Harry Potter books vs movies
Start writing a post

'Harry Potter' Books Vs. Movies: The Difference Is Huge

Which is better?

'Harry Potter' Books Vs. Movies: The Difference Is Huge
Alexis Hiatt

I've always known that books tend to be more detailed than their movie counterparts but I never realized just how different they can be until I started reading the Harry Potter books after watching the movies.

My mom owned all of the Harry Potter books when I was growing up and I meant to read them earlier but they were so intimidating. There are seven books with hundreds of pages each and I figured the movie would be enough. I was wrong.

Over the years, I grew to love the Harry Potter movies; always excited for the next one to come to theaters. I own all of the movies and I love when the marathons come on TV because I get to sit and watch 16 hours of straight HP. It's glorious.

I am currently on the fourth book and I have a feeling that if I had read the books first, I wouldn't have liked the movies as much as I do. I'm not saying they're bad but some scenes are extremely different in the books compared to the movies. It's kind of confusing since I'm remembering it one way and reading it another so I've noted some of the alterations made between the two versions.

So far, the fourth book differs the most with little details being moved around and occurring in various fashions. Even the beginning nightmare varies due to a lack of a third person and Voldemort actually being seen in his state of weakness, both of which do not coincide with the movie. Along with little details, there are also much bigger details that are completely missing from the movie like the fact that house-elves do not appear at all.

I understand the impossibility of fitting hundreds of pages into a two-hour film but I do feel that directors and producers owe it to the authors to follow the structure of the book as much as possible. The omission of the house-elves changes a lot of details in the movie even though it was a good decision to leave it out. It just seems a bit odd because of how much it appears in the book.

I guess the more important quality of movies is not fitting in all the details but in providing entertainment. The more entertaining, the more people will watch. The tasks are written very differently compared to how they are portrayed in the movie. The danger of the dragon is emphasized in the movie as it breaks loose from its chains and follows Harry around Hogwarts; whereas, in the book, the dragon never leaves the ring created for the champions. The thrill of the second task is more prominent in the movie than in the book, causing Harry to fight harder to succeed.

With all the little details changing, the story doesn't necessarily change but the portrayal of the characters does in small ways. You learn more about the characters when you read the book because there is more to decipher among the words written. But you see how one transforms words into action when you watch the movie. So, it's good to do both and interpret the differences for oneself.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.

The Birthplace of Basketball

The NBA Playoffs are here. It’s kind of funny that my history kind of started out in the same place that basketball’s did too.


Basketball was originally created by James Naismith, a Presbyterian minister who taught P.E. at YMCA in Springfield, Massachusetts. He invented the new game to keep the young men occupied inside during the winter. Borrowing ideas from rugby and a game he used to play as a boy, “duck on the rock”, he thought of nailing up boxes to throw a ball into. He couldn’t find boxes so he used peach baskets instead. The rest of the rules he made up in about an hour.

Keep Reading... Show less

I Met You At The Wrong Time

At least, that's what I keep telling myself.


I met you when I was in middle school and I thought boys still had cooties. I wore flared jeans, Aeropostale shirts, and had the dorkiest braces ever. I cared about what other people thought of me, and I definitely cared a lot about what you thought, too. You were older, and your friends made fun of me when I talked to you. I pretended it didn’t bother me, but it did. I sat two rows in front of you in class, and constantly tried to think of reasons to talk to you. Your hair was a curly mess. It still is. You graduated from middle school a year before me, and I missed you. I don’t think you even knew my name.

Keep Reading... Show less

The Problem With The NBA

Is the NBA losing to College basketball for some sports fans?

New York Times

The annual ESPY award show put on by ESPN was created to reward athletes from around the world for their hard work, skill, determination and more. When Former NFL superstar quarterback Peyton Manning was hosting the ceremony, and in the opening of the show, he absolutely shredded NBA champion Kevin Durant’s move to the Golden State Warriors to create what many sports fans called a “super team.”

Keep Reading... Show less

Why I Don't Believe In Religion

I used to be comfortable with religion, but now I'm uncomfortable.

Rebecca Jarrett

I’m not one of those people who doesn’t believe in God because“if there was a God, why would He let such horrible things happen?” Saying that because sometimes bad things happen, there must be no benevolent higher power, to me, makes about as much sense as saying that because sometimes it gets dark, there must be no light.

Keep Reading... Show less

In Honor Of Mental Health Awareness Month

An open discussion on how much we need an open discussion on mental health awareness

Ashley Wen

Odyssey recognizes that mental well-being is a huge component of physical wellness. Our mission this month is to bring about awareness & normality to conversations around mental health from our community. Let's recognize the common symptoms and encourage the help needed without judgement or prejudice. Life's a tough journey, we are here for you and want to hear from you.

Keep Reading... Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments