Why Citizenship Should Not be Asked on the US 2020 Census

Why Citizenship Should Not be Asked on the US 2020 Census

A perspective on the 2020 Census with the Citizenship question, as well as the consequences of it.


"Emilio, can you please pass the beans?" my mother asked me during breakfast this morning I gave her the bowl of pinto beans while watching the news for that day. As I was watching the news coverage of the local basketball game, the headlines "2020 CENSUS WILL ASK FOR CITIZENSHIP" came over the screen.

Suddenly, the news switched to a full-on debate about the issue, with conservative contributors arguing that other countries such as the UK, Australia, Canada, France, and Germany ask the citizenship question on their censuses (Stempel). The liberal contributors argued back, stating that this was being used as a strategy to skew the numbers of immigrants living in the political districts to their advantage. As I turned to get a tissue, I saw that my mother was watching the screen intensely.

After the news segment ended, my mother turned to me and said: "Unless you already know the person, do not answer the door for anyone, no matter what". I nodded at this but did not understand why she was very serious about this. "It will be highly unlikely for them to visit us," I told myself. As I picked up the plates from the kitchen, I saw a notification on my mother's phone; it read "Residents in your country should expect for people from the Census Bureau to visit their homes this week".

The drapes were closed for that entire week, as my mother was adamant that we could not be interviewed for the Census; on Tuesday night, I asked her why.

"Because then they will found out our status, and we could be deported" she explained. "I worked very hard for us to have a better life here, and that could easily be ruined by someone coming here and asking us questions".

"Yes Mom, but the Census Bureau is not going to share our information with any other departments; they're not legally allowed to do that (Jordan)" I replied. "And because of that, we can tell the truth that we are not citizens in this country, they are not legally able to give out that information".

"I don't believe that not at all. I will never forget how your tio Roberto was caught. He was just sitting in his house when ICE came in; they just took him without an arrest warrant or anything. He's back in Guadalajara now, the same could happen to us if we tell them about us" my Mom said.

"Mom, while that was bad that that happened to tio, that's a different case. The Census literally can't let ICE know, that would be illegal. Also, by avoiding the Census, don't you know that that will affect US Politics for the next ten years?"

"Well, do you see politics in this room right now? Does it help me pay the bills, at work, or with you and school? I can't afford to pay attention to politics right now, I can only focus on you and me, that's it. And what happens… happens. I'm doing the best I can for us to live in this country without being caught by ICE or the INS" my Mom argued.

"Well then what if E-Verify is mandated in our state? Conservative lawmakers know that by adding the Citizenship question on the US Census, illegal immigrants, like us, will not participate in it, skewing the numbers of people in each district. This would allow for easier redistricting, giving conservatives more political leverage to pass laws such as that. Therefore, by illegal immigrants like us that refrain from participating in the Census, we are stripping ourselves of representation in the US population. Mom, I know that you're scared, but please, it's important that you participate in this"

A knock is heard at the door; Emilio and his mother go silent.

"Hello, this is Sam from the Census Bureau, I am here to take your information for the 2020 Census".

He continues to knock.




Silence soon follows after this.

NEWS UPDATE: In a historical record, our county flips Republican for the first time ever. Many believe that this was due to the inclusion of the 2020 Census, which included the controversial Citizenship question. This caused redistricting in our county that many believe led to a Republican congressman being elected.

NEWS UPDATE ( 2 years later): In a close vote, E-Verify in our state has been approved, and will go into effect next month. E-Verify is a system that requires employers to verify that their employees are US Citizens, green card, or work visa holders. It is predicted that this will cause massive layoffs in the state, as many employers do not currently use this system, allowing the opportunity for illegal immigrants to work.


Miriam Jordan "If Census Asks About Citizenship, Some Already Have an Answer: No Comment"

Jonathan Stempel "Trump declares U.S. census 'meaningless' without citizenship question"

For Further Reading:

Gregory Wallace "2 versions of census prepared, with and without citizenship question"

Ariane de Vogue "Supreme Court agrees to take up 2020 census case"

Why the census shouldn't try to count undocumented immigrants

Popular Right Now

What Does Equality Mean To America?

Does America truly have the equality it preaches?

Equality is a right given to all the citizens of the United States of America, and the quote “all men are created equal” was a central idea in the Declaration of Independence, one of the most influential documents in our country’s history. Equality is everyone having the same fundamental rights, no matter the circumstance. Equality is everyone having the same worth. Although equality is a key tenet dating back to the founding of our country, it is not fully honored, even to this day. Many minority groups do not receive complete equality, both economically and socially. Equality is a lofty goal our country still strives toward.

We must keep continue to strive toward equality in this day in age. Already, our nation has progressed. We have given all citizens the right to vote, the rights to many basic freedoms citizens of other countries simply do not possess. We have the right to free speech, more freedom than 40% of the planet. We have the right to bear arms, the right to fair trial, among numerous other freedoms.

Yet, the United States is not perfect. Social equality still has not arrived for many African Americans and Latinos, with arrest and conviction rates much higher than their white counterparts still prevalent. These minorities suffer social injustice and prejudice. Muslim Americans have oft been falsely accused and derided because of their religion. Economic equality has not been realized either, and a wage gap of 20% persists.

But, we can change this. Us as a nation must stand for equality and strive for the ideal world where everyone is equal.

Cover Image Credit: Surge

Related Content

Connect with a generation
of new voices.

We are students, thinkers, influencers, and communities sharing our ideas with the world. Join our platform to create and discover content that actually matters to you.

Learn more Start Creating

Dear Marvel, You Really Need TO Do Better With Representation

This is simply a poor attempt at more diversity.


SPOILER WARNING: This article contains spoilers for the Marvel Cinematic Universe

Avengers "Endgame" hit theaters and shattered records across the world with making an amazing $350 million in North America and an even more stunning $1.2 billion worldwide. In fact, 'Endgame' has already destroyed records set back "Star Wars: The Force Awakens," "Avatar," and even the first part of the movie, 'Infinity War.' Fans went in expecting a mix of emotions and for the most part, the movie definitely delivered. However, there is one thing that some fans are severely disappointed in.

Directors like the Russo Brothers hyped up an "exclusive gay character" and "Marvel's first openly gay character" in the 22 movie franchise. But fans weren't happy with what they received after all of this hype beforehand. While representation is representation sometimes it's simply not good enough. In this movie, Steve Rogers (Captain America) goes to a counseling group with others to deal with such a huge loss in their world and lives. This is where we meet the "exclusive" gay character, who barely even has a name. He's an unnoticeable character if you're not paying attention, has no relevance to the plot, and doesn't make any kind of difference in the movie at all. He talks about how he finally went out on a date, with a guy, and how eventually they both cry while reflecting on their lives after the snap. While they call this "exclusive," we call this pretty close to queerbaiting.

Making a big deal over a background character and parading him around for his sexuality isn't what we would call representation. While it's always cool to see an LGBTQ character on the screen in such a huge series, this character is still just a minor character and has no relevance and is literally never seen again. He is on screen for less than five minutes before we never see this character again. This is what you call representation? A minor background character with no importance whatsoever? No thanks!

What we are looking for is at least someone that has something to do with the plot, not just there to say they've done it and market to the LGBTQ community. Marvel needs to do better when it comes to this. Their big deal over a minor character lost our respect more than it gained because this excitement was only a money grab more than an actual attempt at diversity. When we have characters like Valkyrie, who is Bisexual in the comics, we want to see more major characters gain this diversity. Even Captain Marvel actress Brie Larson agrees, "we gotta move faster" as no person should be excluded from being a superhero for any reason, even sexual orientation.

So Marvel, while you're here breaking box office records, don't forget to do better at giving the LGBTQ community the representation they deserve, and the representation we all want! And until you do, we'll just be here looking over Brie Larson's and Bev Johnson's support of Captain Marvel and Valkyrie!

Related Content

Facebook Comments