Is J.K. Rowling A TERF?
Start writing a post

J.K. Rowling Displays Deliberate Ignorance On Trans Issues And Tries To Normalize TERF Ideology

In a new essay, J.K. Rowling exposed her blatant ignorance on transgender issues.

J.K. Rowling Displays Deliberate Ignorance On Trans Issues And Tries To Normalize TERF Ideology

J.K. Rowling has been in the news lately because of her views on transgender people. It began several months ago when Rowling tweeted her support of Maya Forstater. Forstater's contract work was not renewed after she tweeted, "People who I admire . . . are tying themselves in knots to avoid saying the truth that men cannot change into women (because that might hurt mens feelings)."

Rowling was back in the news this month when she tweeted more ignorant thoughts about the trans community. She claimed that it was perceived as "hateful" to state that biological sex is real. I am not able to speak for the trans community, nor am I trying to. However, I have a feeling most trans people would agree that biological sex is real. There is a difference between biological sex and gender identity. This is crucial to understanding what it means to be transgender.

After receiving quite a bit of backlash, Rowling published a lengthy manifesto on her website. The article didn't help the public to understand Rowling's point of view. If anything, she just dug her grave even deeper.

Rowling has been accused of being a TERF. For those that aren't familiar, TERF stands for "trans-exclusionary radical feminist." It's a branch of feminism that believes trans women are just men trying to invade female spaces. They also believe trans men are traitors to the female gender. The TERF mentality reaches a disturbingly high level in Rowling's article.

What makes it so disturbing is how she seems to try to underplay this sort of extremism. "Examples of so-called TERFs range from the mother of a gay child who was afraid their child wanted to transition to escape homophobic bullying, to a hitherto totally unfeminist older lady who's vowed never to visit Marks & Spencer again because they're allowing any man who says they identify as a woman into the women's changing rooms," Rowling writes.

She doesn't just gaslight her audience with fictional examples, which, granted, Rowling is quite experienced at coming up with. She also attempts to normalize the TERF way of thinking. In the very next sentence, Rowling writes, "Ironically, radical feminists aren't even trans-exclusionary – they include trans men in their feminism, because they were born women."

The above statement is a perfect example of someone getting caught in a lie and unintentionally exposing the truth. Rowling is trying to act like the TERF mentality isn't real, yet her reasoning is at the very basis of such thinking. She is valuing of a group of trans people, not because of their gender, but the biological sex they were assigned at birth.

Rowling also displays a complete lack of understanding when it comes to gender dysphoria. "But, as many women have said before me, 'woman' is not a costume," she writes. "'Woman' is not an idea in a man's head. 'Woman' is not a pink brain, a liking for Jimmy Choos or any of the other sexist ideas now somehow touted as progressive."

Trans women who experience gender dysphoria aren't wearing women's clothes for fun. They're wearing them because they need to. It's a matter of survival. It's who they are. It's not someone they're pretending to be. Rowling further exposes her TERF mentality when she says things like this.

Rowling claims to have done extensive research on trans issues. Bearing this fact in mind, it's hard for me to believe she isn't coming from a hateful place. In a previous article, I said Rowling was just ignorant and needed to be educated. It's become clear to me that she hears what she wants to hear. She already has her mind made up. She's not interested in learning anything. She just wants to take information and twist it to fit her narrative.

Rowling's main issue is the fact that she sees validating trans women as invalidating cis women. It comes across as, "My struggle is more important than your struggle." I believe this is the reason Rowling is deliberately ignorant on several trans issues. If she were honest about these issues, it would force her to see that sexism and transphobia aren't in competition with one another.

Two things that Rowling seems to weaponize against the transgender community are de-transitioning and teenagers transitioning. For one thing, someone who de-transitions shouldn't invalidate the countless other trans people whose transitions are vital to their very existence. One has nothing to do with the other.

In her article, Rowling seems to make light of teenagers' experiences with gender dysphoria. She writes, "The argument of many current trans activists is that if you don't let a gender dysphoric teenager transition, they will kill themselves."

Yes, people do say that because it is a very real possibility. It has happened many times before. Gender dysphoria makes you feel like you're in the wrong body. If your body starts going through puberty, that feeling of discontent will only grow. This is why it's important to give teens options for starting the transition process.

When it comes to young teens starting their transition, there are steps put in place to help prevent needing to de-transition later on. This is where puberty blockers come in. Despite what some have said, puberty blockers don't cause any permanent changes to the body. It does exactly what it says, it stops the process of puberty.

This is especially useful for trans females, whose voices don't change with estrogen. If the teenager realizes they're not trans, they can stop taking the blockers. Their body will continue with puberty as usual. It will pick up where it left off.

Rowling doesn't seem to understand that in order for a teenager to transition in the first place, they need to have a diagnosis. Therapy and doctor's appointments are a vital part of starting that process. No doctor in their right mind would allow a young person to transition without being absolutely certain.

"The allure of escaping womanhood would have been huge," Rowling writes. "I struggled with severe OCD as a teenager. If I'd found community and sympathy online that I couldn't find in my immediate environment, I believe I could have been persuaded to turn myself into the son my father had openly said he'd have preferred."

If Rowling told a therapist she wanted to escape womanhood as a teenager because of sexism and OCD, she wouldn't be diagnosed with gender dysphoria. She wouldn't be put on puberty blockers and no doctor would prescribe testosterone. The most she would've received were more therapy sessions and a prescription of anti-anxiety medication.

Perhaps the most discussed portion of the article came when Rowling talked about the abuse and sexual assault she experienced. She used these horrible experiences to justify her view that trans people shouldn't use the bathroom of the gender they identify with. It's absolutely horrible that Rowling experienced these things. No person should ever be subjected to such treatment. However, this isn't a reason to deny trans people a basic human right.

When it comes to abuse, there are plenty of cisgender men who molest little boys. There are also plenty of cisgender women who molest little girls. These grown men and women share public restrooms with these children. So why does this issue of public restrooms only come up when dealing with trans people?

This sort of transphobia needs to be reduced. In order for that reduction to happen, there needs to be more education. However, J.K. Rowling has shown us that education alone won't work. People need to be willing to listen and learn. Here's hoping those people outnumber people like Rowling and Maya Forstater.

Report this Content

Biden's Inauguration Signals A Time Of Healing After A Dark And Painful Period

Joe Biden's inauguration marks the beginning of a time of healing for America.


The day finally arrived. Joe Biden has been inaugurated and is now the 46th president of the United States of America. Kamala Harris has been sworn in as our country's new vice president. She is the first woman and the first person of color to fill the role. After years of fighting, frustration, and fear, this is a day of celebration. It's a day of hope as we look to the future. It's also a day of healing, as our collective wounds are still very fresh.

Keep Reading... Show less

Victory For LGBTQ Americans As The US Gains 6 New LGBTQ Government Representatives

Regardless of who is president, let's celebrate these huge victories for LGBTQ representation in various states' governments.


The presidential election was extremely stressful for us all, causing us to worry about who will win and what it means for the future. For many of us, this can mean the difference between life and death, especially for BIPOC and members of the LGBTQ communities who are at the mercy of homophobes and racists — many of whom are proud supporters of the color orange.

Instead of worrying whether I'll be sent to a conversion camp next year or not, I'd rather celebrate the much bigger and more important wins. There have been six representatives added to state governments this past election who are all a part of the LGBTQ community.

Keep Reading... Show less

Who Said It — Donald Trump Or A Villain From The Avatar Universe?

A hilarious and frightening game of who said it: Donald J. Trump or a villain from "Avatar: The Last Airbender" or "The Legend of Korra."

Gage Skidmore / Flickr Creative Commons; Nickelodeon

Have fun guessing whether outgoing President of the United States Donald J. Trump or a literal anime villain said each of these 26 quotes. To keep the answers a surprise (not being able to see the answer right below the quote), I will have all of the answers at the bottom of the page.

Keep Reading... Show less

Scotland Is The First Country To Make Menstrual Products Free, And The Rest Of The World Should Follow

The idea that they are a "luxury" that should be paid for (and taxed) is absurd because nobody chooses to have a period.


Scotland recently became the first country in the world to make menstrual products free to anyone that needs them, and the rest of the world needs to follow their lead. It is honestly sad that in the year 2020, there is only one nation that has passed a law to make period products free. The idea that they are a "luxury" that should be paid for (and taxed) is absurd because nobody chooses to have a period. It should not be seen as a luxury to have access to products that are a basic necessity.

Keep Reading... Show less

Candace Owens' Backwards Ideas Are Causing Damage, Not Harry Styles Wearing A Dress

Candace Owens thinks men wearing dresses are damaging to civilization, but it's her ideas that are the problem.


Androgyny is something that has always been part of culture. Since the beginning of time, gender expression has always been varied and expansive. However, as time went on, society forced particular roles onto certain genders. These sorts of gender roles have caused many to rebel against them, including artists and rock stars. Harry Styles seems to be the next one in line to rebel in this way.

Keep Reading... Show less

​If You Have An Issue With Harry Styles Wearing A Dress, This Is For You

Harry Styles, the first male to appear solo on the cover of Vogue in American history should be something celebrated, not denounced.


Harry Styles has consistently been catapulted into stardom for countless reasons such as, but not limited to: being an amazing artist and an all-around phenomenal human to admire. Renowned for leading his platform through kindness, acceptance, love, and self-expression. It is not a secret to anyone that follows Harry Styles that he upholds an eccentric sense of fashion. Harry Styles is a mogul for shifting the traditional gender fashion roles towards a more gender-neutral normative fashion. He leads this by rocking whatever fashion he wishes to express himself in and extending the same acceptance and kindness to others.

Keep Reading... Show less

Native Americans Might Have Been The Key To Turning Arizona Blue

Voter turnout hit records in this year's election, and it may have been the secret weapon for the Democrats.


The 2020 general election brought in more participants and voters than ever before, and in Arizona, an important chunk of the registered voter turnout was the Native community.

Keep Reading... Show less
Facebook Comments