. Even I, who had no bond with these fish, fell victim to the air of mourning that lingered about in that room. There’s something about handling a lifeless body that affects anyone with a soul and I don’t know how generations of parents appeared so strong when we were kids to be able to do this ritual. Why they both passed in the same day, we will never know, but it was a double punch in the stomach to my sister who had cared for them each and every day.
Eventually, my sister moved on. She once again was able to get herself a pet. I don’t know why she got another fish after that first horrible incident, but she did and she’s happy with him. She also purchased a hamster, Hammy, with her girlfriend and both pets are doing well. Hopefully they stay this way for a long time. During this time, though, I keep asking myself why my sister keeps choosing pets that pique the interest of my cats.





















