J.K. Rowling And Kaitlin Bennett Need To Understand Trans People Better
Start writing a post

J.K. Rowling And Kaitlin Bennett Have ONE Thing In Common, Neither Understand Trans Rights

Recent events involving J.K. Rowling and Kaitlin Bennett prove that education is the key to progress on trans issues.

J.K. Rowling And Kaitlin Bennett Have ONE Thing In Common, Neither Understand Trans Rights

When it comes to bigotry, ignorance is usually the main cause. Not everyone is fortunate to live in a big city will a diverse population. Some people are raised in small towns with extremely narrow-minded surroundings. People always have the capacity to grow, however. Education is key to this growth.

The transgender community has been gaining a lot of visibility in recent years. Trans rights are still a new topic of discussion for some, whether dealing with public bathrooms or the military. Hate crimes are alarmingly high for trans people, especially trans women of color.

There is absolutely no excuse for such behavior. It really seems to come from fear of the unknown. In order for things to improve, these fears must be faced. People need to be educated.

While I don't consider myself to be an expert on all trans issues, some recent events got me thinking. It seemed like a perfect opportunity to educate some who really need it.

That is, if they're willing to listen.

J.K. Rowling has been in the headlines lately for something she tweeted.

Surprisingly, it wasn't something she tweeted against, but rather in support of. She tweeted in support of Maya Forstater, a British woman whose job contract expired and was not renewed. The story many are trying to spin is that Forstater was unfairly branded transphobic for pointing out so-called biological truths. This is the story Rowling seems to believe, as evident by her tweet.

I don't think Rowling herself is transphobic, but she does appear to be misguided. I don't think she knows the whole story.

What people don't seem to understand is that Maya Forstater isn't merely pointing out biological facts. She has tweeted beliefs that many would categorize under the TERF label. TERF stands for "trans-exclusionary radical feminist." They believe that trans women are just men trying to invade women's spaces. They also believe that trans men are traitors to the female gender.

Forstater tweeted a thread which included referring to trans women as "men." She also claimed that these trans women would be exposing themselves to vulnerable cis women and girls. This was her argument for why trans women shouldn't be allowed in women's restrooms or locker rooms.

I have a hard time understanding why so many pull out the "predator" argument when discussing this issue. It's as if there are no grown cis men who prey on little boys. It's as if there are no grown cis women who prey on little girls. We all know that isn't the case. We all know these people routinely use the same public restrooms too. So why is the issue of bathroom predators only a problem when discussing trans people?

My main issue with Forstater is that she blatantly refers to trans women as "men." It comes across as if she's invalidating their entire identity. This bothers me, because it can trigger dysphoria is trans people. Dysphoric feelings can lead to suicide. Suicide among trans people is a serious issue.

This is why Rowling shouldn't be supporting a person like Maya Forstater. I don't support cancel culture. At the end of the day, I don't think that helps anyone. What I do think needs to happen, is more education. Not just for Rowling, but for Forstater herself.

Obviously, Forstater's employer has every right to fire her if they choose. I'm not trying to deny them that right. However, it shouldn't stop there. Educating people on how and why they got something wrong is an important next step.

Education is something a young woman named Kaitlin Bennett could use too.

A self-described gun rights activist, Bennett is an outspoken conservative voice online. She has become known as "gun girl" because she brought a gun to her college graduation.

Bennett is featured in a video on YouTube called, "College Students Have No Morals." It featured Bennett walking around the University of Kentucky campus and asking students about trans bathroom issues. Clips from the video have gone viral on Twitter.

Bennett is seen asking students what they think of offering tampons in men's restrooms for trans men and urinals in women's restrooms for trans women. She doesn't often use this wording, however. In fact, Bennett routinely expresses a blatantly deceptive obliviousness to transgender people altogether.

There is an aspect of the video that seems unintentionally clueless. I highly doubt trans women would actually want to use a urinal if given the option. I don't and can't speak for them, but I imagine they would want to blend in with the other women in the restroom. I also think a urinal might trigger some dysphoria (although that is different for everyone).

Obviously, Bennett has the predictable disapproving stance on trans people using the bathroom they choose. But she took it another step further when she questioned how to identify those with a more ambiguous look. She wondered how to know whether to use "sir" or "ma'am."

It's not required to use "sir" or "ma'am" to exchange pleasantries. Such wording is usually reserved for more formal environments and even then, there are other options. But that's beside the point. The way Bennett questioned this issue made it sound like she was trying to come up with reasons to say being trans is wrong.

From my own experience, trans people typically present themselves as the gender they identify as. If a trans person is at the beginning stage of their transition, it might be more difficult to tell.

However, if you do get it wrong, the sky won't open up and people won't start keeling over.

Nine times out of 10, trans people are pretty cool and understanding when it happens.

It becomes a problem when the misgendering person makes no effort to correct themselves.

It becomes an issue when the person continues to misgender them deliberately.

It's not difficult to spot the difference between those people and individuals who are genuinely making an effort.

This sort of education is something Bennett can certainly use more of. When you first hear Bennett's views, you might think all she needs is to be exposed to more trans people. Maybe she's just ignorant. However, it becomes harder to be compassionate when you see her reaction to students who try to educate her. Bennett will listen to what they have to say, but walk away with a snide comment or making a face at the camera.

This is childish behavior and it doesn't seem like this is someone who wants to learn. It comes across as someone who wants to remain in an echo chamber.

In order for education to have a positive effect, one must be open to it. Maybe Kaitlin Bennett will grow, maybe not. Whatever the outcome, I remain hopeful that the transgender community will make progress. There will always be people who aren't just ignorant, but thrilled to wallow in their ignorance.

But that won't stop the overall climate from improving. Every civil rights movement has endured this kind of pushback. Yet, things have always gotten better. Look at how America has improved on issues like segregation, women's right to vote, and marriage equality.

Trans rights have a long way to go and I have no doubt there is a light at the end of the tunnel.

Report this Content

Biden's Inauguration Signals A Time Of Healing After A Dark And Painful Period

Joe Biden's inauguration marks the beginning of a time of healing for America.


The day finally arrived. Joe Biden has been inaugurated and is now the 46th president of the United States of America. Kamala Harris has been sworn in as our country's new vice president. She is the first woman and the first person of color to fill the role. After years of fighting, frustration, and fear, this is a day of celebration. It's a day of hope as we look to the future. It's also a day of healing, as our collective wounds are still very fresh.

Keep Reading... Show less

Victory For LGBTQ Americans As The US Gains 6 New LGBTQ Government Representatives

Regardless of who is president, let's celebrate these huge victories for LGBTQ representation in various states' governments.


The presidential election was extremely stressful for us all, causing us to worry about who will win and what it means for the future. For many of us, this can mean the difference between life and death, especially for BIPOC and members of the LGBTQ communities who are at the mercy of homophobes and racists — many of whom are proud supporters of the color orange.

Instead of worrying whether I'll be sent to a conversion camp next year or not, I'd rather celebrate the much bigger and more important wins. There have been six representatives added to state governments this past election who are all a part of the LGBTQ community.

Keep Reading... Show less

Who Said It — Donald Trump Or A Villain From The Avatar Universe?

A hilarious and frightening game of who said it: Donald J. Trump or a villain from "Avatar: The Last Airbender" or "The Legend of Korra."

Gage Skidmore / Flickr Creative Commons; Nickelodeon

Have fun guessing whether outgoing President of the United States Donald J. Trump or a literal anime villain said each of these 26 quotes. To keep the answers a surprise (not being able to see the answer right below the quote), I will have all of the answers at the bottom of the page.

Keep Reading... Show less

Scotland Is The First Country To Make Menstrual Products Free, And The Rest Of The World Should Follow

The idea that they are a "luxury" that should be paid for (and taxed) is absurd because nobody chooses to have a period.


Scotland recently became the first country in the world to make menstrual products free to anyone that needs them, and the rest of the world needs to follow their lead. It is honestly sad that in the year 2020, there is only one nation that has passed a law to make period products free. The idea that they are a "luxury" that should be paid for (and taxed) is absurd because nobody chooses to have a period. It should not be seen as a luxury to have access to products that are a basic necessity.

Keep Reading... Show less

Candace Owens' Backwards Ideas Are Causing Damage, Not Harry Styles Wearing A Dress

Candace Owens thinks men wearing dresses are damaging to civilization, but it's her ideas that are the problem.


Androgyny is something that has always been part of culture. Since the beginning of time, gender expression has always been varied and expansive. However, as time went on, society forced particular roles onto certain genders. These sorts of gender roles have caused many to rebel against them, including artists and rock stars. Harry Styles seems to be the next one in line to rebel in this way.

Keep Reading... Show less

​If You Have An Issue With Harry Styles Wearing A Dress, This Is For You

Harry Styles, the first male to appear solo on the cover of Vogue in American history should be something celebrated, not denounced.


Harry Styles has consistently been catapulted into stardom for countless reasons such as, but not limited to: being an amazing artist and an all-around phenomenal human to admire. Renowned for leading his platform through kindness, acceptance, love, and self-expression. It is not a secret to anyone that follows Harry Styles that he upholds an eccentric sense of fashion. Harry Styles is a mogul for shifting the traditional gender fashion roles towards a more gender-neutral normative fashion. He leads this by rocking whatever fashion he wishes to express himself in and extending the same acceptance and kindness to others.

Keep Reading... Show less

Native Americans Might Have Been The Key To Turning Arizona Blue

Voter turnout hit records in this year's election, and it may have been the secret weapon for the Democrats.


The 2020 general election brought in more participants and voters than ever before, and in Arizona, an important chunk of the registered voter turnout was the Native community.

Keep Reading... Show less
Facebook Comments