The Pink Tax is not a literal tax that states implement, but it still exists in our economy today. The idea behind the Pink Tax is that products targeted towards women often cost more than a similar product that targets men. This includes almost all consumer items that are subject to a gender norm; clothing, toys, personal care products, etc.
A study posted by USA Today found that women's clothing cost 8% more than men’s. A side-by-side comparison of red, short-sleeve polo shirts used as uniforms showed a $2 difference despite there being no obvious difference in style or quality. Both came from the same retailer. In another situation, a side-by-side comparison of two Radio Flyer My 1st Scooters showed this: a red scooter cost $24.99 and a pink scooter cost $49 despite them being identical in all other ways. It also found that women's personal care products also cost 13% more than men’s.
The argument for the reason these products need to be marked-up in price is their production. An argument made by Mises Institute is that in the case of hygiene products, it must be remembered that men and women have different standards of hygiene leading to very different demand curves. While this is true, I personally find many of these added elements are unnecessary.
Take razors as an example: men’s razors are focused on precision, getting a close shave, and having good blades. Women’s razors are focused on providing smooth shaves, precision, and shaves a larger space.
However, the added lotion strips often take away from the precision of the razor and the rest of the construction looks the same as men’s except for the clear color differences. I personally switched over to men’s razors because they do what they are supposed to do, shave while costing less, and last longer.
While products like razors and shaving cream may have more grounds for price markups on the grounds of their production, items like clothing and especially toys do not. It is often the case that the same product gets marked up for having a specific color, pattern, or general “girly” effect. In an article by Listen Money Matters, it was noted that Old Navy got busted for charging more for women’s plus-sized clothing, but not for men’s.
One comparison however that personally bothers me more than others is when you compare two considered necessities to solving biological phenomenon: the issue of period products versus Viagra. While many states are slowly exempting feminine hygiene products from sales tax, it is changing at a slow rate. Tax Foundation noted that only 12 states exempt period products from sales tax and that five of them just do not have a sales tax.
In comparison, Politifact noted that Viagra, the drug for erectile dysfunction, is only taxed in one state, Illinois. Both erectile dysfunction and menstruation are natural biological occurrences that cannot be controlled. While ED is common, The National Institutes of Health estimates that erectile dysfunction strikes as many as 30 million men in the United States; it is less common than the fact that every woman, barring medical issues, goes through her period.
Tampons and pads are a necessity to any female on her period. We cannot just hold it in. These products are vital in helping women manage their periods. However, in many places, they are still considered a luxury and therefore are not exempt from sales tax. However, they are a necessity. When a female is on her period, she will bleed non-stop for anywhere between 4-8 days; without period products, this would incapacitate most women from being able to go about their regular day.
While there may be reasons for certain discrepancies in pricing between gendered products due to production issues, the reality is it happens too often to products that do not need to be marked up. The Pink Tax needs to be addressed as a real problem. The issue of tampons and pads still counting as a luxury item should be the start. Until then, I recommend finding non-gendered products or using men’s products. They often work just as well and are cheaper.



















