9 Times The 'Harry Potter' Books Clearly Got Political

9 Times The 'Harry Potter' Books Clearly Got Political

Reading these books as a child, you probably passed right over the political commentary layered within the story.
807
views

If you're the obsessive "Harry Potter" fan that re-reads the series at various intervals throughout your life, you can attest to the fact that reading these books as an adult is a vastly different experience from reading them as a kid. For one, you tend to pick up on details that your younger self-overlooked.

For me, this was definitely true when it came to the political statements buried within the text. It's no secret that J.K. Rowling harbors passionate beliefs when it comes to public affairs, so it makes sense that these would shine through her writing.

However, a part of me was still surprised to discover all of the social commentaries I'd passed by years ago. "Harry Potter" teaches kids about way more than just love if they manage to catch it. It demonstrates political machinations at work, both in the Wizarding World and in our world.

1. The consequences of prejudice

This is the only item on the list that I did catch on my first read. It's impossible to miss the pureblood prejudice toward Muggleborns, considering it's the basis of the entire series. It's clear that this obsession with the purity of wizarding blood is the Wizarding World equivalent of racism, and it serves as a rallying point for Voldemort and his Death Eaters.

Rowling's story depicts how much suffering is caused by prejudice, and it encourages fans to fight it.

2. The importance of a fair judicial system

Until re-reading these novels, I never realized how prevalent the theme of conviction without a fair trial is throughout the series. Numerous characters are shipped off to Azkaban without any opportunity to declare their innocence.

Sirius Black is the primary example of this, but we see it in other instances as well. In "Chamber of Secrets," Hagrid is taken away without any proof that he's been opening the Chamber of Secrets. "Prisoner of Azkaban" shows Buckbeak's biased and laughable facade of a trial. And Stan Shunpike is arrested later in the series, despite many people insisting that he's probably under the Imperius curse.

Of course, all of these characters would be capable of defending themselves if given a fair trial.

Again and again, the consequences of an unjust criminal justice system are brought to light. And the results are never good.

3. S.P.E.W. and political indifference

Hermione's failed attempts to rouse support for house elf rights becomes a bit of a running joke throughout the series. All of the characters, including her friends, scoff at her futile attempts to organize for a cause she believes in. Eventually, readers find themselves shaking their heads at her as well.

But the joke's on us. That the characters' indifference extends to readers tells us something about the effect political apathy has on society. If the majority regard injustice as the norm, many of us are happy to follow suit.

4. The connection between wealth and power

"My father will hear about this!" Malfoy's famous line is another fandom-wide joke, but something more sinister lies beneath the Malfoy family's ability to pull strings to get what they want.

Lucius Malfoy's numerous connections within the Ministry of Magic are an obvious result of his wealth. It's implied that his money is the reason he was able to escape Azkaban after Voldemort's disappearance, and it's also given him a fair amount of say in the Ministry's actions.

Through the Malfoy family, Rowling makes it clear that money can buy you a certain amount of power, particularly in the political sphere. But given the use of their wealth, this doesn't seem something we should aspire to.

5. Keeping government out of education

The Ministry's interference at Hogwarts plays a huge role throughout "Order of the Phoenix," and it's made abundantly clear that readers are meant to resent this intrusion as much as the characters do. Umbridge's speech on doing away with "progress for the sake of progress" is not only reminiscent of political figures, hanging desperately onto their outdated views, but it also demonstrates how schools can be used as political weapons.

The Educational Decrees that Umbridge passes to grant herself more governance at Hogwarts yield a great deal of resistance, but the Ministry forces its morals and beliefs onto the student population. Anyone deviating from their standards is investigated in an attempt to throw them out.

The entire storyline involving the Ministry at Hogwarts shows the dangers of bringing politics into education, particularly when it comes to letting kids develop their thoughts and values.

6. Political influence on the media

It's no secret that news organizations tend to show bias depending on their political affiliations. News in the Wizarding World is no exception to this rule, a fact Rowling demonstrates throughout "Order of the Phoenix."

From the moment that Harry and Dumbledore cross the Minister of Magic, The Daily Prophet begins tarnishing their reputations accordingly. The paper makes snide remarks questioning their sanity and implying poor motives. At the worst of times, the Prophet flat out lies to its readers, intent on backing anything Cornelius Fudge deems the truth.

And it's clear as day that Fudge is the one who put them up to writing these scathing articles. He'd do anything to debunk Voldemort's return.

In "Half-Blood Prince," however, the Prophet's stance changes with the Minister. Rufus Scrimgeour is now backing Harry's story, and the paper begins referring to him as "The Chosen One" yet again. Rowling shows how easily our sources of news can be corrupted, particularly when under government influence.

7. Celebrity influence on politics

Celebrities have much sway when it comes to public opinion, and smart politicians use this to their advantage. We see this clearly in "Half-Blood Prince" when Scrimgeour, the newly elected Minister of Magic, tries to persuade Harry to be the Ministry's poster boy.

It's a clever tactic Scrimgeour uses, and he's probably correct in believing that it would raise morale if Harry were seen giving the Ministry a thumbs up. The public puts a certain trust in celebrity opinions, which shows how easily one person can persuade a group to vote a certain way.

And given that Scrimgeour wants to use Harry's influence to pull the wool over the public's eyes, we can see that this sort of celebrity authority may not always be a positive thing.

8. Dumbledore's take on tyranny

During "Half-Blood Prince," Dumbledore and Harry discuss the prophecy that landed Harry in his current situation. Dumbledore is insistent on making the point that Voldemort's choice to abide by the prophecy is what led to his downfall. Choices are undoubtedly a huge theme in the series, but Dumbledore then takes the conversation a step further. He tells Harry:

"Voldemort himself created his worst enemy, just as tyrants do everywhere! Have you any idea how much tyrants fear the people they oppress? All of them realize that, one day, amongst their many victims, there is sure to be one who rises against them and strikes back!"

This is a powerful analysis of oppression, and there's truth in Dumbledore's statement. Oppressors create their downfalls simply by the way they treat people. This is more than an explanation of the prophecy. It's the reason tyranny cannot last.

9. Standing your ground against injustice

The biggest political takeaway from "Harry Potter" is that change doesn't happen overnight. You have to keep fighting for what you believe is right, even in the face of adversity. The trio never ceases their efforts against Voldemort, regardless of the obstacles in their way.

Harry carries on contradicting Umbridge, even after she has him carve "I must not tell lies." into the back of his hand. Dumbledore and the Order continue to rally against Voldemort, even with the Ministry fighting them as well.

The repeated message throughout this series is to keep fighting for what's right, even if you're in the minority, and even if you're the only one.

And there's something beautifully political about that.

Cover Image Credit: Warner Bros. Pictures

Popular Right Now

14 Stages Of Buying Jonas Brothers Concert Tickets As A 20-Something In 2019

"Alexa, play "Burnin' Up" by the Jonas Brothers."

14138
views

In case you missed it, the Jonas Brothers are back together and, let me tell you, they're giving us some major jams. For those of us who were there when it all began back in 2007 with their first album, It's About Time, this has been one of the most important events of the year. But nothing, and I mean nothing can rival the excitement every twenty-something felt as the Jonas Brothers announced their Happiness Begins tour. I, for one, put my name in for ticket presale, have been following every single social media site related to the tour/group, and, of course, listening to the Jonas Brothers on repeat. And if you did manage to snag tickets, then you know that this is how your brain has been ever since they announced the tour.

1. Finding out that they're going on tour

2. Hopefully entering your name into the lottery to get presale tickets

3. Finding out that you actually get to buy presale tickets

4. Impatiently waiting for your presale tickets by listening to their songs on repeat

5. And remembering how obsessed you used to be (definitely still are) with them

6. Trying to coordinate the squad to go to the concert with you

7. Waiting in the Ticketmaster waiting room...

8. ...And feeling super frantic/frustrated because there are about 2000 people in line in front of you

9. Actually getting into the site to buy the tickets

10. Frantically trying to find seats you can actually pay for because, let's be real, you're twenty-something and poor

11. Managing to actually get the seats you want

12. Joyfully letting your squad know that you've done it

13. Crying a little because all of the dreams you've had since 2007 are coming true

14. Listening to every single Jonas Brothers song on repeat (again)

If you, like me, have finally fulfilled one of your dreams since childhood, then congrats, my friend! We've made it! Honestly, of all the things I've done in my adult life, this might be the one that child me is the most proud of.

Related Content

Connect with a generation
of new voices.

We are students, thinkers, influencers, and communities sharing our ideas with the world. Join our platform to create and discover content that actually matters to you.

Learn more Start Creating

Severus Snape Is The Worst, And Here's Why

Albus Severus, sweetie, I'm so sorry...

335
views

I grew up being absolutely obsessed with the Harry Potter franchise. I read the books for the first time in second and third grade, then again in middle school, and for the third time in my last year of high school. Recently, I had a somewhat heated argument with a fellow fan of the books about Severus Snape. As I've reread the Harry Potter books, I've noticed that, although J.K. Rowling tried to give him a redemption arc, he only got worse because of it. Here's why I still think Severus Snape is the absolute worst.

His love for Lily Potter was actually really creepy. When I was younger and reading the books, I always found the fact that he held fast in his love for Lily to be very endearing, even noble. However, rereading it after going through a couple of relationships myself, I've come to realize that the way he pined over her was super creepy. It was understandable during his time at Hogwarts; he was bullied, and she was the only one who "understood" him. However, she showed zero interest, and if that didn't clue him into realizing that he should back off, her involvement with James Potter should have. She was married. He was pining after a married, happy woman. If he truly loved her, he would have realized how happy she was and backed off. Instead, he took it out on her orphan son and wallowed in bitterness and self-pity, which is creepy and extremely uncool. When a girl is kind to a boy during high school (or in this case, wizard school), it's not an open invitation for him to pine for her for the literal rest of his life and romanticizes the absolute @#$% out of her. It's just her being a decent person. Move on, Severus.

He verbally abused teenagers. One of the most shocking examples of this is in The Prisoner of Azkaban when Snape literally told Neville Longbottom that he would kill his beloved toad, Trevor if he got his Shrinking Potion wrong, and then punished him when he managed to make the potion correctly. Furthermore, poor Neville's boggart was literally Snape. The amount of emotional torture Neville must have been enduring from Snape to create this type of debilitating fear must have been almost unbearable, and even if Snape was simply trying to be a "tough" professor, there is no excuse for creating an atmosphere of hostility and fear like he did in his potions class for vulnerable students like Neville. In addition, he ruthlessly tormented Harry (the last living piece of Lily Potter, his supposed "true love," btw), and made fun of Hermione Granger's appearance. Sure, he might have had a terrible life. However, it's simply a mark of poor character to take it out on others, especially when the people you take it out on are your vulnerable students who have no power to stand up to you. Grow up.

He willingly joined a terrorist group and helped them perform genocide and reign over the wizarding world with terror tactics for a couple of decades. No explanation needed as to why this is terrible.

Despite the constant romanticization of his character, I will always see the core of Severus Snape, and that core is a bitter, slimy, genocidal, manipulative trash being. J.K. Rowling's attempt to redeem him only threw obsessive and controlling traits into the mix. Snape is the absolute worst, and romanticizing him only removes criticism of an insane man who just so happened to be capable of love (just like the vast majority of the rest of us). Thank you, next.

Related Content

Facebook Comments