From Epic to Hellenic: Part Six of Six

From Epic to Hellenic: Part Six of Six

Coming Full Circle
2
views

This is part the last :) of a six part article exploring the Classical traditions of heroism. My high school philosopher teacher once remarked that one can perceive perfection as a balance. With that in mind, consider the idea that perfection in a hero is found in the balance of masculinity and femininity.

This source (Rutherford) renders itself useful as it discusses the luck or fate of the heroes and how they are different. Aeneas suffers both loss of love and death whereas the other two heroes suffered significantly less. Ironically enough, the hero who is remembered the most and considered the smartest is in fact Achilles. Achilles suffers unto death whereas the two other heroes survive. This develops the question: why are the so called Homeric heroes so different from one another and do those differences prove anything about the mentality of the heroes? Drawing from this source, one can deduce that the Homeric hero changes to reflect the power of the civilization.

The Aeneid is the story of Aeneas of Troy, whose home was destroyed. Aeneas is a pious man fated to be the founder of the Roman Empire. First Aeneas sets sail from burning Troy and encounters tough waves and weather. Aeneas lands in Carthage where he meets Queen Dido. Dido is shot with a love arrow and falls in love with Aeneas and they begin an affair. Dido then kills herself when Aeneas leaves. Aeneas goes down into the Underworld with the Sybil. Later, Aeneas staged a huge war with the Latins, wins, and his descendants find Rome. While the Aeneid featured the man and the journey, it is an example of Romans trying to be deliberately better than Greeks. Aeneas constantly is praised throughout the work. Any mistake that Aeneas makes is justified as a sign of the piety of Aeneas. Furthermore, hubris is not a large part of the Aeneid. The same deadly pride that is a key characteristic of the Homeric hero is not present here. The reason being Virgil wants to illustrate that Aeneas is the better hero. Nethercut focuses on the oddities of the Aeneid. Particularly on the fact that Aeneas goes into the Underworld (which requires a death of sorts) and has two people die, he enters the gate of false dreams, and recalls a fighting scene in book twenty of the Iliad. The one in particular to focus on is the fact that in Odyssey and Iliad, only death occurs before the hero descends into the Underworld whereas in the Aeneid, Aeneas has to experience two deaths.

One death occurring before being able to cross over to the other side is a common and almost necessary part of mythology, however the double death hints at the death of both the men and the death of Greece. Again this is another instance where Vergil tries to upstage Homer. Homer only has the one death and then in the Iliad, Aeneas almost dies, but is spared. To the first point, the two deaths signify that something died on top of the original death required to enter the Underworld. The Underworld and mythology requires this, but does not require two deaths thus Vergil is trying to say that Aeneas suffered more and still did better. Another important part of this article is the fact that it discusses how throwing rocks recalls the part of the Iliad where Aeneas almost dies. Vergil brings this up to essentially declare that Aeneas lives due to strength and that he can overcome so much. This is a jab at Homer and the Greeks, even though much of the Aeneid is centered about the Homeric tradition. When Vergil synthesizes both the Iliad and the Odyssey, he adds a new spin to the idea of the Homeric hero to define heroism for Rome.

Achilles is the hero of the Iliad and Odysseus is the hero of the Odyssey. However, one must wonder how Homer developed these two epics. Important to note is that Odysseus did not have a large role in the Iliad until the very end of the poem where Odysseus as the mastermind of the Trojan Horse shines through. Before that, Odysseus claimed to be mad by plowing the sand to avoid the draft. However, Scott argues that one of Achilles’s largest flaws was his inability to be cunning, so in some sense Homer emphasized a two-fold idea of the Homeric hero. Achilles was more of strength while Odysseus had a higher mental capacity.

