20 Differences Between The Harry Potter Books And Movies
Entertainment

20 Differences Between The Harry Potter Books And Movies

Because all fans want to know what happened to Peeves.

50422

If I were to say that I love Harry Potter, it would completely underestimate my obsession. I’ve read the books countless times (mostly because I was to embarrassed to keep count over 30), and one of the most serious forms of punishment I received when I was a kid was when my mom threatened to take away my Harry Potter books. I am an avid Harry Potter fan, and I obviously love the movies too.

There’s nothing better than seeing your favorite series come to life, but as with any book-to-film adaptation, there are some oversights and mistakes. While I am rational enough to know that it was impossible to fit every detail of the books into the movies, here are the top 20 differences between books and movies that annoy me most.

1. Peeves the poltergeist.

Peeves was prevalent in every book, and the troublemaker never made it easy for students, teachers and especially the caretaker, Argus Filch. Peeves' constant interference was inspirational, to say the least. Peeves showed blatant disregard for the students and teachers of Hogwarts, with the exceptions of Dumbledore, the Bloody Baron and the Weasley twins. His best moments were when he saluted Fred and George after they had their fun with Umbridge, and the creative poem he sung after the end of the Battle of Hogwarts.

2. Hermione’s potion challenge.

At the end of the first book, the golden trio attempt to make it through three obstacles intended to protect the Sorcerer’s Stone. Both Ron and Harry have a particular challenge that highlight their characteristics (the chess game and the Mirror of Erised, respectively), but in removing this third challenge from the movie, we don’t get to see how Hermione’s bravery and intelligence come together.

3. James Potter’s backstory.

We get very little information about James Potter in the movies, other than the occasional mention from Sirius and the notorious bullying scene with Snape. The information that the movies chose to show makes him seem like a terrible person, but his portrayal in the books is completely different. When Harry begins to question his father's character, Remus and Sirius are there to reassure Harry that James was a good person.

4. The Marauders.

To those who read the books, the Marauders are James Potter, Sirius Black, Remus Lupin and Peter Pettigrew. They are the creators of The Marauder's Map, but their story is only briefly mentioned in the movies. James, Sirius and Peter became unregistered animagi to help Remus during his werewolf transitions, and the movies never mention it. Besides the lack of backstory for these characters, the fact that each of the actors that portrayed the Marauders were about 15 years older than the actual characters undermines the tragedy of their deaths. Overall, this story arch is popular with Harry Potter fans, and I desperately want J. K. to write a more detailed backstory.

5. The Deathday Party.

In "Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets," Sir Nicholas de Mimsy-Porpington (a.k.a Nearly Headless Nick) invites Harry, Ron and Hermione to celebrate his 500th Deathday Party. A lot of interactions with Hogwarts students and ghosts were eliminated in the films, but this party would have been an interesting addition to the movies.

6. Rita Skeeter's secret.

Rita Skeeter was the journalist that everyone loved to hate, but the movies never really show how she gathered the information for her destructive stories. She wrote an article revealing that Hagrid was part giant, and she was able to sneak around because she was an unregistered animagus. She could transform into a beatle, allowing her to spy on the subjects of her stories.

7. Dobby.

Dobby is definitely a beloved character for his involvement in the movies, but he’s more important than you might think. Dobby is the one who suggests that Harry use gillyweed for the Triwizard Tournament, tells Harry about the Room of Requirement for D.A. meetings and constantly appears whenever Harry needs him.

8. Winky.

Winky, a house-elf that formerly belonged to the Crouch family, is another loss to the movie adaptation. If you were ever confused why the Wizarding World made such an uproar when Sirius Black escaped prison, but there was no mention of Barty Crouch Jr.’s escape, Winky is the missing link. Barty Crouch and his wife helped their son to escape, and Winky was left with the responsibility of taking care of him. When Barty Jr. escaped to rejoin "You-Know-Who," Winky was fired and began working at Hogwarts.

9. Kreacher.

Pretty much, all of the important house-elves are neglected in the movies (the irony is not lost on me). The two aforementioned house-elves both play important roles in the series, but so does Kreacher, the crotchety house-elf left to Harry after the death of Sirius. Kreacher believes in the pure-blood mania of his former owners, and he was often found muttering insults under his breath and making the cleanup of 12 Grimmauld Place difficult. He played an integral role in the death of Sirius by divulging information to the Malfoys and lying to Harry about Sirius' whereabouts. However, he also tells Harry and the others the true story of the fake locket horcrux, and his loyalties lie with Harry at the end of the series.

10. The prophecy.

When Harry finds out about the prophecy regarding Voldemort and himself, we're all a little confused. The books cut out a lot of the informational aspects of "Harry Potter and the Order of the phoenix" and "Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince," so there isn't a lot of background information about the somewhat confusing prophecy. Considering that it's one of the more important plot points, I think the films should have spent more time explaining the prophecy.

11. Neville’s importance to the plot.

Neville plays an important role in the movies. He's always there to help Harry, and he destroys Nagini and the Horcrux within her. However, Neville is much more relevant than he seems. The aforementioned prophecy applied to a child who was born at the end of July and whose parents had defied Voldemort three times. Although Voldemort chose Harry, this prophecy applied to anoter child: Neville Longbottom. Neville could have just as easily been the main character of this series, and the movies don't emphasize the importance of Voldemort's choice. However, Voldemort instead chose to eliminate the threat of the Longbottoms by sending Death Eaters to torture Neville's parents mercilessly, until they lost all sanity.

12. The Dursleys' final goodbye.

Throughout the entire book series (and movies), the Dursleys are terrible to Harry. They blame him for everything and shun his magical ability, so it's not surprising that they are widely disliked. However, the movies skipped over Dudley's one moment of redemption. After years of tormenting Harry, Dudley shows some sign of remorse when he shakes Harry's hand and says goodbye.

13. Ginny and Harry’s relationship.

Harry and Ginny had no chemistry on screen, and the movie does a pretty bad job of leading up to their relationship. Ginny's fiery spirit is a perfect match for Harry. The fact that Harry likes Ginny is subtly hinted at throughout a couple of the books, culminating in their relationship at the end of "Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince." Harry breaks up with Ginny to protect her while he goes hunting for Horcruxes, but of course they get back together. The only time the movie really hints at their relationship is that awkward kiss in the Room of Requirement, and it's not an accurate representation of their relationship at all.

14. Peter Pettigrew’s demise.

In "Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban," Harry makes the decision to save Peter Pettigrew’s life, against the wishes of Remus and Sirius. Dumbledore tells Harry that Pettigrew now owes Harry his life. The movie never shows the relevance of this moment, but in the book, when Pettigrew goes to the chamber where Harry and Ron are being kept by the Malfoys, the deed comes full circle. After struggling and losing his wand to Ron, Pettigrew’s silver hand, which was gifted to him by Voldemort, betrays him and strangles Pettigrew.

15. Dumbledore’s backstory.

In the last movie, Harry begins to learn about Dumbledore's past, but it goes much deeper in the books. We learn about Dumbledore's family, the death of his sister Ariana and his relationship with Grindelwald. Learning more about Dumbledore definitely changed my perspective on his character, and it gives you a better idea of what Dumbledore really sees in the Mirror of Erised.

16. Voldemort’s history.

In the books, there is a much larger focus on Harry learning about Voldemort's past. Dumbledore shows Harry a series of memories in order to prepare him for his quest to destroy the Horcruxes, but the movie only shows a few of these. We don't get to see Voldemort's family history, in which we learn that Voldemort's mother gives his muggle father a love potion. The lack of love in Voldemort's past is influential in his future villainy, but the movies completely skip over this information.

17. The Battle of the Astronomy Tower.

In "Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince," Draco approaches Dumbledore on the Astronomy Tower, intending to kill him. Draco uses the vanishing cabinet in the Room of Requirement to penetrate the Hogwarts' defenses. However, in the movie, after all the Death Eaters congregate in the tower and Snape kills Dumbledore, they just leave. In the book, there is a battle fought between the Order of the Phoenix, Dumbledore's Army and the Death Eaters.

18. S.P.E.W.

Hermione is an intelligent, fierce, badass witch but she's also an activist. She started the Society for the Promotion of Elfish Welfare (S.P.E.W.) to help increase better treatment of house-elves, despite the movement's lack of popularity. She knits socks and hats for the house-elves. Even though Dobby winds up keeping all of them, it's endearing to see Hermione so passionate about her cause. Similarly, when Hermione and Ron kiss in the last book, it's after Ron shows an interest in the well-being of the house-elves.

19. Voldemort's death.

Voldemort spends the entire series desperately trying to avoid death—his name literally means "Flight of Death." At the end of the book, Harry and Voldemort are in a standoff, and Harry explains to Voldemort why he's been wrong all along. Harry sets out to prove that Voldemort has to face death eventually because he is no different than anyone else. In the movies, Voldemort slowly disintegrates when he is hit with the killing curse, undermining his humanity.

20. “Harry did you put your name in the Goblet Of Fire!?”

I would be remiss if I didn’t include this scene. We all fondly remember the time in the book when Dumbledore so calmly approaches Harry to ask if he put his name in the Goblet of Fire. While I love Michael Gambon, and believe he is a magnificent actor, I think that he portrayed book Dumbledore quite differently than I had ever pictured him. RIP Richard Harris, you will always be the perfect Dumbledore to me.

There are a lot of disparities not mentioned in this list (such as the mirror Sirius gave Harry, Dumbledore's funeral, the final duel between Harry and Voldemort and the explanation of the wand cores), but some things have to get lost in the transition from book to movie. Although I'm disappointed some of my favorite moments from the books didn't make it to the movies, it won't stop me from having regular Harry Potter movie marathons.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Lifestyle

10 Etsy Father's Day Gifts Under $40 To Support Your Dad And Small Businesses

Stores may still be closed, but the internet is still wide open. So, while you're already shopping online check out Etsy for your Father's Day needs and support small creators.

As June approaches, Father's Day is coming up quickly with it. While they may not ask for much, it's always a nice gesture to give your dad something special to share your appreciation. Although, at the same time, it might be difficult to find the perfect gift either for their humor or that will be practical.

On a normal occasion, it's simple to find a gift for your father figures in stores, but for the times we're currently in our access has become very limited. Small and independent businesses need help now more than ever, so what better time than now to support them? If you're still stuck on what to give for Father's Day, look to this list for some inspiration that won't hurt your wallet too much.

Keep Reading... Show less
Health and Wellness

5 Helpful, Effective Mental Health Resources Specifically For The Black Community

These organizations are qualified, caring, and acknowledging the mental trauma individuals are experiencing.

On May 25, George Floyd died after being pinned to the ground by a Minneapolis police officer. In the last week, protests have sprung up across the nation, demanding justice for Floyd and accountability for police brutality. Social media has also seen widespread conversation regarding Floyd's death, Black Lives Matter, and racism in the United States. Today is #BlackoutTuesday, where many are sharing a single black square to represent unity and support for Black voices.

In light of the heavy climate that our country is facing, it is a safe assumption that many individuals' mental health may be suffering. We wanted to highlight mental health resources and organizations that are Black-owned and prepared to assist in whatever you're going through.

Keep Reading... Show less
Lifestyle

15 Black-Owned Haircare Brands That Cater As Much To Inclusivity As They Do To Your Locks

Championing Black entrepreneurs who make some of our hair favorites.

The haircare industry is vast. With the rise of social media came hundreds of thousands of empowered, niche brands. Single entrepreneurs came out of the woodwork with hair brands that now, years later, have dedicated cult followings.

Of those multitudes of brands, few cater to all hair types, most made without regard for curly or coily hair. These brands, however, are different.

Keep Reading... Show less
Swoon

4 Women Of Color Share How Racism Affects Their Dating Lives, And Everyone Needs To Listen

"My race is typically a factor in almost everything I do, and with dating, it's no different."

Racism affects the daily lives of people of color in the United States, and other parts of the world, in some capacity every day. When it comes to dating and relationships, this is unfortunately no different.

Keep Reading... Show less
Entertainment

13 Movies And Shows On Netflix Directed By Black Men And Women You Need To Watch Now

Take the time right now to watch these fantastic films and TV shows directed by Black men and women.

Netflix

Netflix is notorious for getting us insanely addicted to watching TV and films. From documentaries, true crime, reality, and fiction, we get very sucked in.

Right now the American people are fighting for the lives of our Black brothers and sisters, so instead of watching "The Office" for the 30th time, take the time to watch these 13 films and TV shows directed by Black men and women.

Keep Reading... Show less

I love working out, it makes me feel great. It helps my mood, sleep schedule and I just feel overall healthier. Recently I wanted to focus more on my glutes than I previously had been. At the gym, I would just go to the squat bar to do my thing and call it a day. But since we have been home in quarantine I feel like squats just aren't doing it for me but even if I love doing them. Doing squats I always have felt does more for banging my thighs than it ever did for my butt. It made them so big, which I didn't mind except I felt it made my butt look pretty much the same. Straying from squats, and the fact that gyms will probably remain closed for a while, sent me on a fitness journey to see what other exercises I could do at home with no or very little equipment needed. Hopefully, these exercises will help keep your booty banging.

1. Diamond Leg Lifts

Keep Reading... Show less
Lifestyle

10 Podcasts On Race Everyone Should Listen To In Order To Be A Better Ally

Listen and learn, because knowledge is power.

Podcasts are such an integral part of some of our everyday lives that it can be hard to recall a time at which they didn't exist. Podcasts exist on about every single topic, from dating to celebrity gossip and Harry Potter.

Now more than ever, it's likely you're reeling from the news, and (hopefully) wanting to do something about it in order to educate yourself. Podcasts are one of the best ways to get the most up-to-date information in a conversational, personal way from some of today's top educators, scholars, and theorists.

Keep Reading... Show less
Swoon

Stop Pitying Me Because I'm Single, I'm Very Happy With My Relationship With Myself

I don't need your opinions on why I'm single and you're not. We are two different people.

I'm so happy for my friends when they get into relationships, but that doesn't mean they get to have control over my love life, and that is what bothers me. For the record, I've been in four relationships, one lasting for three years, so I do understand relationships.

Keep Reading... Show less
Facebook Comments