Fact Or Fiction?
Start writing a post

Fact Or Fiction?

How reading can influence us not only as individuals, but as a society

Fact Or Fiction?
Reccomendations on Tumblr

How often do you read fiction? It doesn't even have to be a full-blown novel, but any sort of fiction: short stories, poems, or vignettes. Be honest, probably not a lot. Most of us don't read as much as we'd like, and even the people who read a lot wish they could read more. The human mind is always in search of new information, that's why in this world of "instant everything," Snapchat, Buzzfeed, and YouTube reign supreme. There's nothing necessarily wrong with the existence of these things, especially since it provides a platform for so many different voices that may not otherwise be heard, but because of this constant input, we as consumers forget to practice something called "deep reading." Deep reading is a phrase I most recently heard while reading three articles for a literature class. "Deep reading," as opposed to "carnal reading," is the act of reading (usually fiction) and immersing oneself in the story, putting the mind in someone else's shoes and forming empathy for their story. The questions of these articles mainly focus on whether reading fiction makes a person better, more moral, and more empathetic.

Reading Literature Makes Us Smarter and Nicer by Anne Murphy Paul
Does Great Literature Make Us Better? By Gregory Currie
How Reading Makes Us More Human by Karen Swallow Prior

The first two articles I read by Paul and then one by Currie seemed to argue against each other, as Currie claims there is no evidence to support that reading fiction makes a person more moral, while Paul retorts that reading fiction makes a person kinder and more empathetic overtime. The article by Prior however, points out very well that while either may be right or wrong, the two authors are actually making different points. It is not a question of whether reading fiction makes us better people, but that it makes us more human, which I think that both Paul's and even Currie's articles support that. Currie took a much more skeptical approach by saying there wasn't enough evidence to support the idea that fiction makes us better people, but still conceded that it may be possible. He points out the flaw in not knowing which comes first; if it's intelligent and good people that decide to read fiction, or if fiction is making those people good. He puts an emphasis on morality, which I think does relate to Paul's emphasis on empathy, but he states that the moral issues explored in fiction are too specific and not realistic. While fiction can be a sort of theoretical and moral testing ground, he claims that when put to practice in real life, the "expert morality" would fail.

On the other hand, Paul argues that since the reading one does while reading fiction is a deep reading, the immersion that occurs as result allows the reader to empathize with the situation. That existence of empathy is what makes readers who read deeply, or "spiritually," to be kinder, better people. I think that the evidence she provides supports this claim very well, although I will admit that Currie raises reasonable concern as to whether or not the studies are thorough enough. With such a philosophical question that can span and affect one's entire reading career, putting quantitative data in place can be challenging, especially in individual situations. A classmate of mine pointed out that while we may not be able to prove the case of fiction bettering the individual, we can see how it has bettered society as a whole with novels like Uncle Tom's Cabin by Harriet Beecher Stowe and To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee. In these instances, a book of fiction opens up a new perspective to society, spreading interest like the plague and causing a shift in paradigms over important issues such as race, gender, and equality.

For me, I think Prior put it best when she stated that the act of reading is uniquely human, and therefore reading well makes us more human, while reading in a shallow and carnal manner will not enrich nor diminish our humanity. Committing to something and doing it well, as opposed to just going through the motions for the sake of it, is the difference between genuine success and passive mediocrity--- in almost any part of life. As a slower reader myself, who read often as a child, I like to believe I am a more empathetic person, but I can't honestly say it was because of that reading. I don't know if any study will be able to prove something that may just come down to a question of nurture versus nature, but it can't hurt to keep trying.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Politics and Activism

One Indictment, Three Charges, And No Justice For Breonna Taylor

We can't settle for this decision or a system that is fundamentally broken and unequal.


On March 13, 26-year-old Breonna Taylor was fatally shot in her apartment by police who were executing a "no-knock" warrant. Since then, there have been rallying efforts both in the streets and on social media demanding justice for Taylor and keeping her name known.