The idea of the two types of heroes readily supports the idea that Vergil attempts to combine both types of the Homeric hero through Aeneas. Aeneas’s fatal flaw is arguably his overt piety, but Aeneas has the best of both Odysseus and Achilles. Aeneas’s cunning manifests itself throughout the whole epic poem when he cleverly discerns how to deal with the war of the Latins and navigating the Underworld. The physical brawn that Aeneas has is shown through his fighting. While Aeneas is depicted as wearing excessive amounts of expensive clothing, an important characteristic to note is the fact that Aeneas is physically strong and a big man. It seems as though Vergil attempted to outshine Homer by taking only the best aspects of the Homeric heroes and minimizing the flaws that he gave them to create Aeneas. Aeneas does not make as many mistakes as Homeric heroes do along with the fact that Aeneas is presented as only adhering to piety, which in a sense excuses his flaws.

This article explores how the Homeric tradition does not traditionally or even mostly dictate how the Aeneid was composed. The inductions of all three epics carry some differences, however only between the Aeneid and the Homeric epic poetry is the difference apparent. The Aeneid up front enumerates Aeneas’s journey and provides a mini plot summary while Homer opts to wait to do this. Additionally, Homer focuses more on the aspects of Olympus than Vergil does. The concept of Olympus and the gods’ place there is more stressed in the Homeric epics and barely mentioned in the Aeneid. Another aspect is the fact that Vergil attributes far more to fama than Homer does. Homer’s epic poetry presents itself more as fact than plausible rumor while Vergil personifies fama and focuses on the antiqua of Carthage to promote Rome.

The most useful part of this article is the breaking of Homeric tradition that Vergil uses to elevate Aeneas as a hero. The problem that Vergil faces when writing the Aeneid is the fact that Iliad and Odyssey are older works of note and the Aeneid is more contemporary since Rome came to fruition later historically. Vergil (mostly Augustus) wants to drive home the point that Rome’s historical beginnings are as impressive if not more impressive than Greece’s history. Thus Vergil attempts to break from Homeric tradition by mentioning the antiquity of the cities that Aeneas interacts with and most importantly, using rumor to creatively emphasize the point that since Rome was founded a long time ago, some of the founding story is based on rumor.

Cover Image Credit: On the Screen Reviews

Popular Right Now

30 Things I'd Rather Be Than 'Pretty'

Because "pretty" is so overrated.
32094
views

Nowadays, we put so much emphasis on our looks. We focus so much on the outside that we forget to really focus on what matters. I was inspired by a list that I found online of "Things I Would Rather Be Called Instead Of Pretty," so I made my own version. Here is a list of things that I would rather be than "pretty."

1. Captivating

I want one glance at me to completely steal your breath away.

2. Magnetic

I want people to feel drawn to me. I want something to be different about me that people recognize at first glance.

3. Raw

I want to be real. Vulnerable. Completely, genuinely myself.

4. Intoxicating

..and I want you addicted.

5. Humble

I want to recognize my abilities, but not be boastful or proud.

6. Exemplary

I want to stand out.

7. Loyal

I want to pride myself on sticking out the storm.

8. Fascinating

I want you to be hanging on every word I say.

9. Empathetic

I want to be able to feel your pain, so that I can help you heal.

10. Vivacious

I want to be the life of the party.

11. Reckless

I want to be crazy. Thrilling. Unpredictable. I want to keep you guessing, keep your heart pounding, and your blood rushing.

12. Philanthropic

I want to give.

13. Philosophical

I want to ask the tough questions that get you thinking about the purpose of our beating hearts.

14. Loving

When my name is spoken, I want my tenderness to come to mind.

15. Quaintrelle

I want my passion to ooze out of me.

16. Belesprit

I want to be quick. Witty. Always on my toes.

17. Conscientious

I want to always be thinking of others.

18. Passionate

...and I want people to know what my passions are.

19. Alluring

I want to be a woman who draws people in.

20. Kind

Simply put, I want to be pleasant and kind.

21. Selcouth

Even if you've known me your whole life, I want strange, yet marvelous. Rare and wondrous.

22. Pierian

From the way I move to the way I speak, I want to be poetic.

23. Esoteric

Do not mistake this. I do not want to be misunderstood. But rather I'd like to keep my circle small and close. I don't want to be an average, everyday person.

24. Authentic

I don't want anyone to ever question whether I am being genuine or telling the truth.

25. Novaturient

..about my own life. I never want to settle for good enough. Instead I always want to seek to make a positive change.

26. Observant

I want to take all of life in.

27. Peart

I want to be honestly in good spirits at all times.

28. Romantic

Sure, I want to be a little old school in this sense.

29. Elysian

I want to give you the same feeling that you get in paradise.

30. Curious

And I never want to stop searching for answers.
Cover Image Credit: Favim

Related Content

Connect with a generation
of new voices.

We are students, thinkers, influencers, and communities sharing our ideas with the world. Join our platform to create and discover content that actually matters to you.

Learn more Start Creating

13 Taylor Swift Lyrics About Love

“We could get married. Have 10 kids and teach em how to dream."

307
views

Taylor Swift is the only reason I've gotten through every love, and every break-up. Here's a list of 13 lyrics/quotes about love from Taylor Swift's albums.

“Losing him was blue like I’ve never known. Missing him was dark grey all alone. Forgetting him was like trying to know somebody you never met. Loving him was red.”

"Red" from the album "Red." This song perfectly describes every feeling that radiates through your entire being when you love and then lose someone.

“I wish we could go back, and remember what we were fighting for. I wish you knew that, I miss you too much to be mad anymore. I wish you were right here, right now, it’s all good. I wish you would.”

"I Wish You Would" from 1989. Sometimes I wish it was acceptable to just blast Taylor Swift during an argument because I totally would.

“You learn my secrets and you figure out why I’m guarded. You say we’ll never make my parents mistake.”

"Mine" from Speak Now. Let's surpass everyone's expectations.

“My baby’s fly like a jet stream, high above the whole scene, loves me like I’m brand new.” 

"Call It What You Want To" from the Reputation album. Once in a lifetime, there's someone who looks at your scars and calls you strong and brave, instead of damaged.

“My mother accused me of losing my mind, but I swore I was fine.” 

"Dear John" from Speak now. Love makes you do crazy things.

“One night he wakes, strange look on his face. Pauses then says ‘you’re my best friend’. And you knew what it was. He is in love.” 

"You Are In Love" from the 1989 album. Swift gives me chills with this song. Every time you think you're in love, you realize that the last time wasn't even close. True love, happens once or twice, and not for everyone.

“You pull my chair out, and help me in. And you don’t know how nice that is, but I do. And you throw your head back laughing like a little kid. I think it’s strange that you think I’m funny cause, he never did. I’ve been spending the last eight months, thinking all love ever does is break, and burn, and end. But on a Wednesday, in a cafe, I watched it begin again.”

"Begin Again" from the Red album. One of my top five favorite songs. Real love shows you how you should've been treated all along.

“Why would you wanna make the very first scar? Why would you wanna break a perfectly good heart?”

"A Perfectly Good Heart" from the first Taylor Swift album. Some people are only here to take. Never to give or share.

“The rain came pouring down, when I was drowning that’s when I cold finally breathe. And by morning, gone was any trace of you, I think I am finally clean.”

'Clean' from 1989. It can take years, even lifetimes, to finally feel free from love.

“There I was again tonight, forcing laughter, faking smiles, same old tired lonely place. Walls of insincerity, shifting eyes and vacancy, vanished when I saw your face. All I can say is it was, enchanting to meet you.”

'Enchanted' from Speak Now album. Love at first sight?

“Romeo take me somewhere we can be alone, I’ll be waiting all that’s left to do is run. You’ll be the prince and I’ll be the princess, it’s a love story, baby just say yes.”

'Love Story' from Fearless album. This song makes me want to take a chance and escape with a stranger.

“I once was poison ivy, but now I’m your daisy.”

"Don't Blame Me" from Reputation. I'm only better when I'm with you.

“We could get married. Have 10 kids and teach em how to dream.”

"Starlight" from the Red album. Only certain people are worth growing with.

Related Content

Facebook Comments