Trump Declared A National Emergency To Build A Border Wall But It's Absolutely Not The Solution

Trump Declared A National Emergency To Build A Border Wall But It's Absolutely Not The Solution

A wall is not the solution to immigration problems.


President Trump declared a national emergency to build the border wall. A wall that Congress did not agree to fund and the majority of the American public does not support.

While the declaration of a national emergency is something other presidents did in the past, this time it's in defiance of the will of Congress. Our founding fathers created this system of government to provide checks and balances, and a national emergency should not be used simply to bypass Congress, or in non-emergency situations.

Nothing major has happened recently to make the immigration problem an emergency now. The only thing that happened is a change in this administration's policy that has impacted families and children more than it helped prevent any dangers from immigrants entering the country illegally.

But if there were genuinely a national emergency as the president is saying, why would he himself say that this move was not necessary?

"I didn't need to do this, but I'd rather do it much faster," Trump said. "I just want to get it done faster, that's all." Via NY Times.

The idea of building a wall from the start seems impractical and will cost much more than Trump is asking for. It is more of a symbolic thing than an actual solution.

A statistician broke down the numbers on the cost of building a wall along the nearly 2000 mile border between the U.S. and Mexico. She concluded that it would cost $25 billion! This doesn't include the cost to maintain it.

History demonstrates that walls are not a good solution. Just remember the Berlin Wall, or to go further back The Great Wall of China. And if Trump and his supporters say this wall would be more technologically advanced, it would cost even more.

The idea of building a wall goes against American principles of being a safe place for victims of war and persecution. Just read what's written on the Statue of Liberty and you'll see that this wall doesn't represent American values. We are a country of immigrants. Building a wall and vilifying immigrants in the way that Trump and his supporters are doing is un-American in my opinion.

I think all Americans can agree that the immigration system needs improvement and that we need border security, but a wall is not the solution. Facts say that the majority of illegal immigrants in the U.S. came in legally. Additionally, most of the drugs that are smuggled into the U.S. come through legal ports of entry. So, this wall will not fix the main problem. And arguably will not fix anything.

Fixing the immigration system is not an easy task and a solution has eluded us for years. We need independent experts that can come up with real solutions, not partisan policies that are not backed up with facts and there's zero evidence that they will actually fix the system or any part of it.

Popular Right Now

Irish-American History Is Just As Important As Any Other Culture, You Can't Prove Me Wrong

I cherish being Irish and I will not let anyone let me feel bad for that.


Depending on when you're reading this, Saint Patrick's day has either just passed or is around the corner. For me, Saint Patrick's day is tomorrow. I've been debating this article for some time now because I didn't know how it would be perceived. At this point, though, I feel it's important for me to get out. No, Irish people were never kept as slaves in America, and I will never be one to try and say they were. However, Irish people were treated tremendously awful in America. A lot of people tend to forget, or just try to erase entirely, the history of the Irish in America. So much so that I felt shameful for wanting to celebrate my heritage. Therefore, I want to bring to light the history that everyone brushes under the rug.

In 1845, a potato famine broke out across Ireland. This was a big deal because the Irish lived off, mainly, potatoes. They were cheap, easy to grow, and had tons of nutrients. So when the famine struck, many people either died of starvation or fled to America in seek of refuge. When the Irish arrived in America they were seen as a threat to the decency of America. People viewed them as drunk beasts, sinful savages, barbaric, violent, belligerent, stupid, and white apes. When the Irish would go to look for jobs, many times they found signs that read "Irish Need Not Apply," even when the job was hiring. Therefore, the Irish did the jobs no one wanted, and even jobs African slaves wouldn't do. The biggest example of this is when Irishmen built canals and drained swamps. They were sent to do these things because of the enormous amount of mosquitoes; in the swamp, they would get bit and ultimately die of malaria.

Also, during this time, Irish people were poor and therefore lived in the same neighborhoods as the free African Americans. A lot of the Irish people were friendly with their neighbors of color and even got into interracial relationships. Because the Irish lived in these neighborhoods they were seen as dirty and even a lot of people at this time put African Americans higher on the totem pole than Irish. One person during the time even said, "At least the black families keep their homes clean."

The main reason American's outlook on Irish people changed was that most Irishmen took up fighting for the Union in the Civil War. I make this argument, not because I think the Irish suffered more than African slaves. I don't say this in means of trying to erase the struggles of the African slaves. I do not think that any of our ancestors should have been treated the way they were. I mean to say that the Irish did in fact suffer. Irish people were treated wrongly on the basis of...nothing. Simply because my ancestors hailed from the shores of Eire, they were treated with malice. And I write this simply because I want people to remember. I want people to understand what happened.

On Saint Patrick's Day this year, next year, and for the many years to come, I want people to embrace the Irish culture. I want the folks of Irish heritage to not be ashamed of where they come from; to not be ashamed to share their culture the way I have for many years. I want everyone to have a beer, wear some green, eat a potato or two, and dance the Irish step; to celebrate the history of Irish people with a bit more understanding than before.

Related Content

Connect with a generation
of new voices.

We are students, thinkers, influencers, and communities sharing our ideas with the world. Join our platform to create and discover content that actually matters to you.

Learn more Start Creating

Our Leaders Need A 'Time-Out'

We all learned a few essential rules as children.


As I look watch the news, I can't help but wonder if the lessons we learned as children might not serve our leaders well. They seem to have forgotten these basic lessons. I am reminded of the book by Robert Fulghum "All I Really Need to Know I Learned in Kindergarten."

Watch out, hold hands, and stick together.

I think this could be useful in a couple of different contexts. First, the current divisiveness in the country doesn't serve us well. We are first and foremost, a part of the family of humankind. Differences in politics, religion, and so on come in far behind that one important attribute. What happened to the notion of agreeing to disagree?

Second, when leaders get off a plane in another country, they should remember who they came with and who they represent - "watch out, hold hands, and stick together."

Clean up your own mess.

Trump seems to take great pleasure in blaming everyone else for their "mess." The government shutdown was someone else's fault – any Democrat. When the stock market went up, he happily took credit, but when it went down, he quickly shifted gears and placed the blame on the Federal Reserve Chairman. Daily and hourly tweets out of the White House place blame on someone else for his "mess." Sadly, he still likes to blame Obama and Hillary for his mess.

Don't lie.

Politicians have always had a bad reputation when it comes to honesty. Still, the number of lies that we hear from Trump (and members of his staff) is unprecedented even for a politician.

We all learned these lessons when we were little more than five years old. Now more than any time in history I think our leaders need a " time out" to re-learn these lessons.

Related Content

Facebook Comments