An Unfortunate Argument Skeptics Make Against Theism
Start writing a post

An Unfortunate Argument Skeptics Make Against Theism

"I don't know, but I know that you are wrong!" is an absurd argument.

An Unfortunate Argument Skeptics Make Against Theism

In the 21st century, it is often said that we live in a culture that is unfortunately marred by post-modernism and relativism and other ideas that are detrimental to culture and society. There is a shred of truth to this notion, but as philosopher William Lane Craig once said, the problem in America today isn't post-modernism but, ironically enough, modernism! Ideas that stemmed from modernism when it first began to take root in culture during the Enlightenment such as naturalism, scientism, and a general lack of reverence for religion are still very much at work in many hearts and minds not just in America, but all over the Western world, even dominating in places like the United Kingdom and Denmark.

I say all of this to serve as a preface for what the premise of this blog post will be, that is a hopeless argument against theism that has been proposed by all sorts of skeptics and atheists across Western academia. Recently as my Intro to Philosophy class at Vincennes University came to a close, my assignment was to write an essay on a speech that was given by the famous atheist thinker Michael Shermer at the California Institute of Technology in Pasadena that concerned his 2015 book "The Moral Arc" and explains why I agreed or disagreed with him.

As you can imagine, I disagree with Mr. Shermer's argument in the book and in the speech, which was basically that the less religious and more scientifically advanced mankind gets, the more moral mankind gets. I wrote what, if I am remembering properly, was a roughly 10-page critique of Shermer's speech, explaining why his argument, as I see it, fails.

One problem that was glaring and is glaring in every atheistic attack on theism and religion that I have ever heard is the problem of those pesky objective moral values and duties that cannot be reasonably accounted for on an atheistic worldview. Of course, Shermer's worldview could not and cannot account for moral facts and duties, yet he vehemently advocates morality and pushes people to be serious about morality.

But my issue with Shermer and most skeptics that I want to discuss in this post doesn't have to do very much with the Moral Argument for the existence of God or the atheist failure to account for objective moral values and duties. (A good resource on this subject though is the recent debate between William Lane Craig and Eric Wielenberg; check it out!) Rather, it has to do with an objection to theism that I have heard many skeptics make, including Michael Shermer in a debate he had with Christian apologist David Wood, that possibly may be explained by the following syllogism…

1. We do not presently know how the universe came into being from nothing or how the universe can look intelligently designed.
2. Christians say that God created and designed the universe and the world.
3. Therefore, Christians are wrong and there must be a scientific answer.

This argument seems to me to be a non-sequitur, meaning the conclusion doesn't logically follow from the premises. Premise two is definitely correct in that orthodox Christianity definitely affirms that a timeless, spaceless, immaterial, enormously powerful mind, or in other words God, created the universe out of nothing (creatio ex nihilo) and specially designed the universe and the earth. Premise one is true from the perspective of someone like Michael Shermer, a self-proclaimed skeptic, and editor of Skeptic magazine. Atheists do not believe that God or any gods exist and therefore are left with a naturalistic explanation for the origin of the universe.

Some say the universe came from nothing or created itself, but these claims are irrationalities and don't require any further discussion, as they defy laws of logic and are mere assertions that don't hold water.

Some atheistic thinkers like Stephen Hawking have proposed the multiverse theory, but there is literally no evidence for the multiverse and such a claim seems to me to wildly go against the principle of Occam's Razor, which essentially states "when you have two competing theories that make exactly the same predictions, the simpler one is the better."

But do you see the problem in thinking here coming from the skeptic's argument? The argument is basically this, in a nutshell: "I do not know where the universe came from or why it looks specially designed, but I know that your argument cannot be true."

Also, the skeptic, whether or not he/she realizes it, is assuming in this argument that science has the ability to answer every question that mankind may have, which is demonstrably false and has been shown to be false time and time again. Here is an example: If I tell you that last Saturday evening I had a bowl of chips and queso dip for supper and there isn't any way for you to verify it through scientific inquiry, it doesn't follow that I am lying to you or that it cannot be known what I ate. If you feel as if I am trustworthy, then my claim can be believed by you and wouldn't reasonably require scientific examination to come to a conclusion. Such a worldview isn't reasonable nor is it livable. The same is true with matters of philosophical inquiry. Consider this syllogism…

1. If there are other ways to determine truth apart from scientific study, the claim, if something isn't scientifically proven it isn't true, is false.
2. Truth can be discovered through testimony and philosophy.
3. The claim, if something isn't scientifically proven it isn't true, is false.

Clearly, if someone truly doesn't know something, then all plausible theories should be acknowledged and then carefully measured through reason and critical thinking. It won't do to just shrug off a theory because it isn't naturalistic and it pertains to the supernatural, as evidence suggests that supernatural claims are worth considering, given the reality of documented miracles, the reasonableness of the Biblical account of the resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth, and the likelihood that human beings have consciousness independent of the brain.

To say "I don't know" should really mean "I don't know," not "I don't know, but I do know you're wrong."

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Health and Wellness

Exposing Kids To Nature Is The Best Way To Get Their Creative Juices Flowing

Constantly introducing young children to the magical works of nature will further increase the willingness to engage in playful activities as well as broaden their interactions with their peers


Whenever you are feeling low and anxious, just simply GO OUTSIDE and embrace nature! According to a new research study published in Frontiers in Psychology, being connected to nature and physically touching animals and flowers enable children to be happier and altruistic in nature. Not only does nature exert a bountiful force on adults, but it also serves as a therapeutic antidote to children, especially during their developmental years.

Keep Reading... Show less
Health and Wellness

5 Simple Ways To Give Yourself Grace, Especially When Life Gets Hard

Grace begins with a simple awareness of who we are and who we are becoming.

Photo by Brooke Cagle on Unsplash

If there's one thing I'm absolutely terrible at, it's giving myself grace. I'm easily my own worst critic in almost everything that I do. I'm a raging perfectionist, and I have unrealistic expectations for myself at times. I can remember simple errors I made years ago, and I still hold on to them. The biggest thing I'm trying to work on is giving myself grace. I've realized that when I don't give myself grace, I miss out on being human. Even more so, I've realized that in order to give grace to others, I need to learn how to give grace to myself, too. So often, we let perfection dominate our lives without even realizing it. I've decided to change that in my own life, and I hope you'll consider doing that, too. Grace begins with a simple awareness of who we are and who we're becoming. As you read through these five affirmations and ways to give yourself grace, I hope you'll take them in. Read them. Write them down. Think about them. Most of all, I hope you'll use them to encourage yourself and realize that you are never alone and you always have the power to change your story.

Keep Reading... Show less

Breaking Down The Beginning, Middle, And End of Netflix's Newest 'To All The Boys' Movie

Noah Centineo and Lana Condor are back with the third and final installment of the "To All The Boys I've Loved Before" series


Were all teenagers and twenty-somethings bingeing the latest "To All The Boys: Always and Forever" last night with all of their friends on their basement TV? Nope? Just me? Oh, how I doubt that.

I have been excited for this movie ever since I saw the NYC skyline in the trailer that was released earlier this year. I'm a sucker for any movie or TV show that takes place in the Big Apple.

Keep Reading... Show less

4 Ways To Own Your Story, Because Every Bit Of It Is Worth Celebrating

I hope that you don't let your current chapter stop you from pursuing the rest of your story.

Photo by Manny Moreno on Unsplash

Every single one of us has a story.

I don't say that to be cliché. I don't say that to give you a false sense of encouragement. I say that to be honest. I say that to be real.

Keep Reading... Show less
Politics and Activism

How Young Feminists Can Understand And Subvert The Internalized Male Gaze

Women's self-commodification, applied through oppression and permission, is an elusive yet sexist characteristic of a laissez-faire society, where women solely exist to be consumed. (P.S. justice for Megan Fox)

Paramount Pictures

Within various theories of social science and visual media, academics present the male gaze as a nebulous idea during their headache-inducing meta-discussions. However, the internalized male gaze is a reality, which is present to most people who identify as women. As we mature, we experience realizations of the perpetual male gaze.

Keep Reading... Show less

It's Important To Remind Yourself To Be Open-Minded And Embrace All Life Has To Offer

Why should you be open-minded when it is so easy to be close-minded?


Open-mindedness. It is something we all need a reminder of some days. Whether it's in regards to politics, religion, everyday life, or rarities in life, it is crucial to be open-minded. I want to encourage everyone to look at something with an unbiased and unfazed point of view. I oftentimes struggle with this myself.

Keep Reading... Show less

14 Last Minute Valentine's Day Gifts Your S.O. Will Love

If they love you, they're not going to care if you didn't get them some expensive diamond necklace or Rolex watch; they just want you.


Let me preface this by saying I am not a bad girlfriend.

I am simply a forgetful one.

Keep Reading... Show less
Student Life

10 Helpful Tips For College Students Taking Online Courses This Semester

Here are several ways to easily pass an online course.

Photo by Vlada Karpovich on Pexels

With spring semester starting, many college students are looking to take courses for the semester. With the pandemic still ongoing, many students are likely looking for the option to take online courses.

Online courses at one time may have seemed like a last minute option for many students, but with the pandemic, they have become more necessary. Online courses can be very different from taking an on-campus course. You may be wondering what the best way to successfully complete an online course is. So, here are 10 helpful tips for any student who is planning on taking online courses this semester!

Keep Reading... Show less
Facebook Comments