The 10 Most Gloriously Terrible 'American Idol' Auditions Of All Time | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Entertainment

The 10 Most Gloriously Terrible 'American Idol' Auditions Of All Time

Let's relive the moments that made us who we are.

5984
The 10 Most Gloriously Terrible 'American Idol' Auditions Of All Time
Inquirer Entertainment

Well, everyone, it’s over. After nearly 14 years of tension, tears and laughs so hard they nearly pushed your stomach out of your chest, "American Idol" is over. Though the show’s end has been inevitable since Simon Cowell left after Season 9, it’s still a bit strange to know that "Idol" is finally off the air. Let’s relive the 10 best (terrible) auditions the show has ever seen (note: two auditions that appear on this list are from the "X Factor UK," but I included them 1) in honor of Simon Cowell, and 2) because they are too bizarre to not be included in a list like this).

10. Steven “Red” Thoen - Bohemian Rhapsody - Season 6


Red kicks off our list with one of the most bizarre auditions "Idol" has ever seen. Before even beginning his song, he tells the judges he’s auditioning because he “likes competition”—not because he can sing. Don’t worry, though—he has seen the show “a couple of times” and knows what it’s all about. After he out-of-the-blue compares himself to Freddie Mercury, he begins his horrifying rendition of “Bohemian Rhapsody” that, predictably, ends in disaster.

Best quotes: “I can also do country as well” - Red; “That was like a one-year-old singing that song” - Simon

9. James Lewis - Go Down Moses / I’ll Fly Away - Season 7


There is just something… odd about James Lewis straight from the get-go. All the editors tell us about him is that he loves his job as a tour guide and has a slight speech impediment. He compares himself to Eddie Vedder and says his specialty is “anything that’s low.” It’s all very disturbing—and then we hear him sing, and things turn from disturbing to flat-out horrendous. The lyrics to “Go Down Moses” are completely incomprehensible, as Lewis sounds utterly piss drunk; think a stumbling, slurred version of “Swing Low, Sweet Chariot.” It’s horrifically glorious.

Best quotes: Every time Lewis says “let my people go”; “Pharaoh Pharaoh” - Lewis

8. Rachel Lester - Sugar Walls - Season 3 (X Factor UK)


Ah, the first of two entries from overseas. I know nothing about Evil Rachel’s past, and quite frankly, I don’t want to. All I know is that her "X Factor" audition is absolutely legendary, and that she went even crazier after her iconic performance.

Best quotes: Literally everything Lester says, specifically “I was good, wasn’t it? Let’s face it” and “Nothing, I’m lazy at the moment”

7. Derek Stillings - ?????? - Season 1

The original terrible audition is here in all it’s glory. It’s evident that 20-year-old Derek Stillings was quite passionate about his "Idol" performance by the fact that he composed his own song and choreographed his own dance routine to impress the judges. Unfortunately for him, it was absolutely abysmal. Also: the Chinese tattoo on his left arm is lowkey the best part of this audition.

Best quotes: The entire exchange between Simon and Stillings that ends the audition (and if Simon had his way, it would be Stillings’ last audition)

6. Joseph Land - Young Girl - Season 4

This is easily the most lighthearted and playful of the auditions listed here, but it doesn’t disappoint at all. Yes, Land’s singing is hilariously terrible, but the best part about his "Idol" story is that he falsified documents saying that he was 28 in order to meet the Idol age requirements. His passion is admirable, and the fact that he is very clearly not anywhere close to 28 is even more pleasing.

Best quotes: “That’s a long life” - Simon; Paula laughing at 1:24; “I can’t bear to listen to this anymore, please” - Simon

5. Keith Beukelaer - Like a Virgin / I Wanna Dance With Somebody - Season 2

Keith Beukelaer’s performance of Madonna’s “Like a Virgin” is unquestionably staged, yet still enthralling. Between his sweater, hair, inflection, dancing and especially his head movements, his, um, “unique” rendition of the Madonna classic is undeniably amazing. The best part of the audition, though, is that after he's finished slaughtering "Like a Virgin," Simon asks him to sing another song. “”I Wanna Dance With Somebody” is even worse; I’d argue that, without the chorus, it’d be near impossible to tell what song he is singing. It’s a brilliant, atonal mess, and it helped secure Beukelear’s spot in the top five.

