Worst Academy Award Mistakes Of The Past 25 Years
Start writing a post

Worst Academy Award Mistakes Of The Past 25 Years

How did the Academy make these glaring mistakes?

Worst Academy Award Mistakes Of The Past 25 Years
Wikimedia Commons

The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences will give out their annual Academy Awards (Oscars) on Sunday. They have made some very good decisions in its long and storied history. They also have made some very bad ones. For sake of your interest, as people like to hear about mistakes in this field, here are some of the worst of the worst (in one person's opinion) in the past 25 years. Poring over the list of recent Oscar results shocked me on numerous occasions.

Qualifications for consideration:
For a mistake to be considered, it must have occurred in 1992 or later.
For a mistake to be considered, it must have been at the expense of another nominee for the award.
For a mistake to be considered, it must have been a mistake in one of the six major categories (Picture, Director, Actor, Actress, Supporting Actor, or Supporting Actress).

Without further ado:

10. Best Actor of 1998

Won: Roberto Benigni for his role in "Life is Beautiful"
Deserved to win: Edward Norton for his role in "American History X"

Full disclaimer: this is not American bias. There are some foreign films that had great performances. "Life is Beautiful" isn't one of them. It may be a bias in favor of "American History X," as it was the better film, but I think: one, playing a Nazi is harder than playing someone persecuted by Nazis; two, Norton simply did a better job. As I said, I may be biased too much in favor of the film, so it's not as high as some other upsets.

9. Best Supporting Actor of 1996

Won: Cuba Gooding Jr. for his role in "Jerry Maguire"
Deserved to win: William H. Macy for his role in "Fargo"

While I like "Jerry Maguire" quite a bit, I see it really as more of a guilty pleasure than a film that should win Oscars. Now, this wasn't all that much of a mistake (Best Supporting Actor/Actress isn't talked about very much, see also below), but Macy was, again, the better executor of a more difficult role. And it deserves mention, but not a very high place on the list.

8. Best Supporting Actress of 1992

Won: Marisa Tomei for her role in "My Cousin Vinny"
Deserved to win: Judy Davis for her role in "Husbands and Wives"

See above. This is almost an identical case, and No. 9 should really be "8b." But I don't do that. Still, better movie, harder role, better execution, low level of importance.

7. Best Actress of 1998

Won: Gwyneth Paltrow for her role in "Shakespeare in Love"
Deserved to win: Cate Blanchett for her role in "Elizabeth"

"Shakespeare in Love" is one of the most overrated films of all time. "Elizabeth" is one of the most underrated 90's films, chiefly due to Blanchett playing the titular character. So why did Paltrow win? The Academy, I guess, cared more about the life of the commoner (Shakespeare's lover) than the queen (Elizabeth) in that time period, at least in depiction.

6. Best Actor of 2002

Won: Adrian Brody for his role in "The Pianist"
Deserved to win: Daniel Day-Lewis for his role in "Gangs of New York"

Yes, I'm saying that the only person who has ever won Best Actor three times deserved it four times. That is out of the way now, so I can tell you that Day-Lewis played a much more compelling character. That's the job of an actor, right? He totally deserved it.

5. Best Director of 2001

Won: Ron Howard for "A Beautiful Mind"
Deserved to win: David Lynch for "Mulholland Drive"

To be fair, I was moved by "A Beautiful Mind," owing to the fact that I have acute anxiety and profound intelligence (my experience is that those two things occur together more often than not). But no one will be able to convince me that Lynch did not do a better job directing "Mulholland Drive." I mean, come on. While both films are highly acclaimed, "Mulholland Drive" has more accolades outside the Oscars. Lynch is a big reason why.

4. Best Picture of 1995

Won: "Braveheart"
Deserved to win: "Apollo 13"

"Apollo 13" is one of my favorite films of all time. Braveheart was boring by comparison. I have been thrilled by "Apollo 13" ever since I was about six years old. But I know exactly why the Academy made their fourth-biggest mistake since 1992, and it is directly tied to their third-biggest.

3. Best Picture of 1994

Won: "Forrest Gump"
Deserved to win: "Pulp Fiction"

Many would say "The Shawshank Redemption" deserved to win, which it certainly did more than "Forrest Gump." But here's what it boils down to: The Academy chose the wrong Tom Hanks film. If they had waited a year to give the award to "Apollo 13" and given "Pulp Fiction" the award for 1994, this would only be a top eight. "Pulp Fiction" is one of the greatest and most influential films of the 1990's. "Forrest Gump"? Just a quaint curiosity by comparison.

2. Best Picture of 1998

Won: "Shakespeare in Love"
Deserved to win: "Saving Private Ryan"

How? I mean, come on. Were the voters put off by the gore of the first half hour? I fast-forwarded through most of it as well, but "Shakespeare in Love"? "Saving Private Ryan" is obviously the better film. Obviously. It's more captivating and not overrated one bit.

1. Best Picture of 2005

Won: "Crash"
Should have won: "Brokeback Mountain"

When I watched "Crash," ten years after this debacle, my biggest question was this: how was it even nominated? Winning went farther still, but if you make a film that bad, you shouldn't expect the Academy to even look at you. But the Academy gave it to "Crash" instead of "Brokeback Mountain" for one reason only: they didn't want to be accused of progressive bias in favor of "Brokeback Mountain" being a story about two gay men. But when the choice is that obvious, you can throw those potential allegations out the window.

Best of luck to all the people involved in filmmaking on Oscar night, and best of luck to the Academy for an eleventh straight year without a decision this bad!

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
New Year Resolutions

It's 2024! You drank champagne, you wore funny glasses, and you watched the ball drop as you sang the night away with your best friends and family. What comes next you may ask? Sadly you will have to return to the real world full of work and school and paying bills. "Ah! But I have my New Year's Resolutions!"- you may say. But most of them are 100% complete cliches that you won't hold on to. Here is a list of those things you hear all around the world.

Keep Reading...Show less

The Ultimate Birthday: Unveiling the Perfect Day to Celebrate!

Let's be real, the day your birthday falls on could really make or break it.

​different color birthday candles on a cake
Blacksburg Children's Museum

You heard it here first: birthdays in college are some of the best days of your four years. For one day annually, you get to forget about your identity as a stressed, broke, and overworked student, and take the time to celebrate. You can throw your responsibilities for a day, use your one skip in that class you hate, receive kind cards and gifts from loved ones and just enjoy yourself.

Keep Reading...Show less

Unleash Inspiration: 15 Relatable Disney Lyrics!

Leave it to Disney to write lyrics that kids of all ages can relate to.

The 15 most inspiring Disney songs

Disney songs are some of the most relatable and inspiring songs not only because of the lovable characters who sing them, but also because of their well-written song lyrics. While some lyrics make more sense with knowledge of the movie's story line that they were written for, other Disney lyrics are very relatable and inspiring for any listener.

Keep Reading...Show less

The Six Most Iconic Pitbull Lyrics Of All Time

Mr. Worldwide just wants to see you succeed.

a photo of artist Pitbull

It is no secret that Pitbull is a gifted artist, but many fail to remember that he can be a source of great inspiration as well. The following is a list of iconic Pitbull lyrics that we know and love. Read on to feel empowered — if you think you can handle it.

Keep Reading...Show less

11 Essential Expectations for Becoming the Ultimate Cheermeister

Mastering Festive Expectations: Tips to Shine as Your Holiday Cheermeister

Crazy for Christmas

So you’ve elected yourself as this year's Holiday Cheermeister, there’s no shame in that. The holidays are your pride and joy, and you've taken on the responsibility to get everyone in the spirit. With only one week until Christmas, here are some things we expect from you, Cheermeister.

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments