Drew Brees Vs. Peyton Manning

Drew Brees Surpasses Peyton Manning in Every Way

Nobody's brave enough to say it, so I will.


So a few weeks ago on your casual Monday Night Football Drew Brees launched a 62-yard touchdown to Tre'Quan Smith, to surpass Peyton Manning as the NFL's all-time leader in passing yards. The story behind Brees record-setting game sort of crept up on fans and analysts of the league. It didn't snowball into a major story until the day after he did it. Was that because of the other more meaningful games that weekend? Was it playoff baseball? Or was it the people have been doing the same thing they've done for the past 18 years. Not acknowledging Brees as one of the best to ever spin the laces.

When asked, who are the best quarterbacks to ever play the game of football most lists would say, Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Aaron Rodgers and several other quarterbacks who played way back when people thought "The Wizard of Oz" was cutting edge.

But when taking a closer look, Brees has quietly put together a resume that not only matches up to Mannings but also knocks him out of the number two spot. I know for a fact that all of the Peyton people are either really salty, but before you click away just hear me out for a sec.

Brees has now played longer and has sustained a higher level of play than Manning. Mannings 17 season was incredibly hard to watch, he threw 17 interceptions to just nine touchdowns. Sure, he won a Super Bowl, but he didn't light the world on fire throughout any of the playoff games. On the other hand, during Brees' 17 seasons he completed 72 percent of his passes, threw 23 touchdowns to eight interceptions and was one knuckleheaded play away by then-rookie safety Marcus Williams, the Saints would have been in the NFC championship. But it's not all about what the two have done recently. Per Pro Football Reference, Brees has a career completion percentage of 67 percent along with a career quarterback rate of 97.3, both of which are better than Mannings.

What can also factor into how good a quarterback performs is the team that is put around him, especially on the offensive side of the ball. Throughout Mannings career, he has had the luxury of throwing the ball to two future halls of farmers in Marvin Harrison and Reggie Wayne, along with super talented guys like Demaryius Thomas, Dallas Clark, Wes Welker, and Emmanuel Sanders. Surely if Brees has surpassed Mannings record he had the same riches of receivers that Manning did right? Well, he did have Antonio Gates in his first three seasons and he turned Jimmy Graham into an elite tight end. But after those two guys, you run into names like Lance Moore, Devery Henderson, and Marques Colston. All of them were pretty decent players, but none were ever on the level of at least a Demaryius Thomas.

One of the big arguments against Brees not being involved in the conversation with the greats is that he isn't as talented as guys like Manning and Rodgers and that he only has one Super Bowl.

"How many rings? How many championships do you have? Drew Brees only has one, he only went to one," said ESPN analyst Ryan Clark during a Tuesday episode of the first take. "The other thing is talent. The reason we talk about Aaron Rodgers the way we do is not that he's won a ton of Super Bowls or his team has a ton of super bowl rings. It's the way it looks it's the way it comes out of his hand it's the feeling he gives us when we watch him play (and) Drew Brees doesn't do that."

First, if we're talking championships Brees has only won once but it came at the defeat of which quarterback? Peyton Manning.

Super Bowl XLIV Recap: Saints vs. Colts | NFL YouTube

Championships should also never be brought up when comparing Aaron Rodgers and Drew Brees because they both only have one. But the biggest point Clark made that I take most issue with is how he inferred that Brees isn't as talented as some of the other greats or he doesn't give you that "special feeling" when he plays. In my opinion when using phrases like "he doesn't give you that feeling" or "he isn't as talented" are both empty statements. Neither can be backed up with many facts. But what can be backed up is Drew Brees is one of the most efficient players to ever play the game. And if I'm being completely honest the fact that a guy that essentially plays catch for a living gives you a "special feeling," that makes me a bit uncomfortable.

It is still mind-boggling to me how people don't see Brees as one of the greatest quarterbacks of all-time. All he's done is overcome a horrific shoulder injury, lead his team to a super bowl after a horrible hurricane and continue to pass everyone in the record books who most would say have more talent. Maybe when Brees enters his age 40 seasons, the non-believers will realize that maybe they were wrong counting this guy out. Or maybe they will continue to make up excuses to knock Brees further back on the last. Either way, Brees has accomplished a remarkable feat and shows no signs of slowing down.

Popular Right Now

When You Give A Girl A Dad

You give her everything

They say that any male can be a father, but it takes a special person to be a dad. That dads are just the people that created the child, so to speak, but rather, dads raise their children to be the best they can be. Further, when you give a little girl a dad, you give her much more than a father; you give her the world in one man.

When you give a girl a dad, you give her a rock.

Life is tough, and life is constantly changing directions and route. In a world that's never not moving, a girl needs something stable. She needs something that won't let her be alone; someone that's going to be there when life is going great, and someone who is going to be there for her when life is everything but ideal. Dads don't give up on this daughters, they never will.

When you give a girl a dad, you give her a role model.

If we never had someone to look up to, we would never have someone to strive to be. When you give a little girl someone to look up to, you give her someone to be. We copy their mannerisms, we copy their habits, and we copy their work ethic. Little girls need someone to show them the world, so that they can create their own.

When you give a girl a dad, you give her the first boy she will ever love.

And I'm not really sure someone will ever be better than him either. He's the first guy to take your heart, and every person you love after him is just a comparison to his endless, unmatchable love. He shows you your worth, and he shows you what your should be treated like: a princess.

When you give a girl a dad, you give her someone to make proud.

After every softball game, soccer tournament, cheerleading competition, etc., you can find every little girl looking up to their dads for their approval. Later in life, they look to their dad with their grades, internships, and little accomplishments. Dads are the reason we try so hard to be the best we can be. Dads raised us to be the very best at whatever we chose to do, and they were there to support you through everything. They are the hardest critics, but they are always your biggest fans.

When you give a girl a dad, you give her a credit card.

It's completely true. Dads are the reason we have the things we have, thank the Lord. He's the best to shop with too, since he usually remains outside the store the entire time till he is summoned in to forge the bill. All seriousness, they always give their little girls more than they give themselves, and that's something we love so much about you.

When you give a girl a dad, you give her a shoulder to cry on.

When you fell down and cut yourself, your mom looked at you and told you to suck it up. But your dad, on the other hand, got down on the ground with you, and he let you cry. Then later on, when you made a mistake, or broke up with a boy, or just got sad, he was there to dry your tears and tell you everything was going to be okay, especially when you thought the world was crashing down. He will always be there to tell you everything is going to be okay, even when they don't know if everything is going to be okay. That's his job.

When you give a girl a dad, you give her a lifelong best friend.

My dad was my first best friend, and he will be my last. He's stood by me when times got tough, he carried me when I just couldn't do it anymore, and he yelled at me when I deserved it; but the one thing he has never done was give up on me. He will always be the first person I tell good news to, and the last person I ever want to disappoint. He's everything I could ever want in a best friend and more.

Dads are something out of a fairytale. They are your prince charming, your knight in shinny amour, and your fairy godfather. Dads are the reasons we are the people we are today; something that a million "thank you"' will never be enough for.

Cover Image Credit: tristen duhon

Related Content

Connect with a generation
of new voices.

We are students, thinkers, influencers, and communities sharing our ideas with the world. Join our platform to create and discover content that actually matters to you.

Learn more Start Creating

Every Question You Have About The Stanley Cup Playoffs, Answered

The Stanley Cup is upon us and there are a few things you should know if you're tuning in for the first time.


April is such a crazy time this year in the entertainment arena. With "March Madness" coming to a close, the Stanly Cup Playoffs beginning April 9th, "Game of Thrones" premiering its final season on Sunday, April 14th and "Avengers: End Game" premiering Friday, April 26, things are going to be insane all month long.

To kick things off, hockey fans everywhere are preparing for the Stanley Cup. Here are a few tips if you have no idea what the Stanley Cup is to make you look like you know exactly what you are talking about (even if you don't know anything about hockey in the first place).

1. What even is hockey, anyways?


Hockey is a sport that is played against two teams on the ice. The players wear skates, use ice hockey sticks and play with a rubber disc called a puck. The objective of the game is to score on the opponent's goal. The game itself can be very fast paced, physical and it's very popular in the United States, Canada, Russia and Central and Eastern Europe.

2. Why do people care about the NHL?


It is widely thought that the NHL (in North America) is the most admired hockey league in the world. As of right now, there are currently 31 teams in the NHL both from the U.S. and Canada.

3. What is the Stanley Cup?


The Stanley Cup is named after Lord Stanley of Preston who was the 1892 Governor General of Canada. The shiny silver cup was purchased by him in London and he then donated it to award the top amateur hockey club located in Canada. The first winner of the Stanley Cup in 1893, was the Montreal Amateur Athletic Association (or MAAA). The cup has an escort (currently Philip Pritchard), who always accompanies it. The poor cup has seen its fair share of horror, including being urinated in by the New York Rangers.

4. So how do the Stanley Cup Playoffs work?


Well, the Stanley Cup Playoffs usually begin the first few weeks of April and can go into the first week of June (depending on how fast each team makes it thru the four rounds of best-of-seven series.) There are eight teams from each of the two conferences and are in the tournament depending on how well they did during the regular season. Whoever wins the cup gets the claim to the trophy for the year.

5. What happens if a team wins?


It's a really big deal to win the Stanley Cup. Basically, it's just a ton of bragging rights and being able to say that your team worked really hard to get there. Imagine working so hard to get that big promotion at work and you get it. It's a wonderful feeling but if you don't get it, well there can be some tears (and let me tell you it can be very sad watching hockey players cry.)

6. Who were last year's Stanley Cup winners?


The defending champs, the Washington Capitals, are back in the Stanley Cup Playoffs this year. Winning for the first time in franchise history, the Capitals hope to make a Stanley Cup Final appearance and win again. Since I was six years old, I have been the biggest Capitals fan so being able to be in Washington D.C. and watch them win was one of the best moments in my life (I am hoping for a repeat... but this year there are some really awesome teams.)

7. Who is predicted to win?


Coming in hot with the most wins for the regular season and the team I have been calling to win since their loss to the Washinton Capitals during the third round of the playoffs last year, the Tampa Bay Lightning led by Steven Stamkos are the big favorites to win this year. Both the Calgary Flames and the Vegas Golden Knights are close contenders. I'm calling it now, though. The Tampa Bay Lightning will be hoisting the Stanley Cup in June.

8. Are there any underdogs?


Out of all the teams (besides the Washington Capitals of course), I was really hoping to see the Carolina Hurricanes go to the playoffs. This team, who have become famous this year for their post-game celebrations, have really stepped it up. The last time this team made a playoff run was in 2009. It's really great to see a team who isn't normally in the playoffs competing. Although I can't wish them luck as they are playing against the Capitals in the first round, I hope to see them play next year.

9. So who should I talk about to make it sound like I actually watch hockey?


Whenever I talk about hockey, people seem to like to quiz me on players to see if I really know hockey. A few players you should mention to people if they bring the Stanley Cup are as follows. Right Winger on the Tampa Bay Lightning, Nikita Kucherov, is on fire this season with 87 assists. I hate to be basic but Alex Ovechkin and the reason for him is that he is sitting at 51 goals, making this his eighth season to obtain 50+ goals a season.

Brad Marchand is a huge fighter, but the Boston Bruins would be lost without him. If you really want to piss a New York Islanders fan off, you just need to mention John Tavares name. Lastly, Brent Burns is one of the best defensemen and plays for the San Jose Sharks. He's got some pretty great locks of hair and a big toothy smile but he can play hockey like no other. Of course, there are so many other talented great players this playoff run, but these are just a few you could mention.

10.  I heard there are a lot of fights in hockey ... do you think I'll see one?


Yes, fights happen in hockey all the time but especially during the playoffs. Tensions are high, but so are penalties. Tensions are especially high when a team is playing game four and if they don't win they are done. I have seen some pretty nasty fights break out during the playoffs and it's not pretty especially when it involves fans. Be prepared to see some fights break out and would not be surprised to see if Tom Wilson gets suspended again as he does every year (for no good reason) during the playoffs.

11. Why does the Stanley Cup Playoffs affect me?


The Stanley Cup Playoffs are way more fun than a lot of other sports playoffs in my opinion. I saw this first-hand when the Washington Capitals won and how the whole city of D.C., Virginia, and Maryland came together (yes we see you bandwagon fans). It's a sport that's fast, exciting and brings people together.

May the best team win.

Related Content

Facebook Comments