Calling BULL on "Calling Bull on Service Trips"
Start writing a post
Politics and Activism

Calling BULL on "Calling Bull on Service Trips"

Here's a million reasons why your 7 reasons are wrong

Calling BULL on "Calling Bull on Service Trips"

I usually am not one to call people out for their own opinions, despite how much I might disagree with them, because generally everyone probably has a good reason, with experiences and circumstances that give reason to whatever it is they believe in. But this past week I read an article that had be actually so angry that I had to stop reading it and put my phone away. And honestly, I have never read something so wrong and so ignorant in my life.

Two weeks ago, I got back from a trip with a wonderful organization that I learned about through Marquette. It is called Global Brigades, and it was actually originated here at Marquette 14 years ago. I got the opportunity to travel to Nicaragua with this amazing organization, and with an even more amazing group of people on a week long Public Health brigade. I have been at a loss of words when trying to put into thoughts and memories and favorite moments when retelling this trip to all of my family and friends. Between the people there with hearts bigger than anyone could ever imagine, the friends I got closer within a week than some people I have known for years, the relationships I made and treasure with the staff, the people of Nicaragua, the students who went with me, and the steps out of my comfort zone that gave me a chance to see things from whole new, connected, solidified experience—I mean it when I tell you this was the best experience of my life, and anyone who has the chance to do a trip to work WITH and not FOR a group of people who can show them new spots of their heart, and new talents and hard working capacities they hold, and new ways to laugh and appreciate life, and new ways to grow—you should freaking go.

The day I landed back in Milwaukee, I read an article. An article titled, “7 Reasons Why Your Two Week Trip to Haiti Doesn’t Matter: Calling Bull on “Service Trips.” Well first off, what the heck, there is so much ignorance in just the title I should have just stopped there. As I continued reading, though, I could actually feel my face get red. Between rude assumptions and stereotypes, the article went on to say that service trips don’t matter and why should we even bother going on them, right?

"Service trips do more harm than good.” More harm than good to who? The people who get to be reminded every week, by every new group of volunteers that America and everywhere else that sends people to help them grow, is actually not an ignorant and selfish country solely concerned about themselves and not willing to remind those struggling that whether the help we offer is a smile, a hand, or a day of shoveling, that we are in this together? That there are people who care about them? That whether we build six sanitation stations or two, people are fighting WITH them and want them to have access to a healthy life and want them to feel loved? Or does it do more harm to the volunteers? The ones who get to be reminded of how selfless and loving people can be by seeing the welcoming and undefinable amazing people around the world? How maybe being an exclusive and unwelcoming country isn’t something to be all that proud of after all, and how simplistic joy can be. Seriously those trips man, they are just such a harmful experience—hard to believe I made it through okay, wow.

These service trips are “entirely focused on the volunteers.” Now, this just freaking frustrating because the entire trip, every morning, every night at reflections, we were constantly pouring our hearts out and reflecting on how special of an experience it was to get to work in solidarity, hand in hand, learning with the families we met each day. Not for them, not for us, but together. I learned a whole new definition of hard work, I dug, and built, and saw more concrete in those six days than I have in my whole life. I saw more smiles and heard more courageous and genuine laughter than I hear in a week sometimes back home. I saw more dedication and passion for a country than I knew even existed. I learned and grew so much from the life and hearts and welcoming arms of these people—and does that mean the trip is focused on me? The fact that these people taught me and helped me see a new light makes the trip self-focused? Huh, who would’ve thought maybe it was a special experience that has reciprocated reminders of life joy and love. I forgot I was just hoping to come back happy and fulfilled from quick little emotion-free weekend. No one was sad to leave, no one felt for the people just focused on a quick little vacay, duh.

It said the lasting impact of short-term voluntarism trips is “negligible.” In six days, we built four sanitation stations (a clothing wash, a toilet, and a shower) for four different families, we built four septic tanks for the waste to dispose to, and put in three concrete floors. We learned how to truly work freaking hard. We learned how to work hard and not complain about it because they didn’t once. We left families with resources to SHOWER and be clean and walk in their house without worrying of fungal diseases or bacteria or infections—by shoot I forgot concrete floors melt two days after they’re built and septic tanks fall down in two hours, shoot, how negligible. We also dug the final step of a water system that delivers fresh water from a mountain to FIVE DIFFERENT COMMUNITIES, five. But shoot, that isn’t going to affect anyone’s life long term or anything, how negligible. And it's not like we talked with the families, or the masons, or the people we met to remind them of our love for them, or to remind them our admiration for their hard work, or to remind them we would be back. The goal was to go and neglect, not to come back and spread the experience and keep the tradition of these trips that allows all of these things to be accomplished going or anything.

“They promote a cycle of dependence.” And is this them talking? Did they tell you that that would rather continue thinking we don’t care and never see helping hands and continue to be left with no resources or helping minds and hands and hearts that give them access to a path up? A path up from a stuck place where they feel alone, or like there is no means to be healthy. Obviously, we should just not go. OBVIOUSLY, we just shouldn’t help them, because we wouldn’t want them to get help or feel cared for or loved or equal to us right? We might as well blow it off and let them handle it, wouldn’t want them feeling too dependent or anything. No no, I shouldn’t go.

And honestly, these are just a few points of the millions of hurtful and IGNORANT words and opinions that filled this article. In what good world would this be a better alternative? It is these trips across the world, they continuously go in cycles that allow growth and allow people to feel love and give love back. It is such a powerful and important thing to work in solidarity with people and to see the power their insights and perspectives can have on you, and it's so important for them to feel like a person and see you caring too. I really hope these feelings aren’t convincing, I really hope this isn’t a majority, because I promise you, you are missing out on a life-changing, a mutually life-changing, experience that advocates for SO much more than service—it advocates for love, for unity, for growth, for care, for there being more to this world than a self-centered perspective.

Don’t be ignorant and don’t let articles like that load of bogus fool you and block your heart from opening up to the world. Global brigades in itself is an organization offering trips for all areas of the community to grow—between the medical brigades that help to treat ad give assessments and care to those who have been searching for where to go and what to do for so long, and public health brigades that offer preventive care and showers and concrete floors and new utilities for so many families, and the water brigades that work over and over again to deliver communities fresh water, and the business brigades that work to build things back up—it’s the cycle of going, and growing, and inspiring others to go and grow too that keeps this cycle moving upwards, not back downwards. I can only imagine all of the other amazing and powerful organizations that exist out there too. Keep going, keep spreading your heart, and keep letting the world fill yours back up too. So this is me CALLING BULL on the girl who thinks calling bull on service trips is anything close to accurate. Whether you lend your heart from a million miles away, or you go to the countries and help hands on, it’s all important and it all makes an impact. Don’t be ignorant, don’t be selfish, spread your freaking heart.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
Student Life

150 Words For Anyone Who Loves Football Games

Why I love high school football games, even though I don't like football.

Dallas News

When most think of high school they think of friend drama, parties, getting your drivers license, and best of all foot ball games.

Keep Reading... Show less

10 Greatest Speeches In Modern American History

The United States is a relatively infantile nation, but its legacy of spoken rhetoric is one of the richest in the world.


Rhetoric, in all its forms, arrives under the scrutiny of historians both for its historical impact and literary value. Dozens of speeches have either rallied the nation together or driven it drastically apart –– the impact of speeches in politics, social movements, and wars is undeniable.

Keep Reading... Show less

What If The U.N. Actually United The Nations?

This is me taking a break from being cynical and imagining how the world could be one day.


By now, people are probably sick of hearing me talk about myself, so I’m changing it up this week. In keeping with the subject of my J-Term class, I’m asking myself a political what-if question. What if we could create a sovereign global government firmly grounded in justice that could actually adjudicate Earth’s many disparate nation-states into one unified world government?

Keep Reading... Show less

100 Things I'd Rather Do Than Study

Procrastination Nation, unite.

Panda Whale
Here are 100 things I'd rather to than study. I know the semester just started, but

    1. Watch a movie
    2. Take a nap
    3. Have a dance party
    4. Eat ice cream
    5. Bake a cake
    6. Cry just a little bit
    7. Knit a blanket
    8. Learn to ride a bike
    9. Build a crib
    10. Watch a hockey game
    11. Watch any game
    12. Play with my hair
    13. Dye my hair
    14. Go grocery shopping
    15. Learn to crochet
    16. Do 50 jumping jacks
    17. Drive cross country
    18. Take a bubble bath
    19. Squeeze lemons for lemonade
    20. Sell the lemonade
    21. Make heart-shaped ice cubes
    22. Moisturize my knees
    23. Paint my nails
    24. Find the cure for cancer
    25. Run a marathon
    26. Just kidding, run down the hall
    27. