Although they are most definitely more than five pizza places in the town of Westerly, we've narrowed it down to our top five. If you disagree, well, you're entitled to your wrong opinion.
Starting the countdown...
5. Supreme Pizza of Westerly, 157 Granite Street
Even though you haven't been here long, you've made an impression, well a car made an impression in you. When attempting to come up with a favorite entree to mention, we struggled because everything is good. Supreme ranked number five simply because we're a town of Italian Pizza Lovers and it is hard to break a connection with our lifelong favorite pizza place.
4. Mario's Northend Pizzeria, 61 Friendship Street
The pizza at Mario's is consistently cooked so the cheese is golden. Mario's is known for great prices and great service, along with their $6 Large pizzas on Tuesdays. Who can argue with a $6 pizza? Mario's fell to the next three pizza places for the simple fact, I've only ever ordered take-out and cannot comment on the restaurants atmosphere.
3. Vetranos Italian Restaurant, 130 Granite Street
We're really liking what you've done with the place Vetranos. Recently renovated and looking more and more like a lovely Italian Restaurant. However, this title of Italian Restaurant hikes up your prices and leaves you at number three. We also could not forget Vittorias, your sister place, which provides a more casual environment.
2. Dunns Corners Pizza, 271 Post Road
DCP you have stolen my heart. Cooked to perfection whether it be takeout, delivery, or sit down. While I may be a little biased because you're less than five minutes from me, I will always yell DCP when asked where we should order in. There is one reason and one reason only while you fall to number one, you don't deliver before 4 p.m.
1. PizzaPlace, 43 Broad Street
Obviously PizzaPlace is the number one pizza place in Westerly. Starting from Apps to Entrees, PizzaPlace always delivers, except they actually don't deliver. PizzaPlace is known for their Chopped Pasta Salad, and a trip there is incomplete without it. While your crust may not be the fluffiest, and your cheese a golden brown, you never fail to impress with the delicious of your classic Mozzarella.
Honorable Mention: Pizza Lady
While a top five was hard to decide on, we must give an Honorable Mention to none other than Pizza Lady. Even though you're not in Westerly, but just across the Connecticut border, we still love your sweet pizza and cannot get enough of it.
