1. When he wore leather.

2. When he was on the island and looked like this.

3. When he fixed his tie and worried about his suit because, c'mon–who can pull off a suit like Caffrey can?

3. When he pretended to be a real FBI agent.

4. When he smiled.

5. When he flipped his hat so effortlessly.

6. When he looked better in glasses than we ever thought anyone could.

7. When he faked a smile to make Peter happy.

8. When he shows his love for Peter.

9. When he was with Kate (even though we were super jealous of her).

10. When he pretended he didn't do anything wrong.

11. When he answered the door.

12. When he was utterly hysterical.

13. When he cried.

14. When he was honest.

15. This time.

16. When he and Mozzie were together.

17. When he would examine art.

18. When he wore turtlenecks.

19. When he was a great distraction for any FBI plan.

20. When he was optimistic and believed that there is always another way.