I've been going to off-broadway musicals with my parents for as long as I can remember, and as I see new shows, my parents always want to know how they compare to all the rest. Usually I give a vague "it was good but not one of my favorites", but I've never really stopped to figure out exactly which shows are my favorites.
So, Mom and Dad, here is the answer to your question of what my favorite Broadway shows are.
5. Hamilton
I didn't think Hamilton was going to live up to the hype surrounding it, but it definitely did. It was somehow even better than I was expecting, and as an absolute history nerd, it was right up my alley.
Favorite Song: Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story
4. Chicago
I watched the movie version who knows how many times before finally seeing it live, and it was a million times better live. Every song is incredible, and the murderous drama is to die for (pun intended).
Favorite Song: Cell Block Tango
3. Something Rotten
I had never heard of Something Rotten when I went to see it, but it was immediately one of my favorites. A musical about creating the first musical through a series of hilarious misunderstandings? Yes please!
Favorite Song: God, I Hate Shakespeare
2. Wicked
Have I seen Wicked four times? Yes. Has it managed to get even better each time? Absolutely.
Favorite Song: Defying Gravity
1. Waitress
I was absolutely shocked by how much I loved Waitress. It made me laugh and cry and angry and hopeful all at the same time. Truly an emotional roller coaster.
Favorite Song: She Used to be Mine
Honorable mentions that were painful to not include: Kinky Boots and The Sound of Music