It's OK To Sit During The Pledge Of Allegiance Because Forced Patriotism Violates Our Constitutional Rights

It's OK To Sit During The Pledge Of Allegiance Because Forced Patriotism Violates Our Constitutional Rights

I refused to stand for the pledge for a week, and I learned a lot.

One of the ideas that our Constitution supports is the separation of church and state. Students are no longer required to worship a standardized deity during school hours, and religious acceptance has expanded to allow a greater degree of freedom.

With this in mind, I wondered why I was required to stand and say the pledge of allegiance every morning... How is it any different than forcing students to pray to one specific religion?

So I did a little social experiment: for an entire week, I stayed seated during the pledge and observed the surrounding social stigma. What I discovered surprised me.

Even though it was completely optional to stand for the pledge, it was a deep-rooted standard of society to stand anyway. It is seen as disrespect to not stand for the flag of the country in which we live and are supposed to show support for. But, through maintaining that logic, is it not disrespectful to stay seated for our teachers? After all, they are the authority figures in American educational facilities. And what about the president? No one stands for him, but everyone shows him respect through Twitter wars and unsolicited protests.

Isn't it funny that we hold more reverence for a piece of fabric than an actual human?

When I stayed sitting, the first thing I noticed is that the teacher would not take no for an answer. I explained to her that saying the pledge was optional, but all she replied was "No, you have to stand up." When I continued to sit, she kept looking at me but did not say anything. I was perfectly in my right to refuse doing the pledge, and she could not do anything about it. As the week passed, my teacher became used to my actions and didn't give it another thought. My classmates were mildly surprised, but they recognized that I was not doing anything wrong.

Now, I love my country, and I love the people in it. But it's important to respect the values that the flag represents, not the flag itself.

Anyone can say the pledge, but it takes a true American to mean the words they say. Choosing to opt out of the pledge should not be a bad thing; instead, donate to the homeless or advocate for women's rights. Actions speak louder than words. Show that you are passionate about the prosperity of this country. It means a lot more than mindlessly saying the pledge.

Cover Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons

Popular Right Now

I'm An 18-Year-Old Female And I Will Never Be A Feminist

Honestly, I'd rather be caught dead than caught calling myself a modern-day feminist.

"A man told me to have a good day... I'm triggered." How ludicrous does that sound? Tune in because that is the extent of modern day feminism.

Sure, I think boys are stupid and that I'm probably better than 90% of the male population, but that doesn't make me a modern-day feminist. Now I believe that woman should stand up for themselves, and Golding's quote: "I think women are foolish to pretend they are equal to men, they are far superior and always have been," is by far one of my favorite quotes... but modern day feminism is not something I want to be associated with.

I'm all for "anything you can do I can do better," and "We can do it!" but realistically speaking in some situations, that isn't feasible. As an 18-year-old woman who works out regularly, and is stronger than the average female, I couldn't carry a 190-pound man back to a safe zone after he was shot on the front line of a war even if I tried. It is not anatomically possible for a grown woman to be as strong as a fully developed male.

Reality check: Men and women are not equal.

They are not physically equal, they are not mentally equal. Modern-day feminism is equality between the two genders, but corrupt and on steroids. I support what feminism used to be. I support women who work hard and have goals and ambition... not girls who hate men and stomp around with no shirts on to piss off the public. Feminism has developed into a polluted teaching that young men and women are plunging into.

We are built dissimilarly.

The human brain is literally an organ that is sex oriented. There is a cognitive difference, that singlehandedly destroys gender equality.

I will not spend my time running a revolution against anyone who likes Donald Trump. I am not going to binge watch Trump's twitter in an effort to start some leftist gob of drama. I refuse to be part of this head hunt to attack all Republicans on the newest Instagram post made about how feminism is stupid. I do not hate men, and society would crash and burn without the successful men and women who work together to create what we call the United States of America.

Why, you ask? Why are the 15-25 year olds of our society clinging to feminism? They are hopping on the rapidly growing bandwagon where all the hipsters, feminists and Trump haters reside. It's "cool" to hate Donald Trump. Twitter is a world of liberalism, hatred and fake love towards all. Social media is where this generation is living — and modern-day feminism brews there.

We need to keep separation in the household within roles.

We must raise our children to do what they are best at rather than trying to do something they are incapable of just to prove an irrelevant point.

Women must stand up for what they believe in and be strong in their shoes, while not getting so caught up in what your modern day feminist says she thinks is right.

We cannot let this briskly changing society sway us away from what is going to keep the world working precisely.

Cover Image Credit: Macey Joe Mullins

Related Content

Connect with a generation
of new voices.

We are students, thinkers, influencers, and communities sharing our ideas with the world. Join our platform to create and discover content that actually matters to you.

Learn more Start Creating

Teachers Are Better Influences On Generations Than Politicians

Being able to debate with an opponent had to come from somewhere.


I've always wanted to influence the world. When I was 7-years-old, I wanted to be a movie star (deep down I still do). At 14-years-old, I wanted to be a writer. I now want to be a teacher.

"Really?" people ask. "A teacher?"

Despite the "bad" pay, annoying parents, and lots of homework being a teacher is the best way to influence the world because you are influencing the next generation of adults; the next politicians, movie stars, doctors and more. It's a teacher that can make or break a child. They can right wrongs that may happen at home and provide guidance, not just for their future in the workforce, but their future in life.

That's just being a teacher in general though. I don't believe a history teacher can have the same influence as an English teacher. English is used all the time no matter what you do and because of that being an English teacher is the best subject to influence in many ways. By being a teacher, I can guide kids through some of their toughest years and help them find their passion, and as an English teacher, I can do so much more as well. Let me teach you how words are the way to connect, to teach, to influence, to resolve and create. ]

As an English teacher, I can educate the next generation on how to be heard as an adult, even when the world thinks you are just a child. As an English teacher, I can educate the next generation on how to resolve problems in ways that both parties can feel at ease and content, which is something we need more of in the chaotic world we live in. As an English teacher, I can help someone discover the power of persuasion, the power of making connections between seemingly irrelevant things, and the power to create with words. By being an English teacher, I can teach the next generation how to speak and be heard, and to speak kindly, but with a fierceness to be reckoned with. I can teach these kids how to speak as adults, to write like lovers and like CEOs and presidents.

Being a teacher has its ups and its downs, however, it is the best way to influence the world. And being an English teacher has the ability to change it completely.

Related Content

Facebook Comments