Best quotes: “I’ve never, ever heard anything like that in my life” - Simon; “Keith, that was horrific, man” - Randy (you know when Randy adopts British slang that things have truly taken a turn for the worse)

4. Ariel Burdett - ???????????? - Season 5 (X Factor UK)


The best audition in "X Factor" history, hands down. I think it’d be best if I let the holistic vocal coach herself do all the talking, though I do want to point out how perfect the music from 2:05 on fits with the frightening ambiance of the audition room.

Best quotes: Every line. Not a dull moment in sight.

3. Mary “Guilbeaux” Roach - I Feel the Earth Move / Empty Shell - Season 4

Probably the most widely known cringe-worthy "Idol" audition (besides William Hung, who wasn’t even that funny and won’t be appearing on this list). Let’s be clear—Mary Roach is not a real person. She is a character put on by a comedian whose name I unfortunately cannot find. This comedian, whoever she is, is brilliant, because Mary Roach is 100 percent believable as a genuine person. She is obviously quite lost and deluded, but her understanding of tackiness and realistic ambition to pursue a cosmetology career keep her just sane enough for the audience to latch onto her and treat her as legitimate. Her voice is masterfully crafted to walk the line between fake and real, her post-audition rage is just tame enough to seem authentic… it’s all perfect. (She does very subtly break character at one point during the video, though—can you catch it?)

Best quotes: “Break a leg—that’s what they always say in theater” - Mary; “Not too much strut though, because that looks tacky” - Mary; “G-U-I-L-B-E-A-U-X” - Mary

2. Jonathan Rey - The One - Season 3

Ghastly vibrato + assault on Simon Cowell = legendary.

1. Sarah Goldberg - Dreaming of You - Season 6

Unlike Mary Roach, Sarah Goldberg is not a character. Sarah Goldberg is Sarah Goldberg. She knows she can’t sing, and didn’t come to "Idol" expecting to get through to Hollywood. She came as a joke and to be on TV, and thank God she did, because she gave us the most legendary "Idol" audition of all time. It’s almost mythical—and Simon isn’t even a part of it! “You could teach me” is the best line ever said on "Idol," and Goldberg’s ending monologue about the judges drinking until 3 a.m. is equally as memorable. This is another instance where I need to let the audition itself do the talking. If "American Idol" were an epoch, this audition would be epochal. May Sarah Goldberg live in "Idol" infamy forever.
Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
April Ludgate
NBC Universal

Everyone who is in college right now, or has ever been, knows the struggle of pulling in the strings at the last second. It seems impossible, and you have to do a LOT of things in order to assure your future for the next semester.

April Ludgate, historically, is a very annoyed person, and she doesn't hide it. Of all the times that I binged and re-binged "Parks and Rec," her attitude relates more and more to me.

Keep Reading...Show less
Health and Wellness

To The Cheerful Person On Their Rainy Days, You Are Valid

The world is not always sunshine and rainbows, and you do not have to be, either.

298
pug covered with blanket on bedspread
Photo by Matthew Henry on Unsplash

Ask friends of mine to name a quality about me, and one a lot them will point out the fact that I am almost always smiling. I like to laugh and smile -- not to quote Buddy the Elf in April, but smiling is my favorite! It is probably my favorite go-to expression. However, what a lot of people do not see is that I have my down days. I have days when smiling and laughing is a real struggle, or when I have so much on my plate that going out of my way to behappy takes more effort than I have stored in me. Be it a symptom of college and growing up or a facet of life, I cannot always be content.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

11 Struggles of Packing for College

It would be so much easier to just pay someone to do it for you

359
a room with boxes and a window

1. Figuring out when to start

Timing is key, you don’t want to start too early or too late.

Keep Reading...Show less
Entertainment

15 Times 'Parks and Recreation' Has Summed Up Your Life

Relatable moments from one of the best shows I have ever watched.

270
parks and rec
Liz Keysmash

Amidst my hectic college career, I always find time for one thing, even on the busiest weeks: Parks and Recreation. This show has made me laugh and has made me cry, but most of all I have related to this show more than I would like to admit.

Here are some "Parks and Rec" moments that relate to life struggles that just about everyone faces.

Keep Reading...Show less
April Ludgate
Facebook

April Ludgate from Parks and Recreation is notorious for her "I don't care" attitude. She speaks her mind without caring what anyone thinks of her. Fans love her because she isn't afraid to be herself. April can seem cold and negative, but she's really just fearless and strong-minded. And despite her sometimes harsh words, April truly cares about the people she's closest to. These are all reasons she is the epitome of a college student. April complains whenever she has to do any kind of work, but ends up doing the work anyway. April Ludgate is the ultimate college student spirit animal.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments