Police Unions Prevent Criminal Justice Reform
Start writing a post

This serves as a short outline of several arguments against police unions.

Hoover Institute scholars, John McGinnis, and Max Schanzenbach provide excellent arguments against public sector unions. Public sector unions are protected by civil service statutes that prevent arbitrary hiring and firing practices.

Specific to police, unions allow for very powerful collective bargaining leverage. They have the power to resist body cameras, GPS tracking, and rigged arbitration for disciplinary actions against officers.

The goal of police reform should be to target the problem officers and prevent greater disruption to the officers doing the right thing. The first proposal would be to require officers to buy professional liability insurance.

Settlements would be paid for by the insurance company and after too many the premiums would get too high, pricing these bad officers out. One critique is the proposal would make officers cautious when out on duty.

My response is that economic incentives would give officers more reason to use body cameras and GPS trackers. In the event of frivolous, the officer would have proof he followed procedure or wasn't negligent.

Another more radical proposal would be to ban police unions from collective bargaining over termination and discipline procedures. Public unions enjoy privileges like these because specific laws written to favor them. Unlike the private sector unions, they have civil service statutes protecting them.

Finally the last most radical proposal is banning police unions entirely. The philosophical argument is that the public is held hostage by the monopoly power of the government. In 1943, a New York Supreme Court justice said

Nothing is more dangerous to public welfare than to admit that hired servants of the State can dictate to the government the hours, the wages and conditions under which they will carry on essential services vital to the welfare, safety, and security of the citizen.

He went on to say that this would be incompatible with democracy. Because the union leader is chosen by the union and not the public, they have no duty to the citizen, unlike the officers they represent. While this is a more radical proposal, it underscores the stark differences between public and private. Any collective bargaining in a public union is at the expense of taxpayers.

According to a 2001 National Institute of Justice publication, 2% of officers are responsible for 50% of all citizen complaints. Targeting these officers would go a long way in preventing police shootings and incidences of police misconduct. When looking for a solution, a place to look would be the role of unions.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Featured

What Your Car's Color Says About Your Personality

Your color choice speaks volumes. It doesn't just emit an image for the car, it also says something about your style and personality! It's a form of self-expression. Are you confident? Are you sophisticated? Are you easy-going? Are you outgoing? Are you practical? As you're reviewing car sites for your next car purchase, what color will you opt for? Find out what certain color choices says about you!

91312

When it comes to car shopping you likely have certain preferences, including what color it should be. Your color choice speaks volumes. It doesn't just emit an image for the car, it also says something about your style and personality! It's a form of self-expression. Are you confident? Are you sophisticated? Are you easy-going? Are you outgoing? Are you practical? As you're reviewing car sites for your next car purchase, what color will you opt for? Find out what certain color choices says about you!

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

30 Songs On My Back-To-School Playlist For Walks To And From Class

Headed back to in-person classes means you need a pretty banging playlist to power you through those walks to class.

81517
Photo by Zen Chung on Pexels

I don't know about you, but I start each day off with a one-mile walk to class. I have to have good tunes flowing through my ears during those 20 minutes, not to mention the walks between classes and the walks home. So, here is my 30 song playlist to get me through this almost unfamiliar concept we call walking to class.

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

Be Kind to Yourself: 8 Mental Health Tips to Try

One way you can improve your quality of life is to take care of your mental health. As a result, you'll feel less depressed and be able to enjoy spending time with friends and family more often. These mental health tips might be just what you need to forget about your problems.

48113

One way you can improve your quality of life is to take care of your mental health. As a result, you'll feel less depressed and be able to enjoy spending time with friends and family more often. These mental health tips might be just what you need to forget about your problems.

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

Should You Own An SUV If You Live In A Snowy state?

There are many reasons to own an SUV. If you live in a cold state or a rural area, you will see that owning an SUV is very important.

44723

The gas and oil prices are too high to run in a smaller vehicle. You are better off with an SUV for hauling cargo and driving larger loads around the town. In addition, owning an SUV is more comfortable and safe than driving a smaller vehicle.

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

Understanding Why Dog's Lick You

It is a natural instinct for dogs to lick

57693

Why do dogs lick?

Keep Reading... Show less
Facebook Comments