The Eighth Story: A Review
Start writing a post

The Eighth Story: A Review

My geekiness is a-quivering.

The Eighth Story: A Review

Spoilers Ahead

First and foremost I must say that I did enjoy the book. It sure brought a piece of my childhood back, and I couldn't help but hum Hedwig's theme song as I was standing in line holding a copy of "Harry Potter and the Cursed Child" in my hands. However after I finished the book, I didn't feel the same satisfaction I felt reading the original seven books. I understand that the book was written in a play format, and I believe it would make a nice play, but did the eighth Harry Potter book have to be this way?

[rebelmouse-proxy-image crop_info="%7B%22image%22%3A%20%22https%3A//" expand=1]

To start with, the play format was unexpected for me. I couldn't get lost in Rowling's captivating descriptions of the Wizard World, instead, it was an easy read with too much repetition (I mean we know what happened in the "Deathly Hallows" epilogue and Harry's flashbacks took up too many pages).

The Characters

Harry grew up as an orphan, he marveled at the pictures of his parents iceskating, he loved his friends and the Weasley family dearly, and he most certainly loved the closest thing to family that he had, Sirius. Even though he was a sassy child, I doubt he would have grown up to be a terrible father. The Harry Potter in "The Cursed Child" was nothing like the Harry Potter from the 19 years later epilogue. He was caring and definitely not the type to wish his son wasn't born. However, the father-son dynamic could have been more powerful, focusing more on Albus' mind rather than Harry's cruel parenting.

By focusing more on Albus, I would expect something deeper and bigger. In "The Cursed Child," Albus was too much of a whiny and dramatic teenager, who got all angry just because he didn't get into the Gryffindor House (which it seemed like he would be okay with, judging by the "Deathly Hallows" epilogue). Almost like a child stomping their feet and crossing their arms when they're told they can't buy a toy they had their eye on. It was understandable that the authors wanted Albus to be the "different" one, but given the amount of thought J.K Rowling put into her original characters, Albus could definitely have had a stronger story.

Ron was portrayed like a loser, in my opinion. It's admirable that he took over his older brothers' role as the jokester, but the fact that his own family doesn't appreciate the jokes is unbelievable. I mean let's look back at the Weasley twins—I bet the pranks were frustrating at times for Molly, but nevertheless everyone loved them, and it doesn't make sense that they're bothered by Ron. Ron was vital to the original trio; he was a brave and loyal friend, so it doesn't seem right that his character would have no use other than his awkward jokes.

Delphi. Okay, when did Voldemort have the time and how did no one notice Bellatrix carrying Delphi around? We could at least have had an explanation on what spell Bellatrix used to be able to go unnoticed. Though the idea for the darkness to come back is interesting and could have developed in a different way, having "the child of Voldemort" be the main antagonist is predictable.

Scorpius. I have nothing bad to say about him. Just his friendship with Albus was too similar to the Harry and Ron dynamic. Albus/Harry would initiate the rule breaking plan, Scorpius/Ron would be hesitant at first, crack a couple of jokes, and follow along.

The Story

"Voldemort Day..." I'll leave it at that.

The book was partly about the butterfly effect with a wizarding touch to it. Though kind of compelling, it didn't seem as original and as well explored as the action that took place in the original books.

The alternate realities were a nice touch, but don't we have enough fan-fiction for that?

Saving Cedric Diggory? Sure he was a great character but he was also just a casualty of "Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire," besides there are other characters that seem to be more important to Harry. Remus? Sirius? Fred? Dumbledore? Snape? Saving Cedric was definitely not going to make Harry feel better about being the Boy Who Lived. It seemed as if the only motivation to bring Cedric back came from Albus' angsty teenage episode, a chance to rebel against his father... which doesn't deserve to be the main idea of the book. No offense to Cedric.


I was expecting to hear more about the other characters (Teddy Lupin, Luna Lovegood, Neville Longbottom, Rubeus Hagrid, the Weasleys... I honestly wanted a cameo from Filch and Mrs. Norris). However, given that "The Cursed Child" is a play, it not only blocked us from experiencing Rowling's prose, it didn't have the space to include more about the other characters (who were crucial to the Battle of Hogwarts and Harry Potter's life and deserved a cameo).

Final Thoughts

I must say, I was expecting a bigger adventure for the trio's kids. Something that maybe James and Rose would participate in as well, with the help of an unlikely ally Scorpius. I was kind of hoping it would leave the original characters behind, maybe give them a small cameo, but definitely not the disappointing roles they got in "The Cursed Child." The ending of "Deathly Hallows" gave so much room for Harry Potter fans to explore that we all wondered about how their kids' first day at Hogwarts would be like and what the trio would do next, yet we didn't feel empty not knowing. Although "The Cursed" Child gave us the answers, personally, it didn't do the original books justice.

Aside from everything written above, "The Cursed Child" did have some sweet moments and a lot of great lines. I'll always love the characters, and reluctantly accept this book as the eighth and last Harry Potter story.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.

A Letter To My Heartbroken Self

It will be okay, eventually.

A Letter To My Heartbroken Self

Breakups are hard. There's nothing comparable to the pain of losing someone you thought would be in your life forever. Someone who said all the right things at the right times. Someone who would give you the reassurance you needed, whenever you needed it. And then one day, it just... stops. Something changes. Something makes you feel like you're suddenly not good enough for him, or anyone for that matter.

Keep Reading... Show less

2026: the year the Fifa World Cup Returns to North America

For the first time since 1994 the United States will host a world cup (for men's soccer)

2026: the year the Fifa World Cup Returns to North America
Skylar Meyers

The FIFA World Cup is coming to North American in 2026!

Keep Reading... Show less
Student Life

An Open Letter to Winter

Before we know it April will arrive.


Dear Winter,

Keep Reading... Show less
Student Life

6 Questions To Ask Yourself When Cleaning Up Your Room

This holiday break is the perfect time to get away from the materialistic frenzy of the world and turn your room into a decluttered sanctuary.


Cleaning isn’t just for spring. In fact, I find school’s holiday break to be a very effective time for decluttering. You’re already being bombarded by the materialistically-infatuated frenzy of society’s version of Christmas, Hanukah, etc. It’s nice to get out of the claustrophobic avarice of the world and come home to a clean, fresh, and tidy room. While stacking up old books, CDs, and shoes may seem like no big deal, it can become a dangerous habit. The longer you hang onto something, whether it be for sentimental value or simply routine, it becomes much harder to let go of. Starting the process of decluttering can be the hardest part. To make it a little easier, get out three boxes and label them Donate, Storage, and Trash. I'm in the middle of the process right now, and while it is quite time consuming, it is also so relieving and calming to see how much you don't have to deal with anymore. Use these six questions below to help decide where an item gets sorted or if it obtains the value to stay out in your precious sanctuary from the world.

Keep Reading... Show less

Why I Don't Write (Or Read) An "Open Letter To My Future Husband/Wife"

Because inflated expectations and having marriage as your only goal are overrated.

Urban Intellectuals

Although I have since changed my major I remember the feverish hysteria of applying to nursing school--refreshing your email repeatedly, asking friends, and frantically calculating your GPA at ungodly hours of the night. When my acceptance came in I announced the news to friends and family with all the candor of your average collegiate. I was met with well wishes, congratulations, and interrogations on the program's rank, size, etc. Then, unexpectedly, I was met with something else.

Keep Reading... Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments