Can Police Crack Your Phone Without Your Consent?
Start writing a post

Can Police Crack Your Phone Without Your Consent?

Data Privacy & Constitutional Rights

man in suit holding smart phone

Conversations regarding sensitive data, privacy and wiretapping is no new concept. For decades, public authorities have attempted to possess valuable and sensitive data.

However the way data, information and potential evidence that is legally obtained, ie a search warrant, vs the way new technologies have enabled contractors to attempt to hack passcodes and access electronic devices.

Unbeknownst to the owner of the device, new technology may be leading to unlawfully obtained data falling into the hands of legal authorities.

Recently new technology has been introduced to police outlets that pertain to a potential violation of an individual's fourth amendment rights. This being illegal search and seizure.

Several civil rights and civil liberty advocates have expressed serious concerns and doubts pertaining to the legality of these devices.

What Technology is Being Worked On?

The device in question is called Hide UI by Grayshift and law officials spoke on anonymity out of concern in violating a non-disclosure affidavit (NDA). The law officials shared knowledge that this device attempts to unlock an IPhone ® with the assistance of technology by guessing four to six digit key code variations. Grayshift states that the amount of time differs greatly for unlocking a cell phone with four or six digit pass codes from hours to days, while eight to ten digit pass codes can take months or years to unlock. That's where phase two comes into play.

Phase two of this involves deceitful techniques that may be unlawful. Per the article, an anonymous source states that if an eight or ten digit passcode is used, a law enforcement agent may hand the phone to the suspect and alert the suspect that they can make a phone call to a lawyer, or loved one. Upon unlocking the passcode, an installed application stores the unlocked code in a text file that can later be retrieved by law enforcement officials. But is it legal to mislead a suspect and obtain sensitive and potentially incriminating evidence without a search warrant or disclosure? Can information be pulled from devices without the owner's consent, or a search warrant?

Are These Boxes Legal?

This is a developing story and there is minimal precedent available to fully or accurately provide an answer (at least with regards to Grayshift). However, in several cases, illegally obtained evidence has been thrown out. Additionally, the ACLU has expressed serious concerns regarding the legality of this device and software.

Jason Dunkle, a State College criminal defense attorney, has successfully argued that certain evidence obtained exceeds the scope of the warrant, resulting in the evidence being suppressed. Since many of us are not lawyers, if you believe sensitive information was obtained unlawfully by an official it may be best to consult with an experienced professional regarding the legality of evidence.

Based on the unique jurisdiction of your locality a judge may consider this information to be obtained illegally. Two sources that spoke anonymously on this topic mentioned that a phone will only be plugged into a Grayshift box if they have a search warrant. But what happens if sensitive information obtained from an electronic device is obtained without going through the proper channels to obtain a search warrant?

If information is obtained illegally a judge may have to dismiss the evidence per the exclusionary rule. If the password and hidden software is installed on the device without the suspect's consent, it may be considered entrapment. Per Title 18 § 313, entrapment is defined as:

A public law enforcement official or a person acting in cooperation with such an official perpetrates an entrapment if for the purpose of obtaining evidence of the commission of an offense, he induces or encourages another person to engage in conduct constituting such offense by either:

(1) making knowingly false representations designed to induce the belief that such conduct is not prohibited; or

(2) employing methods of persuasion or inducement which create a substantial risk that such an offense will be committed by persons other than those who are ready to commit it.

If officials persuaded a suspect to unlock their phone and then obtain sensitive information, it may very well be considered entrapment and the evidence thrown out by a judge. This type of software may also be considered an unreasonable search and seizure which can be argued is a violation of the fourth amendment of the US Constitution.

I'm Concerned About My Digital Privacy - What Can I Do?

With more and more services shifting from traditional, in person and paper templates to ones in the digital realm, digital privacy has become an ever growing and quickly evolving legal landscape. Data privacy lawyers are an emerging sector of the legal workforce and have shed doubts and concerns on several public policies.

If you are concerned about your digital privacy being compromised, the best advice is to abstain from using a cell phone. This is an unlikely solution for most people however, as cell phones have become an integral component in most of our daily lives. For many it's the first thing we look at in the morning and last thing we see at night.

Another solution is to ensure that all of your passwords are unique. Don't use the same password that you've used since the ninth grade. If doing so, you put yourself at a much higher risk of data getting hacked. For Iphone ® users, a passcode with ten digits can help secure your privacy. Ensure the number is random and only known to you. Never, ever disseminate sensitive information to anyone to help maximize privacy.

In the coming years and decades one can reasonably expect our data to become even more valuable. There is so much information on our devices that many are doing whatever it takes to obtain this sensitive content. In this ever evolving digital landscape law officials are eager to get information from suspects' electronic devices. However, it is imperative that this sensitive information is obtained legally and not in violation of constitutional rights. A law official can obtain information from an electronic device, but they are mandated by law to obtain a search warrant.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.

Marching Through March

Some appreciation for the month of March.


I love the entire year. Well, for the most part. I'm not a big fan of Winter, but even then, every month has something that's pretty great. November? Thanksgiving. December? Winter Holidays. January? New Year's. February? Valentine's and Single Awareness Day. May? Existential dread during finals. But for me, March has always been my favorite month of the year, and for good reason.

Keep Reading... Show less
Content Inspiration

Top 3 Response Articles of This Week

See what's trending in our creator community!

Top 3 Response Articles of This Week

Welcome to post-spring break week on Odyssey! Our creators have a fresh batch of articles to inspire you as you hit the books again. Here are the top three response articles of last week:

Keep Reading... Show less

5 high paying jobs don't need a college degree

Trade School Graduates Make Lucrative Careers Without College Debt

5 high paying jobs don't need a college degree

The common belief that a college degree is a prerequisite for a high-paying job is no longer as accurate as it once was. In today's fast-paced and ever-evolving world, many lucrative career opportunities do not require a traditional four-year degree. As an expert in career development and workforce trends.

Keep Reading... Show less

The Enduring Legacy of Pink Floyd's 'Dark Side of the Moon

Its the 50 year anniversary

The Enduring Legacy of Pink Floyd's 'Dark Side of the Moon

Since its release on March, 1973, Pink Floyd's "Dark Side of the Moon" has stood the test of time as one of the most iconic and influential albums in the history of rock music. Combining thought-provoking lyrics, innovative production techniques, and a captivating album cover, it captured the imagination of millions of listeners and continues to hold a special place in the hearts of fans worldwide. In this article, we delve into the making, themes, and enduring influence of this groundbreaking album.

Keep Reading... Show less

Dear Los Angeles...With Love,

After packing two oversized suitcases and two carryons with all the boho chic clothes I thought I needed to travel across the country for my dream internship, I quickly realized that although I may look like I belong out in the entertainment capital of the world there was a lot more to it than Free People dresses and fanny packs.

Dear Los Angeles...With Love,
September: Los Angeles

Ever since I was younger I dreamed of moving out to California. There was something so amusing about being in the hub of it all that bursts with passion and artistry wherever you look. After a trip to LA when I was a sophomore in high school for dance, I fell even more in love with this utopia of a city and from that moment on, Los Angeles was that light at the end of the tunnel.

Keep Reading... Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments