Why #AllLivesMatter Does More Harm Than Good | The Odyssey Online
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

Why #AllLivesMatter Does More Harm Than Good

"When you're accustomed to privilege, equality feels like oppression."

50
Why #AllLivesMatter Does More Harm Than Good
theatlantic.com

It seems as though my heart is heavy every time I turn on the news. In the wake of the recent tragedies in Louisiana, Minnesota and Dallas this past week, our nation has been left in disarray as we try to piece together stories of victims in the midst of chaos and violence. There is an anger in America right now that cannot be quelled with a hashtag. Action must be taken, injustices must be addressed and perpetrators must be reprimanded. The question that no one can seem to answer, though, is: how?

I myself do not have the answer to this question. I do not know how to right the wrongs of the American past stemming all the way back to the 1700s, how to stop the mass incarceration of peoples of color or how to bring justice to the staggering number of American lives taken through senseless gun violence just in this past year.

I do know, however, that the answer does not lie in the avoidance of the deeper, systemic issues that plague our nation. This is where I have trouble understanding the validity behind the #AllLivesMatter movement. I understand that the movement originated as a response to the #BlackLivesMatter movement following the riots in Ferguson, and the goal of the movement was to make sure that all people, regardless of race, ethnicity and sexuality, were offered equal representation in the wake of tragedy. The problem with this is that all Americans are not offered the same opportunities, treatment, and representation in daily life. To say that people of color are not treated differently (and not good differently) than the white majority is a privilege-fueled statement that completely undermines the gross injustices against minority populations throughout American history. Race cannot be viewed through a colorblind scope. Not when our nation was founded upon racially restrictive and supremacist legislation, when less than 250 years ago African Americans were enslaved, and when people of color today are incarcerated at a rate three times the rate of white Americans. To view race through the All Lives Matter paradigm, you are essentially saying “Hey, I understand that you’re all here for a funeral, but it’s my birthday so if you could just not…?”.

Of course I understand that all lives do matter. Every life on this Earth has value and importance, and no other human should be granted the permission to so flippantly take that away from someone else (my opinion). However, at a historical crossroads where we as Americans find ourselves in today, now is not the time for the majority to be playing victim. Yes all lives matter, but at a time where black and brown bodies are viewed as dispensable, our efforts must be focused on the enrichment and re-humanization of those who are not offered equal visibility. All lives matter, although wonderful in concept, is idealistic. In order to begin to mend our broken government infrastructure, we must be realistic. We must offer visibility to the underrepresented and systematically oppressed. We must recognize that there is a tangible privilege associated with being white, and that privilege often makes the difference between life or death. We must end race silencing and avoidance of the gross racial inequalities still present in America today. So no, I do not know how to solve these senseless acts of racial violence; I believe, however, that I know where we can start.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Student Life

Things You Can Get Away With Now That You're At College

83% of my trends in college would have been shamed in high school.

252
college life
Google Images

Transitioning from high school to college can be a stressful experience, especially if you're like me and hate change. Over the past two years I've realized there's many things I couldn't get away with in High School that are typically applauded in college.

1. Eat

Keep Reading...Show less
Blair Waldorf

Life is hard. You know what makes it even more tough? Living with chronic b*tch face (CBF). This condition is so debilitating that I have decided to chronicle the 10 things everyone who suffers from CBF experiences. Who better to help me than the queen of CBF herself, Blair Waldorf?

Keep Reading...Show less
Harvard Students

I thought senioritis in high school was rough until I became a college senior about to go into the real world. I'm supposed to have everything figured out, right? I mean I went through four years of tough classes and serious self-searching (and crying). What I found overall was Senioritis sneaking up on me.

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

8 Texts You Get From Your High School Friends

You might not see them everyday anymore, but you're still friends and your text messages prove it.

351
High School Friends
Ashlynn West

It takes a little while to get used to not seeing your high school best friends every day. Going away to college causes a lot of changes, but one thing that will never change is my love for my high school BFFs, and the texts that I get from them. Here are just 8 of the texts I get from them on the weekly:

Keep Reading...Show less
legally blonde

College is filled with many things, and we're so often lectured to make the right decisions as we head out on our own into the college life. But sometimes it's necessary to indulge in some guilty pleasures as well as just doing things because you can. And honestly, a lot of the time it's inevitable. College is no piece of cake that's for sure, so it's okay to do some things you deep down know you shouldn't....once in a while anyways.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments