Why Lord of the Rings Was Better Than The Hobbit
Start writing a post
Entertainment

Why Lord of the Rings Was Better Than The Hobbit

A quick breakdown of what LotR got right, but The Hobbit lacked

413
Why Lord of the Rings Was Better Than The Hobbit
Wallpaper Abyss

I still remember arriving in the theater in December 2012, settling into my seat and preparing myself for the epic journey I anticipated. I had purchased my ticket for The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey and had been waiting for months to see it.

Like many, I was sorely disappointed. And the two following Decembers brought nothing even remotely better in the movie's two sequels.

I walked out of the theater with almost a sense of shock, that the genius behind the Lord of the Rings series, barely 10 years prior, had cranked out such mediocrity. Peter Jackson's original trilogy, now ranked among some of the greatest films of all time, each scored in the mid-90s on Rotten Tomatoes. The Hobbit trilogy, by contrast, scored 60, 75, and 64, respectively, for its three movies. Not pure drivel, but certainly not anywhere near the caliber of their predecessors.

So what happened?

I think the difference can all be boiled down to one element: heart. And here's why.

Despite having a prologue that's not only rich in lore but also visually epic, The Fellowship of the Ring (2001) doesn't try to ram characters down the viewer's throat one after another. We open to the actual story with Bilbo writing a passage into his book, taking his time to explain the simple life of the Shire. Then we are introduced to Frodo, then Gandalf, eventually Sam and Aragorn, and it is only halfway through the first movie that we are introduced to the rest of the Fellowship.

At this point, the viewer has already been drawn into Frodo's story. As he meets new characters, so does the viewer, because they feel they are there with him. Contrast this with The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012). The young Bilbo is hardly given any screen time before he is quite literally dumped with thirteen dwarves, few of whom are given any substantial dialogue or even character throughout the rest of the nine-hour trilogy.

While obviously, both trilogies had relatively large casts, the first did a better job of managing it. How? By splitting the main characters into different but intertwining journeys. For instance, at the end of the first film, Merry and Pippin are being hauled away by Uruk-hai, Sam and Frodo have left on a boat, Gimli, Legolas and Aragorn are chasing the former pair of Hobbits, and Gandalf and Boromir have both died, although both continue to impact the plot in their ways.

As a result, each character is given ample dialogue and screen time and we see how they react under pressure and in a small group setting, both of which are criteria for effective character development. The Hobbit trilogy struggled to make their characters significant or relatable to the audience in any meaningful way because they had a main cast of 15 characters who stayed together for the majority of the runtime. One of the dwarves, Bombur, never even had one line of dialogue written for him.

Lastly, The Lord of the Rings was meaningful because it told human stories. Did the characters grapple with mass armies of monsters and dragons and ghost soldiers and hooded wraiths and massive beasts? Absolutely.

But did the characters also deal with a son hopelessly trying to win the approval of his father, and of a niece trying to prove her worth and help her uncle, and of a man struggling with his own mortality and knowing his lover will outlast him by millennia, and of the pressure put on the relationship between two friends? Absolutely.

Frankly, The Hobbit movies tell nothing of this caliber or with anywhere near the level of nuance of their predecessors. Subplots felt forced, nuance was abandoned, characters' motivations were one-dimensional, and the characters as a whole felt incomplete.

In conclusion, you are very much allowed to like The Hobbit movies. They were still enjoyable in parts and fun to watch; but in my opinion, nothing will ever come close to achieving the emotional gravitas of The Lord of the Rings.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Featured

4 Common Reasons Couples Get Divorced

Are some people just not meant to be together? Is there any way to prevent an impending divorce?

39572
4 Common Reasons Couples Get Divorced

We've all heard the statistics. Roughly 50% of married couples eventually end up divorced. This can lead to complications, problems with your children, financial issues, and no small amount of negative emotions.

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

​Pets are Good for the Soul

Millions of Americans have found comfort in pet ownership. The media has been awash with stories about a surge in pet ownership, as Americans have taken advantage of the ability of pets to improve emotional well-being.

49804
Good for the Soul
Pets are Good for the Soul

America is going through a mental health crisis. This crisis predates the global pandemic, but has in many ways been dramatically exacerbated by it. In 2019, 19.86% of adults, or 50 million Americans, reported suffering from a mental illness. The emotional toll of the pandemic has been heavy, with over half of U.S. adults saying that they have experienced stress and worry related to Covid-19. Anxieties over work, uncertainty about the future and other triggers have intensified the mental health crisis. Millions of Americans have found comfort in pet ownership. The media has been awash with stories about a surge in pet ownership, as Americans have taken advantage of the ability of pets to improve emotional well-being.

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

How Your Sleep Position Affects Your Health?

You changed into your pajamas, turn off the lights, and get yourself ready to sleep. How do you prefer to sleep, on the back, on your side, or on your tummy? Although there’s no scientific result that sleeping position affects your back, here are some interesting facts that have been discovered.

165175
Sleep Position

You changed into your pajamas, turn off the lights, and get yourself ready to sleep. How do you prefer to sleep, on the back, on your side, or on your tummy? Although there’s no scientific result that sleeping position affects your back, here are some interesting facts that have been discovered.

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

How to Throw the Ultimate Winter Bash

As the year starts to come to an end, make sure you find the time to have some fun as well.

116594
Ultimate Winter Bash

As the year starts to come to an end, make sure you find the time to have some fun as well.

Keep Reading... Show less
Featured

Prose: When The Gavel Falls (Story Excerpt)

Johnathan Yarrow is a successful defense attorney, until he takes on a personal case he cannot win. Ruined by the loss and haunted by his past, Yarrow, a man who desired to see the good in all people, starts to learn that not everyone can be good... not even himself.

108062
Prose: When The Gavel Falls (Story Excerpt)
https://unsplash.com/s/photos/lawyer

I woke up, like any other night, in a bed full of nightmares, drenched in sweat that stuck coldly to my skin, as a reminder of the dreams I couldn’t escape. The dream was so vivid, I felt it physically burn on my cheek. I wondered if the sting from the slap was worse simply because her eyes held no remorse, not an ounce of respect.

Keep Reading... Show less
Facebook Comments