Your Opinion Isn't Enough
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

Your Opinion Isn't Enough

Why the emotional argument cannot be our only argument

Your Opinion Isn't Enough

It seems as though we live in the era of the opinion. Of course, people have always had deeply held beliefs, but in a more-than-ever connected world through social media, the average person is abler and more inclined to broadcast these thoughts to the greater world. In politics and advocacy, we typically base our viewpoints upon what we feel is right and just, and we often defend our beliefs while neglecting the facts and data that might defend or refute our stances.

What we forget, however, is that this method discredits us.

Anyone who has participated in a formal debate knows that opinions are not debatable. Facts and data can be argued, while opinions are considered invalid. Yet, turn on the television to a political debate, and too often politicians use sentiment-based rhetoric to defend their policies. News hosts then analyze those policies, shouting over one another, instead of engaging in thoughtful conversation.

The result of this is that we fail to mindfully consider our ideas, in favor of sitting in our own echo chambers, reassuring ourselves that we cannot be wrong because our opinions can never be wrong. We don’t consider if our opinions are constitutional. We don’t consider the larger effects of our ideology upon people who may be affected by it. Most importantly, we don’t consider that we may possibly by misinformed or failing to see the larger picture.

The bigger issue, however, is as we’ve seen in our own congress for years: Instead of coming to a fact-based conclusion, differing parties argue endlessly, never compromising to find a middle ground, nor considering alternate solutions or allowing open-mindedness to other perspectives. Nothing is solved this way. We instead move back into our ideological forts, hurling insults at the opposing fort, and stagnation flourishes like algae in a neglected aquarium.

One common problem is that we argue numbers against emotions or vice versa. Sure, a hypothetical environmental policy could cause massive deforestation, but it could be argued that it would increase jobs and boost the economy. Sure, a struggling school needs extra funding, but the budget is too tight. “But think of the animals!” Environmentalists cry. “Think of the poor children!” Education advocates shout.

But, against numbers, feelings fall short.

Consider, then, if the dissenting argument shifted. What if a plan to replant an already deforested plot of land and then open a state park could create an even greater boost to the economy? What if the economic return on funding the struggling school much in the way the G.I. bill returns almost $7 for each $1 spent could be proven?

For a more concrete example, we can consider the recent call of the American Action Forum, a conservative think tank, to provide up to 16 weeks of paid parental leave to low-income new parents. Liberal politicians have pushed for similar policies for years now, citing the need for parents to bond with their newborn children without struggling financially. The American Action Foundation viewed the issue from an economic standpoint and found that providing paid parental leave actually saved individual companies money by greatly increasing the likelihood that new parents would stay with the company and prevent the costly process of hiring new employees.

In this way, a step was made forward. One ideological fort heard the shouts of the other, put their feelings aside, and put crunched some numbers. What they found is something that is, at the very least, progress that can be worked upon.

Our feelings, our convictions, our morality will never lose weight. These things are still deeply important in what makes us who we are as individuals and humankind. But we absolutely must find a way to put our emotions aside for just a moment and work through the issues we find so important so that we can find a substantial reason that can be worked with. Then, and only then, can the two opposing forts stop their shouting and name-calling, come to a treaty, and work together for the benefit of all Americans.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.

The Mystery Of The Gospel

Also entitled, "The Day I Stopped Believing In God"


I had just walked across the street from the soccer field back to the school. I turned around and saw the cars rushing, passing each other, going fast over the crosswalk where I had been moments earlier. “It would be so easy to jump in front of one of them,” I thought, looking at the cars. “I could jump, and this life that I’m stuck in would be over.”

Keep Reading... Show less

College as Told by The Lord of the Rings Memes

One does not simply pass this article.


College as told by the Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit memes. Everyone will be Tolkien about it.

Keep Reading... Show less

A Tribute To The Lonely Hispanic

In honor of Hispanic Heritage Month, I’d like to share a few thoughts about being Hispanic in a country where it’s hard to be Hispanic.

Veronika Maldonado

Just a little background information; my dad was born in Mexico, came to the U.S. as a newborn and became a citizen when he was 25 years old. My mom was born and raised in the U.S. as were my grandparents and great grandparents, but my great-great grandparents did migrate here from Mexico. I am proud to classify myself as Hispanic but there are times when I feel like I’m living a double life and I don’t fit into either one.

Keep Reading... Show less

Dear College Football

It's not you, it's me.


Dear College Football,

Keep Reading... Show less

Hurricane Preparedness

In Louisiana and many other states, it is important to have a hurricane plan

Munger Construction

With hurricane season, it's always best to be prepared for it. It means having a plan for your family and home. Everyone in Louisiana should know the basics of preparing for hurricane season.

Keep Reading... Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments