What The Hobby Lobby Decision Means For You
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

What The Hobby Lobby Decision Means For You


Walking into Hobby Lobby, it is easy to see the religious leanings of the establishment. The store is closed on Sundays to “allow employees time for family and worship” and their stock of Christian crafts and home decorations is extensive. Recently, this viewpoint had an impact in court.

On June 30th, the Supreme Court ruled on a case concerning Hobby Lobby’s policy of denying health insurance that covered contraceptives. The Court upheld that in a company where less than five individuals hold majority stock (a “closely held” corporation), companies have the right to act upon the religious convictions of those shareholders.  According to Inc.com, that comprises 90% of American businesses.  That means that a staggering 90% of businesses now have the freedom to deny female employees contraception (or any other service) if they honestly hold religious beliefs against it.

Mother Jones breaks down the effect of this ruling into three outcomes: access to contraceptives, access to other health benefits under Obamacare, and workers rights.  If companies can do anything except withhold taxes because of religious reasons, the door is opened for denying employment to homosexuals, paying women less, or not funding essential medical processes such as vaccination, Mother Jones reports. Since contraception is a contentious topic to begin with, this case has attracted lots of media attention on what this effect on women now. However, there is little focus forward: how will this ruling affect American workers in 5, 10, 15 years? 

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Cornell alum and sister of Alpha Epsilon Phi, sums up the implications in her 35-page dissent. She summarizes several previous cases where religious convictions did not precede laws, a standard which contradicts the results of the Hobby Lobby case. Ginsberg points out that this is the first time the Supreme Court has allowed a for-profit company to be given autonomy usually used to protect non-profit and community groups. Furthermore, she analyzes that even if one were to consider the corporation to hold the same religious rights of an individual, the law dictates that providing contraception should “substantially” go against said religious beliefs, and it is unclear in the current case if the “substantial” requirement has been met.

Her point that there is a difference between a “community of believers” and a corporation raises the question: can a company’s owners follow their beliefs at the expense of their employees?  According to Monday's decision, yes.  The laws surrounding incorporating, or creating a corporation, are concerned with creating an entity separate from its shareholders.  It doesn’t seem obvious that shareholders ought to retain certain individual rights when operating a company.  The Supreme Court has redrawn the line of what rights shareholders retain.  It is important for future employees to note that although a corporation holds the same rights as a person, it does not have the same liability.  It is remarkably difficult to bring criminal charges against the shareholders of a corporation for damages done by the company.  This double standard seems to have fallen by the wayside in the Hobby Lobby decision. 

Justice Bader Ginsburg certainly is justified in her concern with the breadth of this decision.  As individuals who will likely be employed in the near future, it is important to be aware of what this ruling may mean.  Perhaps it is rather extremist to say that this ruling will allow corporations to discriminate while hiring (as Mother Jones claims, but we should still be aware that this ruling may affect us as employees.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
clock indicates that it is free time

While the idea of free time without a stressful job or an abundance of schoolwork looming over your head may sound like a dream, it can be a nightmare at times. Having a couple of days to decompress is needed for a healthy mind and body. But when too many days go by, it can cause a downward spiral of thoughts and feelings.

As a recent jobless graduate, I was ecstatic to be free from responsibility and take a break from my normal life. That was until I realized just how responsible I had been and needed to be to continue being self-sustained. I learned a few things in this month of unemployment that encouraged me to find a job as soon as possible.

Keep Reading...Show less

74 Reasons Why I Love My Best Friend

You can be yourself without having to explain yourself, because she accepts you and loves you just the way you are.

Two women's hands with their small fingers interlocking

Have you ever found that one person in your life who you literally could not live without? You can talk to her about anything. She's the only person who will look you straight in the eyes and say, "You're stupid." You two can ride around or sit at your house for hours and always have something to talk about. You can be yourself without having to explain yourself because she accepts you and loves you just the way you are.

Keep Reading...Show less

8 Spotify Playlists To Get You In The Autumn Mood

The temperature may not be very Autumn-like, but these playlists sure are.

Autumn Playlists
King of Wallpapers

Autumn is my favorite time of the year. The leaves change, pumpkin spice everything hits the shelves (thank you, world!), the 13 Nights of Halloween on Freeform (formerly abcfamily) and the temperature drops. Well, the temperature is supposed to drop. Being in south Alabama, however, means that the temperature may be relatively low early in the mornings, but you're still going to suffer in the afternoon. So if the weather outside isn't getting you in the Autumn mood, maybe these Spotify playlists will help you slip into that wonderful, Autumn state of mind.

Keep Reading...Show less
Black and white adult cat staring at the camera

As human beings, there are just some things that seem to bring us all together with the same sense of irritation. Here are a few of those annoying things that make my list. I'm sure at least some, if not most, of them make yours as well. If you can think of any more relatable annoyances that I've missed, feel free to comment on this article and let me know!

Keep Reading...Show less

First Snow

It's the Most Wonderful Time of the Year!

First Snow
Sorina Bindea

I have never understood why grown-ups complain when the leaves are all off the trees, and the temperatures take a decided turn towards the zero on the thermometer. I hear complaints about the impending winter weather, and the driving in the snow and ice. We live in Pennsylvania, so I bite my tongue instead of stating the obvious: Maybe you should move to a warmer climate?

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments