Baseball Robot Umpires MLB
Start writing a post
News

Robot Umpires Are Finally Here, But Do You Really Want Them?

As the so called robo-umps make their debut in the Atlantic League, an important question arises: do we want them in the first place?

10
Wikimedia Commons

The dilemma of using computers and robots to call balls and strikes has been around for more than a decade now, but we had yet to see the practice implemented. That is, until now, after the so called "robo-umps" have finally debuted in the Atlantic League, and independent baseball league, which plans to use them for the rest of their regular season.

For those that are unfamiliar, the robo-umps in question are not meant to replace any umpire other than the one behind the plate calling balls and strikes. All the other umpires, including 1st, 2nd, and 3rd base umpires, will still be present to make on-field calls. The robo-umps are solely for strike calling. An earpiece will relay the exact call to the home plate umpire so he can show visually and verbally show the call.

But you still need the home plate umpire in order to relay the message and also to override the system in many cases, like that of a ball that bounces into the zone, an obvious missed ball or strike, foul balls and with hit batters. And with the power to override the robo-ump, what is the point in the first place?

But why do we actually want to use these robo-umps? A huge part of baseball is based on how pitches are presented and how batters and pitchers alike work counts to their favor. If you completely replace the human system, you take out a huge aspect of how baseball's human reward system works.

For example, say a pitcher was struggling and ended up in a 3-0 count, about to walk a hitter. Now, the pitcher throws a pitch that does not catch the zone but is one inch away from doing so, technically a ball. Almost every umpire in the game, and myself included, would call that pitch a strike because of its location and out of sympathy for the pitcher.

The same goes the other way as well; say a batter was struggling this time and ended in a 0-2 count, about to strike out. Now, the pitcher throws a pitch that catches 1% of the zone, technically a strike, and again, most umps and myself would call this pitch a ball, out of sympathy for the pitcher. This "human reward system" is a major part of baseball and in my opinion is one of the defining factors of the game.

Another factor to consider would be the lost value of catchers who frame pitches to get favorable calls from an umpire. What I mean by "framing" is an act by a catcher to make a ball appear as if it is a strike in hopes of getting a strike call from the umpire. If this part of the game is taken out, many players that are known for their pitch framing, especially Tyler Flowers (considered the best pitch framer in Major League Baseball), would lose their value. Not to mention that this skill aspect of the game would disappear forever.

But on the flip side, a huge game in the World Series could not be ruined by an absurd call on a singular pitch from an umpire. With good technology, balls and strikes become more fair and players will have less to gripe about. Ejections will decrease, and both hitters and pitchers will know if they are actually at fault or if the umpire is not on their side.

So, do we really want to see robot umpires make their way into Major League Baseball? I say no, but that is for you to decide on your own.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Adulting

Ask Your BFF These 20 Questions To See If They Know You As Well As You THINK That They Do

Ask your best friend these basic questions to see just how well they know you.

35876
Ask Your BFF These 20 Questions To See If They Know You As Well As You THINK That They Do

My best friend has been in my life since we were 3 years old, now that we are adults now, I'd like to ask her these questions to see how well she knows me.

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

Alone At The Met

I survive a day alone in NYC.

7666
Wikimedia Commons

It was six in the evening. I was sitting in the courtyard of a Renaissance-era Italian villa, glancing around at the statues, most notably one of a boy removing a thorn from his foot. Despite the supposedly relaxing setting, I was incredibly anxious. My phone was at less than 5 percent battery, and once it died I would be completely disconnected from my family and peers, alone in one of the largest art museums in the country.

Keep Reading... Show less
Student Life

College 101: How To Ease The Back To School Blues

Getting back into the school groove when you just can't seem to let go of summer.

9876
Beyond The States

With fall classes just beginning, many of us find ourselves struck with summer withdrawals. Especially for those who refrained from taking courses over the summer, it can be quite difficult to get back in the swing of things. Fortunately, there are various ways to help make the transition back to college as smooth as possible.

Keep Reading... Show less
Dating Apps

We Met At A Bar

Salvage what you can; if you can't, it's alright to walk away.

7032
We Met At A Bar
Anne Waldon

We met at a bar.

Keep Reading... Show less
Sports

The Mets And Me

They may be the worst sometimes, but this baseball team has given me more than I could ask for.

5658
Rich Schultz/Getty Images

On September 3rd, 2001, a sea of children littered my home's navy-carpeted den to watch baseball during my dad's 40th birthday extravaganza. A baseball game flickered on the TV, and a red and blue bubble of a scoreboard sat in the bottom right corner of the screen. The New York Mets and the Philadelphia Phillies were in a wild game at Veterans' Stadium. As I, a five-year-old boy with a jumble of curly blonde hair, sat in the back of the kid clump, I wondered which team I should root for. After a long debate with myself, I decided that I should root for the team that's winning (duh). But, as the ninth inning rolled around with the Phils maintaining a 7-5 lead, some magic occurred. The Mets put up five runs in one frame, stunning the Phillie fans in the room and winning the game 10-7.

Keep Reading... Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments