An Open Letter To Mic:
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

An Open Letter To Mic:

I'm sorry you feel that way, but being white doesn't make me a racist

An Open Letter To Mic:
Mic Media

This article is in response to a video by Mic titled, “Racism is a spectrum,” the caption of which boldly claims, “Are all white people racists? Yes, of course they are. Let us explain” (Video Link – Here)

Aside from the fact that saying an entire group of people - by virtue of their skin color - is racist sounds a bit, well, racist, my writing of this article isn’t to question the validity of the argument or even its claims against white people, but rather the soundness of thelogic used in reaching its conclusion.

For those of you who are already beginning to get lost, a valid argument is one which possesses good logical structure – one which takes a form that makes it impossible for the premises to be true and the conclusion nevertheless to be false. It’s important to emphasize that when testing for validity, the premises are assumed to be true. Thus, a valid argument does not require true premises to be true.

This Is where the term “soundness,” and the source of my objection to this video’s argument, comes into play. An argument is sound if and only if the argument is 1) valid and 2) all of its premises are true. By now you should see that an argument can be perfect valid, yet imperfectly sound. Now that you’ve successfully passed Logic 101, let’s take a look at the video’s argument as presented in its summarized logical-form below:

P1 – Broadly speaking, the word “racist” is defined as, “someone who feels discrimination or prejudice to people of a different race, or feels that one race is superior to another.”

P2 – Because the definition is an either/or, a person who meets the former half while failing to meet the latter half is still, by definition, a racist.

P3 – Because people can have varying degrees of prejudice, racism is not a binary output, but rather a spectrum.

P4 – The implicit association test shows that all people have varying degrees of racial bias.

P5 – White people fall within the category of “all people.”

Ergo, “Are all white people racists? Yes, of course they are.”

Let’s take a look at the first two premises, in which the speaker defines what a racist is, only to then narrow the definition and subsequently expand the scope of those whom it describes. This one-two combo is really informal fallacy known as a straw man– an argument in which the offender creates the illusion of having completely refuted an opponent’s position through the subtle replacement of it with a different but similar position.

In the context of the video, the speaker makes use of semantics to present an either/or definition of the word “racist,” which then allows him to immediately discredit the natural counter-argument to his thesis. In doing so, the speaker misconstrues what it means to be a racist by, in his own words, using prejudice as the foundation of what racism is. Insert any number of other equally acceptable definitions of the word racism, and the argument falls apart.

Take, for instance the top definition for racism via a google search which defines racism as, “prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism directed against someone of a different race based on the belief that one’s own race is superior.” Alternatively, the Wikipedia entry on racism defines racism as “discrimination and prejudice towards people based on their race or ethnicity.” As a final example, take Merriam-Websterfor Students whichdefines racism as, “discrimination or hatred based on race.”

Notice that these three definitions all specifically include some form of action directed towards others. It’s only through the speaker’s definition – which is equivalent in meaning, but subtly different in semantics – can the scope of racism be expanded to anyone who simply possesses some degree of racial prejudice, even if such prejudice is never acted upon.

This is yet another important distinction to make – the difference between being a racist and simply having prejudice. The speaker even admits that having prejudice, alone, doesn’t necessarily make you a racist. However, rather following this concession with its logical extension – which would say that being a racist requires action motivated by this prejudice – the speaker introduces the concept of racism existing on a spectrum by which the amplitude of one’s implicit racial-bias is the more or less a means to measure their position on the spectrum of racism (listed as premise three above).

All of a sudden, those who possess more implicit prejudice are more racist than those with less implicit prejudice. Extending this logic, this means that two people – neither of whom have ever acted out of racism towards another person – can not only both be racist, but also be different levels of racist, simply because they possess different levels of bias.

Surely, no one, including those at Mic, actually takes this view. Unfortunately, though, while “Racism is a spectrum” by Mic, is, on its surface, a video that has good intentions in explaining how we all possess a degree of racial-prejudice, it falls short of constructively building on this revelation by trying to imply that prejudice, alone, carries some degree of moral equivalency to actually racism. This type of definition, and its corresponding claim against white people, is not only offensive, but also marginalizes the impact of real racism and any meaningful discussion that can be had as to how to mitigate it.

*Drops Mic*

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.

8 Spotify Playlists To Get You In The Autumn Mood

The temperature may not be very Autumn-like, but these playlists sure are.

Autumn Playlists
King of Wallpapers

Autumn is my favorite time of the year. The leaves change, pumpkin spice everything hits the shelves (thank you, world!), the 13 Nights of Halloween on Freeform (formerly abcfamily) and the temperature drops. Well, the temperature is supposed to drop. Being in south Alabama, however, means that the temperature may be relatively low early in the mornings, but you're still going to suffer in the afternoon. So if the weather outside isn't getting you in the Autumn mood, maybe these Spotify playlists will help you slip into that wonderful, Autumn state of mind.

Keep Reading...Show less
Black and white adult cat staring at the camera

As human beings, there are just some things that seem to bring us all together with the same sense of irritation. Here are a few of those annoying things that make my list. I'm sure at least some, if not most, of them make yours as well. If you can think of any more relatable annoyances that I've missed, feel free to comment on this article and let me know!

Keep Reading...Show less

First Snow

It's the Most Wonderful Time of the Year!

First Snow
Sorina Bindea

I have never understood why grown-ups complain when the leaves are all off the trees, and the temperatures take a decided turn towards the zero on the thermometer. I hear complaints about the impending winter weather, and the driving in the snow and ice. We live in Pennsylvania, so I bite my tongue instead of stating the obvious: Maybe you should move to a warmer climate?

Keep Reading...Show less


Things to do in October.


Halloween is a fun holiday for everyone of all ages. There are so many fun things to do in the month of October before Halloween and the day of Halloween. I love Halloween especially with all the candy and different types of goodies. Halloween is for everyone that enjoys to be a part of this wonderful holiday and also be careful on Halloween as well. It gives everyone a chance to show what they love to do as well.

Keep Reading...Show less

Top 10 Cranberries Songs That Will Change Your Life

A look at the treasure box, seeing what's hidden in the shadow of "Dreams," "Linger," and "Zombie"

The Cranberries Zombie

Aside from the great hits like "Dreams," "Linger," and "Zombie," you may not know many other songs by "The Cranberries." These three songs are played rather frequently, and it would be hard to imagine someone not recognizing at least one of the three. If you haven't, look them up, and then come back and read this list. But as is the case with many bands, those popular singles only scratch the surface.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments