"The Bachelor Presents: Listen to Your Heart" has only just begun, but you likely have A LOT of thoughts already. And you're not alone.
We put together a panel of viewers to recap and react to this Monday's episode and let's just say their opinions are as entertaining as the show itself.
Introducing Me
Whose intro package was the most memorable to you and why?
Taylor – Brandon's intro package really started the show off strong. There's just something about a musician from Nashville who used to be in the Army that'll really get ya.
Michael – There is only one right answer:
Liv – Right off the bat my favorite intro was Brandon. He seemed like such a good man who had a lot of ambition and love for music. His story about being in the marines and playing music to keep him sane and happy really got me. Also he's hot.
Marisa – I have to go with Sheridan for the "MTV Cribs" style tour of his car. And all the hat jokes. You've got to love someone who can poke fun at himself.
Love Triangle
Who are you shipping Jamie with? Ryan or Trevor?
Taylor – Ryan. Right now Trevor's looks and the fact that he's not the immediate/obvious choice might be tempting for Jamie, but I have a feeling she'll come to realize Ryan was the one for her.
Michael – Although Trevor started off super strong with the golden retriever, Ryan won me over because he just seems more authentic, and he sounded really good singing "Gravity," while Trevor sounded a little soft on his rendition of "Slow Dancing In A Burning Room."
Liv – I do not like Trevor. He gives me major Luke P. energy, just really knows how to say the right things but is way too jealous after a couple days. So far I like Jamie and think that she should be with Ryan. If he isn't a Shawn Mendes look alike I don't know who is. Also, you can just tell that he is such a sweet, genuine guy.
Marisa – Honestly, neither. Jamie seems pretty immature (probably because she's ONLY 21) and the way she pursued both guys without being totally open with either of them rubbed me the wrong way. Ryan is clearly a sweetheart, and I don't think we know enough about Trevor to totally write him off, so I don't think either of them deserve to be led on by Jamie.
Falling Slowly
On a scale from 1 – 10, rate Jamie and Ryan's chemistry on their date.
Taylor – I would say nine! I thought they were precious and really hitting it off! I was sad for Ryan when she chose Trevor over him after they had such a cute date together. Ugh!
Michael – I thought they seemed much more in-tune (music pun alert) than her and Trevor. I give it a solid 8.5. I think the way she looked at him while he was singing "Gravity" was her being genuinely into him.
Liv – I give their chemistry an eight. I feel like they had a lot of pressure on the date because of how much they idolized the producer and band so they didn't have enough of a chance to chat and get to know each other, but while they sang together you could tell that Jamie really trusted Ryan and felt comfortable with him and that's always a good sign.
Marisa – Maybe a seven? As much as Jamie said she was really into Ryan, I wasn't buying it completely. I think she wanted to want Ryan because he was the safer choice but genuinely wanted Trevor from the start.
Rhythm of Love
Do you think Matt made the right decision by taking Mel on his date and not Rudi?
Taylor – Matt rubbed me the wrong way the second he pretended not to know Chris Harrison's name. It's clear he is in it to (try to) win it and unfortunately doesn't care about who he offends in the process — THE Chris Harrison included. I think Matt was right in choosing Mel if he felt he had a stronger connection with her, but he definitely could have done it in a nicer way.
Michael – I don't. I think Matt liked Rudi more but was still put off/being petty about Rudi not wanting to immediately get down in the hot tub and it burned him.
Liv – I honestly don't know, I didn't see Matt and Mel talk together, but that's not to say that they did and we just didn't get to see it. Matt definitely got himself stuck in some hot water so it will be interesting to see how his storyline plays out.
Marisa – I actually do. I got the vibe that Rudi was confusing Matt beyond just the moment in the hot tub where she wouldn't kiss him, and I think he decided to go with someone that felt less complicated. Unfortunately, he and Mel didn't work out, but I doubt he and Rudi would have either. And her true colors really showed when he didn't pick her.
Bad Guy
Who do you think will be this season's villain?
Taylor – Right now, Michael Todd is really setting himself up to be the season's villain based on last night's episode. Though, I don't know… Matt is creeping in as a frontrunner for the role, too (mostly because of that "Chris Hemsworth" comment mentioned above).
Michael – As a pair? Maybe Brandon and Savannah or Jamie and Trevor.
Liv – I feel like Trevor is going to be the one to stir up some trouble. He just seems very fake and snake-like, we also saw his ex's friend come chat with him next week about cheating scandals he was apparently involved in so we will see. Girl wise, I can see Rudi starting up some drama here and there.
Marisa – I know this is an unpopular opinion, but I think Julie gave off some villainy vibes this week! She seems to be treating the show like a season of "The Bachelorette" where she's the star, and I can see her rubbing people the wrong way and ultimately breaking Sheridan's heart.
Can You Feel The Love Tonight?
Which pair are you feeling the most after week one?
Taylor – I stan Julia and Sheridan! I have a good feeling about them.
Michael – Rudi and Ryan! They both got burned by Matt and Jamie respectively, and now they're together. They're both super hot, and we know Ryan is a great singer. If Rudi is talented as well, I think they are going to be a good couple, especially for this show and its narratives.
Liv – Julia and Sheridan are my favorites right now. I really liked them both individually but a lot of the guys want Julia so I can see there being some trouble.
Marisa – This is tough because I'm not really feeling any pairs quite yet, but I do want to see much more of Savannah and Brandon!
Want to be a part of this panel in future weeks? Want to host a panel of your own? Email marisa.dipaolo@theodysseyonline.com for more information!
As an Amazon Affiliate partner, Odyssey may earn a portion of qualifying sales.