Keep Reading... Show less

I was so excited to vote in my local primary election in August. I eagerly researched my local candidates, combed the newspaper for profiles and policy positions, and shared infographics on Insta about voting deadlines. I considered myself a keen voter.

Keep Reading... Show less

Nothing! There is no reason to feel guilty about food and nourishing your body. It's time to make peace with food and stop focusing on the "good" or "bad," "right" or "wrong" because food does not have power over you.

Keep Reading... Show less
Health and Wellness

I Sat Down With An Endocrinologist To Ask All My Questions About Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome

There are so many moving parts of hormonal health, so I went to an expert.

Anjanette Tan

Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome (PCOS) is an autoimmune disease that impacts approximately 1 in 10 women. Any woman who has PCOS can attest to the fact that no two cases are the same — there are so many aspects of hormonal health that can impact a woman's reproductive health! For many, PCOS is a trial and error condition, with many doctors' appointments depending on the stage of life the woman is in.

This week I sat down with Dr. Anjanette Tan to get the expert opinion on all my PCOS questions. Dr. Tan is a board-certified endocrinology who's worked in private practices since 2004. She currently works at the Diabetes and Thyroid Center of Fort Worth, one of the largest all-endocrine practices in the area, where she is the managing partner and head of clinical research.

Keep Reading... Show less

- Since I can remember, I've always been a light sleeper, with the quietest sounds waking me up, and I regularly wake up with the sun.

- While talking to a gynecologist friend of mine, she mentioned the importance of using an eye mask for quality sleep, which regulates hormonal levels.

- I was serendipitously sent the Crane & Canopy Silk Sleep Mask almost right after that conversation and was honestly reluctant to try it after testing other sleep masks that felt uncomfortable and irritated my skin.

- This sleep mask was extremely comfortable, and for the first time in nearly a decade, I slept in far past when I usually do on the weekends and woke up feeling more refreshed than I can remember — I've worn it nearly every night since then.

The older I get, it seems that sleep becomes an increasingly important topic of conversation amongst my friends and me. Yes, of course we complain about how tired we always are, but the pattern seemed to be a lack of sleep on the weekdays followed by late nights and sleeping in on the weekends without any solution.

Keep Reading... Show less

As college students, sometimes life can be overwhelming. Four tests in a week and you only passed one of them? I feel that. Days like that, you just need time for yourself. A time where you're nice to yourself and put your own self-care before anything else.

Keep Reading... Show less
Health and Wellness

The Smile Project Just Launched An Ambassador Program, And I Can't Wait To Get Started

Looking to shift your perspective, be happier, or just get involved in something truly amazing? Look no further.


The Smile Project is a nonprofit organization devoted to spreading happiness, founded by Elizabeth Buechele. It all started on a random day in the fall of her senior year. She was driving home from school when this thought crossed her mind: "Day 1: Happiness is…those perfect car rides where the radio just plays all the right songs."

Keep Reading... Show less

I'll never forget the day that someone told me these words: "Madison, I think you're a good friend to everyone but yourself." I stood there completely in awe of that statement. Before that day, I never really thought about being a friend to myself, and at the time, I didn't really know what it meant. Now, I realize that you can't fully be there for other people unless you're there for yourself, too. You can't show up for others until you're willing to show up for yourself.

Here are five things everyone should learn in order to be a better friend to themselves. These steps are hard, but they're so worth it.

Keep Reading... Show less

It's no secret that social media can be harmful to our mental health. The barrage of heavily edited photos of Instagram models that we see every day only fuels our insecurities. There is a good side to social media, though. It allows us to keep up with friends and family across the globe. Plus, it provides a platform for mental health experts. Listed below are five therapists on Instagram who will fill your feed with motivational quotes and positive infographics.

Keep Reading... Show less

Last week, Netflix released its original film "The Devil All the Time," based on the 2011 novel of the same name. Directed by Antonio Campos, the film boasts an all-star cast including Bill Skarsgard, Robert Pattinson, Riley Keough, and Tom Holland.

Keep Reading... Show less
Facebook Comments