Harvard Lawsuit And Racism
Start writing a post
Life Stages

Harvard's Racism Against Asians Isn't Because Of Affirmative Action; It's Bias

There's a genuine bias against Asian Americans, but removing affirmative action is not the best case of action

654
Harvard's Racism Against Asians Isn't Because Of Affirmative Action; It's Bias
https://pixabay.com/en/student-people-latin-school-person-2816892/

After graduation is over, the new class of seniors face the college application process ahead. There is a lot of information hidden from students applying to college, and it leads to the proliferation of private counseling and tutoring services as families get desperate to land their kids a spot at Harvard, MIT, Stanford, Yale or Princeton.

There are parts of the college application that are completely in the student's control, such as the SAT/ACT, GPA and course rigor. Other parts, such as the essays, recommendations, interviews, and extracurricular activities section, are less objective since not everyone will have the same opinion of your profile or personality.

But what garners controversy is what people do not have control over, such as their race or sex. In a perfect world without bias, this would be easily set aside, because race is not a good indicator of who someone really is or what they can achieve. But in our world, some people are inherently disadvantaged because of how society has structurally set them up to be from the very beginning. This is why affirmative action exists. African Americans and Hispanics are less likely to graduate from high school and go onto college.

However to say that this does not cause issues would be an oversight of nuance.

In a current lawsuit against Harvard University, Students for Fair Admissions (a coalition of Asian-American students suing the university) claim that the school has a negative bias against Asian-Americans. Again, before discussing this further, it is important to mention that this trial has conservative bias, as the Trump Administration is in support of the students, and the lawyers behind the student group also lean conservative.

The student group aims to release decades worth of information behind Harvard's admissions process. Harvard scores each applicant on a scale from one to six in academics, extracurriculars, athletics, personality and overall. Asian-Americans in comparison to other races were more likely to be described as "standard strong" which meant that a student was qualified but lacked truly special qualities, and in the same vein, recieved lower personality ratings.

Personally, as a Latina, I cannot vouch for any experiences that Asian students may have, and it would be intellectually dishonest for me to do so. I can say, however, that minorities will not end up taking an over-represented race's spot. Latinos are less likely to apply to college and chase four-year degrees, so there is no real competition between Asians and Latinos here.

In my family, no one is really required to chase after college, even though most are capable and do so, even if it is not immediately after high school. The likelihood that someone in my family even has Harvard on their radar is rare, not because they think that they don't need a good education but because there are more ways to do so that are much easier. If one of us gets into Harvard, we'll party; any excuse is a good excuse to get together, trust me.

In fact, the group mentions that a change in Harvard's approach would lead to a decrease in white students at the university more than underrepresented minorities. On the other hand, in the documents the group also says that, "What Harvard will not admit — but what the record shows — is that race is not only an important factor; it is the dominant consideration in admitting Hispanics and African Americans."

I find this contradictory to what they say about how white applicants will be the most affected by a change in the application process, yet they still say that this problem is caused by the consideration for the admission of Hispanics and African Americans. Why would affirmative action need to be changed then in that case? The only thing that needs to be fixed here is the school's attitude on Asian Americans, not affirmative action in general.

Some of the statistics that the group uses are also flawed, as they are based on the premise that only the academic factor should be considered. The issue with that is that richer students will end up with higher SAT scores. Also in the same vein, Hispanics and African Americans make less than Asians and Whites.

I feel that the students here have a genuine argument for change, but I do not feel that the blame lies on affirmative action. I do not think that removing affirmative action will fully resolve the issues that the students are seeing. There is an inherent bias against Asian Americans but why should that mean taking out your anger on others who are disadvantaged as well? If you were to remove it, how can you be assured that anything would really change?

Let us say that affirmative action is removed, and as usual, the same amount of students applied to the school with the application process being generally the same. I do not think that the schools will entirely change their stance on diversity, and if about the same amount of Asian Americans apply, won't the same issues occur? Asian Americans are assumed to have the same personality which is a racist generalization, and you can't expect that to change with the elimination of one factor. They already said that the main groups that are competing against each other in this situation are Asians and whites, not Asians and other underrepresented minorities. Minorities are not taking away an Asian's seat at the table, I assure you.

The best solution for this is a change in attitude at the fundamental level, which does not include changing affirmative action. I think that this lawsuit can achieve change; I just feel that they aren't attacking the right policy.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Featured

Panic! At The Disco Announces Breakup After 19 Years

Band Makes Breakup Announcement Official: 'Will Be No More'

2623
panic at the disco

It's the end of an era. Originally formed in 2004 by friends in Las Vegas, Panic! At The Disco is no more.

Brendon Urie announced on Instagram that the band will be coming to an end after the upcoming Europe tour. He said that he and his wife are expecting a baby, and the life change weighed heavily in his mind to come to this decision. "Sometimes a journey must end for a new one to begin," he said.

Keep Reading... Show less
Content Inspiration

Top 3 Response Articles of This Week

Odyssey's response writer community is growing- read what our new writers have to say!

6393
https://www.pexels.com/photo/person-writing-on-white-book-1043514/
https://www.pexels.com/photo/person-typing-on-type...

Each week, more response writers are joining the Odyssey community. We're excited to spotlight their voices on as they engage in constructive dialogue with our community. Here are the top three response articles of last week:

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

To Mom

There are days when you just need your mom

18136
To Mom

There really is no way to prepare yourself for the loss of someone. Imagine that someone being the one who carried you for 9th months in their belly, taught you how to walk, fought with you about little things that only a mother and daughter relationship could understand. You can have a countless number of father figures in your life, but really as my mom always said, " you only get one mom."

Keep Reading... Show less
Swoon

The Way People In Society are Dating is Why I Don't Date

I need someone to show that they want me for me, not that they're using me to chase the idea of being in a relationship.

20372
The Way People In Society are Dating is Why I Don't Date
rawpixel

You hear your phone go off. He's asking you to hang out. Then, of course, you get the advice of your friends to decipher this text. Is it just hanging out or is it more than hanging out? You've probably done this at least once in your life or at least seen a tweet where someone posted their screenshots with a potential love interest.

Keep Reading... Show less
Student Life

Winter Break As Told By 'Friends'

Is a month at home too much to handle?

12962

If you're anything like me, winter break is a much-needed light at the end of the tunnel after a long, stressful semester. Working hard for 15 weeks can really take a toll on a person mentally, physically AND emotionally. It's a nice change of pace to be back at home with your family and friends, but after a couple weeks, it can get, well... boring.

Keep Reading... Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments