Not Your Cherry Blossoms: Southeast Asian Americans Vs. The Model Minority Myth
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

Not Your Cherry Blossoms: Southeast Asian Americans Vs. The Model Minority Myth

The "model minority" argument about Asian Americans poses a risk and hindrance to Southeast Asian American development.

Not Your Cherry Blossoms: Southeast Asian Americans Vs. The Model Minority Myth

The “model minority” notion which broadly paints the Asian American population has rendered Southeast Asian Americans – who remain with large socioeconomic obstacles impeding their communities’ successes – invisible to policymakers and to the American public, inhibiting the widespread implementation of effective assistance to vulnerable Southeast Asian Americans nationwide.

The discussion surrounding the "model minority" assertion recently resurfaced in public attention with the publication of Andrew Sullivan's "Why Do People Feel Sorry for Hillary Clinton?" in New York Magazine. At the end of the article, in arguing that centuries of oppressive structures can be overcome by hard work and traditional family values, Sullivan claims that "Asian Americans are among the most prosperous, well-educated, and successful ethnic groups in America".

In 2016, in honor of Asian Pacific American Heritage Month, the Nielsen company released a report titled “Asian Americans: Culturally Diverse and Expanding Their Footprint”. One of the key statements made in the report that often backs the "model minority" assertion was that “with a household median income of $74,829, the median Asian-American household income is 39% greater than the national median income of $53,657”.

Although the average household income for Asian Americans has recently surpassed the average household income for most Americans, according to a report on income and poverty from the Center for American Progress’s “State of Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders” series, Southeast Asian Americans continue to remain in relatively high levels of poverty and low levels of household income. Asian Americans in general also tend to live in multi-generational households. Therefore, in addition to having lower household incomes, Southeast Asian Americans split those lower household incomes with both immediate and extended family members, reducing the spending capabilities of Southeast Asian Americans as individuals and compounding economic vulnerability of Southeast Asian Americans as a community with individual financial weaknesses.

While Asian American families and individuals originally from Japan, China, and India often migrated voluntarily to pursue educational and vocational opportunities, a majority of Southeast Asian Americans left their countries of origin involuntarily as refugees. Therefore, Southeast Asian Americans and Southeast Asian American families were and are more unprepared and unequipped to adapt to life in the United States. Data collected from Southeast Asian American communities reflects this difference in their capability to adapt. The AAPI Data project by Karthick Ramakrishnan at the University of California, Riverside published data that reveals that most Southeast Asian Americans are more likely to be uninsured, have more difficulties paying for college educations, are less likely to hold a bachelor's degree or higher, are more likely to be unemployed, and are more likely to have lower-quality children's education. Converse to the "model minority" notion, AAPI Data also recently reported data that demonstrates that most Southeast Asian Americans have significantly high rates of limited English proficiency: 54 percent, 58 percent, and 60 percent for Cambodian Americans, Thai Americans, and Vietnamese Americans, respectively.

These devastating numbers extend to Southeast Asian American elders, illustrating how detrimental the obstacles Southeast Asian American communities face are as they continue throughout Southeast Asian Americans' lives. According to the Southeast Asia Resource Action Center (SEARAC), Southeast Asian American elders are twice as likely to be impoverished than elders overall, and over 85 percent of older Vietnamese, Laotian, Cambodian, and Hmong Americans have limited English proficiency.

Andrew Sullivan's assertion that Asian Americans are largely affluent and socioeconomically secure – similar to many other claims that Asian Americans are the "model minority" – is a detrimental generalization of the Asian American population that erases the grave issues of poverty, education, and health in the Southeast Asian American community, as well as other disadvantaged Asian American subgroups. Without disaggregating and contextualizing the data used to evaluate the socioeconomic status of Asian Americans, asserting a claim of wealth, stability, and influence among all Asian Americans is not only fallacious, but dangerously damaging, suppressing the voices of Southeast Asian Americans advocating for the bettered welfare of their communities and preventing the holistic improvement of Southeast Asian American lives.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Student Life

Social Media Or Soul Media

To the generation that cares way too much about affirmation.

Emma Smith
  • This semester I am taking the ever so famous class, Writing 101. Walking into it, I had heard the horror stories about each major assignment. I have to admit, it’s not a class that I am fond of. But, major assignment #2 got me thinking, we had to create a research question based off of a topic that we are interested in.

Two weeks prior, I watched a very interesting documentary on Netflix. Miss Representation was recommended to me by one of my friends and I have to say the topic is absolutely mind blowing. Social Media and Female Body Image. How Social Media makes girls see this unnatural perfection of ‘beauty’ that really doesn’t exist. But female body image isn’t the only thing affected by social media.

Keep Reading... Show less

Sex And The Church

A letter to fellow believers.

Amanda Hayes
  • I know many of you just read that title and thought it was scandalous to see something so “risque” in the same setting as something holy. Well guess what – sex is part of that. Everyone seems to think they are separate, which makes since because most people treat them as though they are complete polar opposites. Shall we think this through?

Who created the Church body? God. Who created the body? Also God. If we know God to be the creator of all things, we cannot leave sex out of that equation. God created sex, people! Praise Him! Like all great things, the world has twisted and perverted it. The world has stained it so badly that even many church congregations see it only as stained and keep quiet about that part of God’s word. Many people know that God told Adam and Eve to “be fruitful and multiply” (Genesis 1:28), but a lot of people overlook the entirety of Song of Solomon. The entire book is dedicated to telling of the love and sex between man and wife. God blessed us with the gift of intimacy, one to be shared between husband and wife. Church if we teach of sex as the blessing that it is, more people will start treating it as such. If we stop viewing sex as this unspeakable act, the temptation would be lessened. With the fall of man, humans naturally desire things they should not have. So if more people speak of it with gladness and praise, and do not hide it in the darkness as if it were vile, fewer people would be drawn to it for the wrong reasons. More people would appreciate it for what it is: a gift from God.

Keep Reading... Show less

Chick-fil-A, I love you.

Keep Reading... Show less

An open letter to my father

What you did sounds dumb to me

An open letter to my father
The Truth About My Parents' Divorce

Considering im 18 now & you're one of the best men i've ever met since you have a child; me. I want you to know that I love you, more than anyone, I love you. I don't forgive you for the way you hurt my mother. I'm hurt because you broke our family. Thing went down hill the day you found Laquita. You we're distant & shortly after my mother turned into the coldest, saddest women to walk past me. She's my best friend & so are you. Not one day goes by where I don't wonder what she did wrong. How on earth could you trade your family & the women who loved you unconditionally for a home wrecker? Sounds dumb to me.

Keep Reading... Show less

Is God Reckless?

Exploring the controversy behind the popular worship song "Reckless Love"

Is God Reckless?

First things first I do not agree with people getting so caught up in the specific theology of a song that they forget who they are singing the song to. I normally don't pay attention to negative things that people say about worship music, but the things that people were saying caught my attention. For example, that the song was not biblical and should not be sung in churches. Worship was created to glorify God, and not to argue over what kind of theology the artist used to write the song. I was not made aware of the controversy surrounding the popular song "Reckless Love" by Cory Asbury until about a week ago, but now that I am aware this is what I have concluded.The controversy surrounding the song is how the term reckless is used to describe God's love. This is the statement that Cory Asbury released after many people questioned his theology regarding his lyrics. I think that by trying to clarify what the song was saying he added to the confusion behind the controversy.This is what he had to say,
"Many have asked me for clarity on the phrase, "reckless love". Many have wondered why I'd use a "negative" word to describe God. I've taken some time to write out my thoughts here. I hope it brings answers to your questions. But more than that, I hope it brings you into an encounter with the wildness of His love.When I use the phrase, "the reckless love of God", I'm not saying that God Himself is reckless. I am, however, saying that the way He loves, is in many regards, quite so. What I mean is this: He is utterly unconcerned with the consequences of His actions with regards to His own safety, comfort, and well-being. His love isn't crafty or slick. It's not cunning or shrewd. In fact, all things considered, it's quite childlike, and might I even suggest, sometimes downright ridiculous. His love bankrupted heaven for you. His love doesn't consider Himself first. His love isn't selfish or self-serving. He doesn't wonder what He'll gain or lose by putting Himself out there. He simply gives Himself away on the off-chance that one of us might look back at Him and offer ourselves in return.His love leaves the ninety-nine to find the one every time."
Some people are arguing that song is biblical because it makes reference to the scripture from Matthew 28:12-14 and Luke 15. Both of these scriptures talk about the parable of the lost sheep and the shepherd. The shepherd symbolizes God and the lost sheep are people that do not have a relationship with God. On the other hand some people are arguing that using the term reckless, referring to God's character is heretical and not biblical. I found two articles that discuss the controversy about the song.The first article is called, "Reckless Love" By Cory Asbury - "Song Meaning, Review, and Worship Leading Tips." The writer of the article, Jake Gosselin argues that people are "Making a mountain out of a molehill" and that the argument is foolish. The second article, "God's Love is not Reckless, Contrary to What You Might Sing" by author Andrew Gabriel argues that using the term reckless is irresponsible and that you cannot separate Gods character traits from God himself. For example, saying that God's love is reckless could also be argued that God himself is reckless. Reckless is typically not a word that someone would use to describe God and his love for us. The term reckless is defined as (of a person or their actions) without thinking or caring about the consequences of an action. However, Cory Asbury is not talking about a person, he is talking about God's passionate and relentless pursuit of the lost. While I would not have chosen the word reckless, I understand what he was trying to communicate through the song. Down below I have linked two articles that might be helpful if you are interested in reading more about the controversy.

Keep Reading... Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments