Why Trump’s Action On Jerusalem Is The Perfect Hanukkah Gift For Critical U.S. Ally Israel
Start writing a post
Politics

Why Trump’s Action On Jerusalem Is The Perfect Hanukkah Gift For Critical U.S. Ally Israel

This year we herald a new step in resolving conflicts over Jerusalem.

3318
Why Trump’s Action On Jerusalem Is The Perfect Hanukkah Gift For Critical U.S. Ally Israel
Kristoffer Trolle

On December 6, President Trump did one thing many presidents before him have emphasized a need for, but failed to act on. Presidents Bill Clinton, George Bush, and Barack Obama have all made statements on the need to recognize Jerusalem as the capital of Israel—something that finally took place, early this month.

Many immediately condemned the action, saying he had no right to do so, or that he was inciting violence in the Middle East which was unnecessary and could have been avoided if he had remained as complacent as the presidents before him.

However, it was an action quite overdue; Israel captured the eastern side of the city—which has been their proposed capital since 1948, and eternal religious capital for the Jewish people—in 1967. Even Encyclopedia Britannica notes that Israel has had full control of Jerusalem since this time.

However, the Palestinians living in east Jerusalem have refused to recognize the annexation of Israeli-controlled east Jerusalem in 1980—just as each of Israel’s allies has failed to recognize it. This has made ownership to the city a point of contention, and one that had largely been left to Israel and Palestine to settle in their on-again-off-again peace talks. The proposed fix is a two-state solution; a solution, which would divide Jerusalem into east and west, with the east being given to Palestine. In fifty full years, an agreement has not been reached.

This hesitancy to recognize the rightful capital of Israel in order to facilitate peace has been a failure thus far, with no indications that it would not continue to be so. With little hope of securing a precarious peace, very little can be lost by finally recognizing the capital, especially given that this recognition further tightens the US-Israeli alliance. This is part of what motivated the action.

In decades, following the same policy of tip-toeing around the recognition of Jerusalem as the rightful capital of Israel has yielded little in progress for the peace talks. To continue that policy of indifference, hoping that one day it will suddenly make a difference, is madness. This decision has been offered as a way to speed up the negotiations, by making clear something which has been true for many years.

Palestinians lay claim to east Jerusalem on the grounds that some two hundred thousand Palestinians live there, and it contains the third holiest site to Islam. Under Israeli control, people of all religions have been permitted to visit their holy sites accordingly. While it’s true that Arabs outnumber Jews in this part of the city, it is important to note that east Jerusalem also contains the Old City, which is the holiest site in Judaism.

To lay claim to east Jerusalem on the grounds of securing the third-holiest place to their religion—which they already have access to—is a very weak claim indeed, especially when contrasted with a religion for who this area is their most holy. Even more so when not one, but two religions hold the belief that it is the most holy place for Jews.

The decision has been met with vast protest, but within Israel it was declared a day of celebration. Following the announcement, Trump has stated that he intends to help finally broker the peace treaty, even if, in their negotiations, they agree to later divide Jerusalem again to achieve the two-state solution. For now, however, it gives credence to the pre-existing unity of Jerusalem and the Israeli control.

Occurring just less than a week before the start of Hanukkah celebrations, this announcement—though met angrily by some—has brought great joy to the people of Israel, and to Jews who have prayed for so long to have their religious capital reclaimed.

Happy Hanukkah!

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Featured

To The 'Best Friend' I Decided I Couldn't Be Friends With Anymore

Most of all, thank you for being the person who finally pushed me to choose myself.

96388
The CW / YouTube

Dear Old Friend,

Keep Reading... Show less
Lifestyle

7 Tips For Traveling

Don't miss any of these ideas to make your trip complete!

2519
7 Tips For Traveling

Whether it's a day trip, an out-of-state journey, or an experience leaving the country, here are some tried and true traveling tips.

Before any trip, we all think about what to pack and what to bring. We may have a strict itinerary, or we may have looser guidelines for what to do when. But we should also consider the following - make them goals:

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

Writer of the Month: Hunter Johnstone

As an aspiring author, Hunter knew writing for Odyssey would be a great fit for her.

2363
Writer of the Month: Hunter Johnstone

Response writers are what make the world go round at Odyssey! Using our response button feature, they carry on our mission of sparking positive, productive conversations in a polarized world.

Keep Reading... Show less
Allison Fishman

1. Why is Wilson Hall so complicated to navigate? Even as a senior, I still get lost in Wilson. As a freshman, I was warned about the unnecessary complexity of the building, was laughed at by upperclassman for my confused looks on the first day of school and walked and rewalked the whole hall before finding my classroom. #annoying.

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

Blair Waldorf For governor of new york

What life would be like if the people were led by Queen B.

3004
Blair Waldorf For governor of new york

Cynthia Nixon, a.k.a Miranda from Sex and the City, is running for governor of New York. I think that this would be the best decision that has been made in a while solely based off of the fact that almost no one knows New York like the cast of Sex and the City. This got me thinking about who else would be a good candidate to take over the city of dreams. Then I realized that Blair Waldorf, if she were a real person, would be my number one choice for governor. Here are five reasons why Queen B would be an excellent ruler.

Keep Reading... Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments