A Look At Cultural Appropriation Within The Hip-Hop Culture

A Look At Cultural Appropriation Within The Hip-Hop Culture

There is always a lesson to be learned.
2345
views

I’ve heard a lot about cultural appropriation since it has recently become such a hot topic in the media - specifically within the world of hip-hop. One thing I’ve heard the most is the opinion that it's more than just a genre of music; it is also a lifestyle and a culture, and I completely agree. Hip-hop was born in the ghettos of the South Bronx as a way for black people to express themselves in a style that was all their own. As time went on, the music became more popular and reached the mainstream airwaves.

With its growing popularity, hip-hop crossed over into pop music and the lines began to blur as artists from each genre began to collaborate. Pop artists began adopting the hip-hop style; everything from hair and clothing styles to dancing and musical sound. Many white artists have fallen victim to criticism for “trying to be black,” but what does being black mean exactly? What does it mean to appropriate a culture?

I came across a video about this topic a while ago. In the video, actress Amandla Stenberg talks about appropriation by describing what it means to be black. She uses the term “black identity” with examples of how white artists in the media have taken the culture and sort of repurposed it for themselves as an expression of style. Stenberg talks a lot about the importance of black hairstyles as a part of the black identity and the role these hairstyles play in the hip-hop culture. She mentions white artists who have since been seen wearing hairstyles such as cornrows and wearing clothing and accessories specific to hip-hop/black culture. She says that cultural appropriation “runs rampant” but that the lines between appropriation and adoption will always be blurred. Stenberg then goes on to give the best definition of appropriation I’ve ever heard. She says “appropriation occurs when a style leads to racist generalizations or stereotypes where it originated but is deemed as high fashion, cool or funny when the privileged take it for themselves.”

The first time I heard the term “cultural appropriation” was in my Intro to Mass Communications class my sophomore year of college. In that class, we were discussing Miley Cyrus’s performance at the 2013 MTV Video Music Awards. The issue with her performance, some may say, is that it was tasteless and inappropriate. While that may be true, the bigger issue some people had with it was the twerking. For most of that year, Miley was the poster child for cultural appropriation. So, what is twerking? Urban Dictionary defines it as “the act of moving/ shaking one's ass/buns/bottom/buttocks/bum-bum in a circular, up-and-down, and side-to-side motion.” Twerking was known as a “black” dance, so when Miley first showed off her new moves at a Juicy J concert back in 2013, the media, of course, went crazy. Everyone was talking about how well Miley could dance and “who knew a white girl from Nashville could move like a black girl!”

The problem wasn’t Miley’s twerking, however. The problem was her use of actual black girls as props in her music videos and stage performances. All of her backup dancers were black women with big butts who twerked around her. A lot of people were outraged by this, and until that class discussion, I hadn’t really given it much thought. I thought Miley Cyrus was awesome and that her new style was working for her. After all, there’s nothing wrong with stirring the pot a little. I never thought of her as appropriating black culture, but referring back to the definition that Stenberg gives and applying the devices Miley has used to break out of her “good girl” Disney image, I would certainly say that she fits the bill. Before Miley started twerking, the dance was mainly seen in hip-hop music videos, where the women are of course oversexualized and objectified, and in strip clubs. In other words, it was a trashy dance that black women did to look sexy for men. When Miley started twerking it became “cool," and young white girls started doing it too - which not only cast a bad light on Miley as a role model but also solidified her role as an appropriator.

Miley is not the only artist who has previously been in the media for this same offense. Rapper Iggy Azalea has gotten even more backlash for her music and style. Iggy is a white, blonde Australian rapper who has blown up the charts in the hip-hop world. Some people support her, but some people think that her origin and race don’t belong in the hip-hop culture. Azealia Banks, a black rapper from the Bronx, has been the most vocal in her distaste for Iggy. Banks is no stranger to twitter feuds, and is known for lashing out at other artists for various reasons, but her most on-going war has been about her opinion that Iggy’s music cannot be considered hip-hop and as a result, Iggy does not deserve all the credit she has received.

Banks first lashed out in regards to Iggy back in 2012. Iggy was featured on XXL’s annual freshmen cover as the only female rapper on the list. Banks fired off a series of tweets discrediting the magazine’s choice, including “I’m not anti white girl, but I’m also not here for any1 outside my culture trying to trivialize very serious aspects of it,” and “Sorry guys. But I’m pro black girl.” While Iggy defended herself, that was not the last we heard from Banks. In a 2014 interview with hosts Ebro and Peter Rosenberg from Hot 97, Banks explained her issue with Iggy and the music world in general.

I am an Iggy Azalea fan and I do not personally like Azealia Banks, and the first time I listened to this interview I thought “who the hell does she think she is?” But after listening to it again and considering every aspect of it (and not just being defensive of Iggy), I understood that Banks is less interested in bashing Iggy and more interested in bringing to light a problem that is at its peak within black/hip-hop culture.

“I feel like in this country, whenever it comes to our things, like black issues or black politics or black music or whatever, there’s always this undercurrent of kind of like a f*ck you,” said Banks in the interview. She explains that there’s a sort of “cultural smudging” when it comes to things that black people own or create, because when white people take it for their own, they get the credit - which comes back to this idea of appropriating the culture. Banks gives the example of The Grammys, and how in previous years, white hip-hop artists have been beating out black hip-hop artists for awards like Best Hip-Hop Album or Favorite Hip-Hop Artist. She mentions Macklemore beating Drake for Favorite Hip-Hop Album and says that his album wasn’t better than Drake’s. Banks says "The Grammys are supposed to be accolades of artistic excellence. Iggy Azalea is not excellent…and when they give these Grammy’s out all it says to white kids ‘oh yeah you’re great’…and it says to black kids ‘you don’t own shit, not even the shit you created for yourself,” said Banks. Not only did she talk about the music, but she also brought up the racial injustices that have been brought to the forefront with the deaths of Trayvon Martin, Michael Brown, Eric Garner and the like. Stenberg also mentions this in her video; White artists who adopt black culture and participate in “blackness” did not speak out on the issues that were plaguing the black community, and Banks criticizes Iggy specifically for staying silent on these matters.

I have to say that agree with her on the issue of The Grammys. It’s been said many times that black Hip-Hop doesn’t get a fair chance at The Grammys because the people who pick the winners are of a completely different age group and demographic than the black nominees, and therefore pick the artists with the most media buzz as the winners. For them, it is about ratings. At the time, Iggy and Macklemore were creating more of a stir than their black counterparts so they won.

Now, while I thoroughly enjoyed both of their albums, I do think the method is a bit unfair. Macklemore himself couldn’t believe he beat Kendrick Lamar and said he shouldn’t have. As for the injustice, I honestly didn’t even notice that they hadn’t commented until Banks pointed it out. And I have mixed emotions on that subject because on one hand, I understand the anger that Banks was expressing: in that if you are going to partake in a culture apart from your own and adopt and promote that culture, you are not exempt from the issues that said culture experiences. On the other hand, I feel that making these observations and shaming people for not speaking out is not doing anything to help solve the problem. If anything, it just drives more of a riff between cultures and races; and it takes the spotlight away from the victims who need to be advocated for.

Macklemore even went on the same radio show after Azealia Banks to give his opinion on the matter. He gives a very good response when asked about why white hip-hop artists did not seem to say anything about these racial injustices. “Silence is an action,” he says, “and I’ve been silent for a long time because I didn’t want to mess up, I didn’t want to offend anybody. But I’m tired of being silent.” He says that, as a white rapper, he has the privilege of staying silent; but watching everything that has gone on has made him sick and that this conversation needs to be had in order to progress in this country. Ebro agrees with him by saying that because people are so quick to dismiss someone’s feelings, the conversation gets pushed aside and ignored. Out of sight, out of mind.

Getting back to the music, much of Macklemore’s interview is a discussion about the progression of hip-hop music into the mainstream and the resulting “whiteness” that has become the genre. Peter Rosenberg notes that when he first discovered hip-hop he didn’t want to hear white rappers, he wanted to learn about black rappers and black culture. He also notes that since it became mainstream, white kids got into it and as a result wanted to see rappers who looked like them. The interview continues on with this debate and Ebro asks Macklemore if he thinks his music was embraced by white radio because he’s a white rapper and Macklemore says yes. Peter Rosenberg then expands on the question by asking “If a black rapper had made Can’t Hold us, you don’t think it necessarily would’ve had the same effect?” Macklemore replies with “Why am I safe? Why can I cuss on a record, have a parental advisory sticker on the cover of my album, yet parents are still like ‘You’re the only rap I let my kids listen to’?”

I think Macklemore makes a very valid point with his response. While he posed it as a question, it spoke volumes more than any straightforward answer would have. Macklemore is right, he is seen as “safe.” And I know for a fact that if I were a parent, I would let my kids listen to him before I even considered letting them listen to Drake or Lil Wayne or Kanye. There's a difference between me and the parents Macklemore is using as an example. He is saying they let their kids listen to his music because he’s white, and because of his whiteness he must be wholesome and decent. My reason for not letting my imaginary/future kids listen to the black rappers I mentioned is not because they are black, but the content of the majority of their music does deal heavily with sex and drugs. That being said, I would also prohibit my kids from listening to Iggy Azalea and Eminem because they also produce content that I would not want my children to be immersed in. And furthermore, if there were any songs on Macklemore’s album that I deemed unfit for little ears, then they would be prohibited too. For me, it is not about race, it is about content. I like all of the artists I mentioned above, and I guess it makes me a hypocrite that I’ve been listening to all of them since they each came out, but I want to make a point that it shouldn’t matter what color the artist is. If the content is inappropriate, that should be the deciding factor.

One last thing I wanted to touch on was Amandla Stenberg. Her video, which is titled “Don’t Cash Crop my Cornrows,” is not just about the appropriation of black hairstyles. That is used as a metaphor for the deeper issue that has stemmed from centuries of oppression of the black community. “Appropriation occurs when the appropriator is not aware of the deep significance of the culture they are partaking in,” Stenberg says. She then goes on to say that hip-hop stems not only from a black struggle but from jazz and blues “that African Americans created to retain humanity in the face of adversity, which itself stems from songs used during slavery to communicate and survive.”

This topic needs to be emphasized because it has such deep roots, and those who partake in the culture because they think it’s cool or fun need to be educated on the significance of the identity created by the black community. There needs to be a line drawn in the sand between adopting/adding to a culture and appropriating it because there is a significant difference.

There is always a lesson to be learned in these debates. People, regardless of racial, economic, social or political background, should educate themselves about the issues that arise. Sure, the argument is valid that some white artists are guilty of appropriating black/hip-hop culture, but like I said, pointing fingers doesn’t help solve the issue. The way I see it, Azealia Banks is just as guilty of fueling the fire negatively as the artists she accuses. While appropriation within the hip-hop culture is only one sect of the racial debate, it still affects not only this generation but the generations to come. These are the people we look up to as young kids and adults. These are the people we see and want to emulate, so if they start the conversation and assist in educating not only themselves but their fans, then progress will soon be on the horizon.

Cover Image Credit: blackgirllonghair.com

Popular Right Now

To The Senior Graduating High School In A Month

"What feels like the end, is often the beginning."
36679
views

It wasn’t too long ago that I was in your shoes. Just a little over a year ago, I was the senior that had a month left. One month left in the hometown that I grew up in. One month left with the friends that I didn’t want to leave. One month left in the place that I had called “my school” for the past four years. You are probably thinking the same things I thought whenever it came down to only 30 days left. You’re probably scared, nervous, worried, or anxious. Maybe you’re like me and are dying to get out of high school, ready to start a new chapter. Or maybe you aren’t so ready yet. Maybe you’re wishing for a little more time.

As scary as it is, this month you have left will fly by. You’ll blink and you’ll be standing in your cap and gown, waiting for your name to be called to receive your diploma. You’ll look back on your last four years at your school and wonder why time went by so fast. It’ll be bittersweet. However, trust me when I say that you have so much to look forward to. You are about to begin taking the steps to build your future. You are going to grow and learn so much more than any high school class could teach you. You are going to meet amazing people and accomplish amazing things. So, as scared as you might be, I encourage you to take that first step out of your comfort zone and face this world head on. Chase your dreams and work towards your goals. You are smart. You are brave. You are capable of achieving amazing things. All your life, the lessons you have learned have prepared you for this point in your life. You are more than ready.

There are times when you will feel alone, scared, or confused. There are times when it won’t always be easy. But those are the times when you will shine the most because I know you will work through whatever problems you may face. Don’t think of the bad times as a terrible thing. Use them all as learning experiences. As author Joshua Marine once said, “Challenges are what make life interesting and overcoming them is what makes life meaningful.”

You might think that this is the end. However, it’s not. This is only the beginning. Trust me when I say that the adventures and opportunities you are about to face are nothing compared to high school. Whether you are going to college, going to work, or something else, this is the beginning of your journey called life. It will be exciting, it will be terrifying, but it will all be worth it.

So, as you walk out of your high school for the very last time, I encourage you to take a deep breath. Relax. You’ll always have the memories to look back on from high school. But your time is now, it begins today. Embrace it.

Cover Image Credit: http://i.huffpost.com/gen/1152445/images/o-HIGH-SCHOOL-GRADUATION-facebook.jpg

Related Content

Connect with a generation
of new voices.

We are students, thinkers, influencers, and communities sharing our ideas with the world. Join our platform to create and discover content that actually matters to you.

Learn more Start Creating

A Beginner's Guide to Milwaukee Sports

Part I: The Bucks

287
views

Being a college student in Milwaukee has its perks, especially for sports fans. Now, while some may have brought their hometown teams to college, others (myself included) may have warmed up to the Cream City teams without knowing much about them. If this is the case for you, then these pointers can help you start enjoying Milwaukee basketball without looking and sounding like a bandwagon fan.

Quick History

www.nba.com

Here are some facts about the Bucks that can make you feel more knowledgeable about the franchise:

- They have only won one championship (back in 1971) and have lost one NBA Finals series (1974) (Land of Basketball)

- They have only had one* MVP-caliber player in Kareem Abdul-Jabbar (#33) during the 1971, 1972, and 1974 seasons (Land of Basketball)

- Other Notable Players Include: Oscar Robertson (#1), Sidney Moncrief (#4), Jon McGlocklin (#14) and Ray Allen (#34) (Land of Basketball)

*Giannis Antetokounmpo may win the MVP award this year

sited: https://www.landofbasketball.com/teams/milwaukee_bucks.htm

Gear Up

https://twitter.com/bucksproshop/status/982026548705415168

This one is a bit of a no-brainer. Wearing team's colors or spirit wear is a must, especially if you're going to a game. Most items like hats and t-shirts are perfectly acceptable, and these are great if you're not trying to break the bank. Buying your gear from a sporting goods store will usually be cheaper than buying them from the team store (the main one of which is located in Fiserv Forum). Most online stores like NBA.com, Fanatics, Fansedge, and sometimes even the team's online store will have sales on sports gear, so getting a good deal on team wear is always a plus!

A Word of Caution: Jerseys

All three of these players are not part of the 2018-2019 roster and #77 and #3 have been reused by current players Ersan Ilyasova (#77) and George Hill (#3)

www.nba.com

If you're willing to go the extra mile, buying a jersey can really get you into locked in and pumped for the live action. However, it should be kept in mind that official Nike NBA jerseys range from $110-$250, so they definitely are an investment. While there are other options available like the FastBreak jerseys by Fanatics, they are a simpler (still official) knockoff of the Nike jerseys. Also; beware buying sale jerseys. There are usually three reasons why jerseys are ever on sale (aside from a storewide sale): a player is injured, a player doesn't play much and is about to be traded, or a player has been traded. While there is nothing wrong with having the jersey of a player who went on to another team (like Kareem and Allen), you are not exactly going to get brownie points for wearing a Jabari Parker or a Thon Maker jersey anytime soon.

Know The Current Squad

Fiserv Forum, Home of the Milwaukee Bucks

www.nba.com

Everyone in Milwaukee has heard of Giannis Antetokounmpo, but who else is part of the supporting cast?

Starting Five for the 2018-2019 Milwaukee Bucks (Basketball Reference):

- #6 Eric Bledsoe at Point Guard

- #13 Malcolm "The President" Brogdon at Shooting Guard

- #22 Khris "Money" Middleton at Small Forward

- #34 Giannis "The Greek Freak" Antetokounmpo at Power Forward

- #11 Brook "Splash Mountain" Lopez at Center

Student Perk

www.nba.com

Using your university email, you can get special discount ticket offers for home games by signing up for the Bucks' Student Rush Program. Tickets usually start at $15 per ticket, and the seats available may depend on who the Bucks are playing (and how well they are doing during the season).

Get Involved and Have Fun!

Mascot Crawl GIF by NBA - Find & Share on GIPHY Giphy

Don't be afraid to get into it! The Bucks are an amazing team to watch and they love Bucks Nation. In addition to cheering at games, going to team events and player appearances can be great ways to make memories and even get an autograph or two!

Are You a Bucks Fan Now?🦌

media1.tenor.com

I think Giannis would agree!

Related Content

Facebook Comments