If You Become a Parent, Don't Circumcise Your Child
Start writing a post

If You Become A Parent, Don't Circumcise Your Child

Male circumcision is unnecessary and unethical.

If You Become A Parent, Don't Circumcise Your Child

The decision to circumcise a child is often an easy one for American parents. Usually, the father is circumcised, and every male in the family has been for generations. It's a tradition that many accept without pausing to consider the consequences. Myths and falsehoods about circumcision abound, which perpetuate the practice. Yet, there are many valid criticisms of circumcision that deserve consideration.

First, circumcision is an unnecessary medical procedure. This isn't merely an opinion; it is a fact. Every major medical organization in America acknowledges that circumcision is not necessary; no major medical organization recommends routine circumcision of all boys. Circumcision can have the potential effect of reducing the risk of UTI infections, but these affect less than 1% of newborns. Circumcision can also reduce the risk of penile cancer, but this disease is quite uncommon.

Circumcision has been the most effective at reducing rates of HIV, and is highly encouraged in African nations, but in a developed country like the United States that doesn't have a high rate of HIV infection (compared to a country like South Africa), ensuring the populace has easy access to condoms and promoting safe sex should be enough to prevent the spread of HIV. Additionally, HIV rates are lower in Northern and Western Europe and most European men aren't circumcised so the likelihood that routine male circumcision would lower the HIV rate in the US is quite slim.

Despite popular belief, penises with foreskin are not less healthy than penises without foreskin. Keeping uncircumcised penises clean is not a hassle. One merely has to pull back the foreskin and wash to maintain proper hygiene, just like any other body part. Of course, if someone neglects to properly clean their foreskin, that could lead to health problems; but there's no reason to chop off foreskin, when parents could instead just teach boys how to keep their foreskin clean.

Additionally, the foreskin serves many important biological functions; it is far more than "extra skin." The foreskin has thousands of nerve endings that give men sexual pleasure; in fact, circumcision became popular in the middle of the 20th century because it was thought to prevent boys from masturbating. The foreskin protects the opening of the penis from infection and irritation. It helps provide natural lubrication during sex and prevents chafing. It also ensures that erections aren't too painful by covering the head of the penis as it is engorged. The foreskin is not a birth defect. It is a normal part of the male body with legitimate biological functions.

Lastly, the practice of circumcising baby boys violates the principle of bodily autonomy. Babies, precisely because they are babies, cannot give informed consent to any medical operation. The parents, of course, are the ones giving consent. Yet, the foreskin is a part of the child's body, and a child's body is not the property of his parents. In the field of bioethics, it is generally accepted that parents can only consent for a medical operation on their child if such an operation is necessary to save the child's life or protect the child's health.

Circumcision definitely isn't necessary and has only a few potential benefits. Thus, if we truly believe in the principle of bodily autonomy, the idea that people should have full control over their own bodies, which is a cornerstone of human rights and has played a role in several Supreme Court decisions, notably Roe v. Wade, then we must reject the practice of circumcision as it exists today in America: as a surgical procedure forced upon baby boys who cannot possibly consent to it.

Circumcision is clearly a questionable practice. It is an unnecessary medical procedure with only a few potential benefits; it removes a normal body part that serves important biological functions, which provide tangible benefits; and from a bioethics standpoint, it can be seen to violate the bodily autonomy of baby boys. For reasons both practical and theoretical, we should all say no to circumcision.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.

College as Told by The Lord of the Rings Memes

One does not simply pass this article.


College as told by the Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit memes. Everyone will be Tolkien about it.

Keep Reading... Show less

A Tribute To The Lonely Hispanic

In honor of Hispanic Heritage Month, I’d like to share a few thoughts about being Hispanic in a country where it’s hard to be Hispanic.

Veronika Maldonado

Just a little background information; my dad was born in Mexico, came to the U.S. as a newborn and became a citizen when he was 25 years old. My mom was born and raised in the U.S. as were my grandparents and great grandparents, but my great-great grandparents did migrate here from Mexico. I am proud to classify myself as Hispanic but there are times when I feel like I’m living a double life and I don’t fit into either one.

Keep Reading... Show less

Dear College Football

It's not you, it's me.


Dear College Football,

Keep Reading... Show less

Hurricane Preparedness

In Louisiana and many other states, it is important to have a hurricane plan

Munger Construction

With hurricane season, it's always best to be prepared for it. It means having a plan for your family and home. Everyone in Louisiana should know the basics of preparing for hurricane season.

Keep Reading... Show less

An Atlanta Weekend

A New Yorker's quick weekend in Atlanta.


On a weekend visit to Atlanta, I had to adjust to people being personable and congenial to me. Although I had lived in the South before, I had to get reacquainted with southern hospitality due to visiting from Brooklyn. Atlanta Uber drivers are very down to earth, offer snacks, and provide great genuine conversations. The opposite is the lay of the land from Brooklyn Uber drivers. The southern hospitality is provided not only from the Uber drivers, but restaurant servers, cashiers, or random people giving suggestions. Brooklyn is a dope and unique place to live, but short on the warmth more often than not.

Keep Reading... Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments