It was recently revealed that Tilda Swinton would play the role of the Ancient One in Doctor Strange, renewing controversy over Hollywood whitewashing. While Swinton’s casting may seem like a simple and ignorant decision on Marvel’s behalf, racial, political and economic factors complicate the casting. At the end of the day, however, the casting is a well-intended attempt for fan service ultimately undermined by ticket sales.
While individuals may criticize Swinton’s casting for a typically Chinese male role, it is important to note that the Ancient One is a very stereotypical Asian character. In the Doctor Strange comics, the Ancient One was typically a Tibetan character characterized by the racist stereotype of an old Asian mentor with a long white beard. This stereotype poses many problems for Marvel, the first of which is proper representation of Chinese culture. While no one character could ever possibly represent all of Chinese culture, it's important for Marvel that they do not reduce any character to a racial stereotype. As such, the Ancient One had to be modified in order to make him more complex. Marvel could have easily done this through clever screenwriting which would have not only solved their racial complication, but also made the character much more intriguing which would have made for an overall better movie. However, Marvel was too afraid of letting the character remain Tibetan.
In an effort to avoid upsetting China, Marvel changed the race of the Ancient One in order to maximize ticket sales. China is quickly becoming the most important country for the U.S. in regards to International Box Office sales. As such, Marvel needs to ensure their movies are accepted by the Chinese government in order to be shown in Chinese theaters. As a result, the Ancient One could not remain Tibetan due to the current political strife between China and Tibet. China sees Tibet as a part of their nation whereas Tibet sees itself as independent. Keeping the Ancient One Tibetan would have acknowledged Tibet as an independent nation and ruined all possibilities of Doctor Strange entering Chinese theaters. Therefore, Doctor Strange now travels to Nepal instead of Tibet to receive his training and the Ancient One is now Celtic. While this decision may seem like Marvel’s best option for avoiding political conflict, it is clear that Marvel has sided with China in the political debate over Tibet. It is a tragic decision that is based not on morals but money.
Marvel needed the Chinese box office sales so that they could even make Doctor Strange, a movie that is ultimately dedicated to the fans. Frankly, Doctor Strange is not a movie that needed to be made. While the same could be said about any movie, Marvel already has a plethora of characters in their cinematic universe from which they could tell countless stories. However, when you meet somebody who can barely hold back tears after watching just the trailer for Doctor Strange, it becomes apparent that this movie could mean the universe to some people. There are just as many die-hard fans of Doctor Strange as there are fans of comic book characters such as Captain America, Iron Man or Spider-Man and for these fans to see their favorite character portrayed on the big screen is like a dream come true.
Doctor Strange is an important movie for many people, including the creators at Marvel, business executives and Doctor Strange fans, but it is important to realize that Doctor Strange features many dimensions. On the surface, Swinton’s casting may seem like classic Hollywood whitewashing, but in reality it is a much more complicated decision. Money talks, and the modifications to the Ancient One is Marvel overtly pandering to a China whose ticket sales enable fans to even see Doctor Strange on the big screen. However, while the tears of joy from the Doctor Strange fans are heartwarming, there is a much larger audience that needs to be addressed first: the Asian populace. Proper representation of Asian culture and characters needs to be Marvel’s top priority. Money talks, but so have the voices of countless people who are waiting to see themselves on the big screen. Controversy will continue should Marvel continue to prioritize ticket sales at the expense of proper Asian representation. This representation should not be a dream come true for the Asian populace, but rather a necessity.





















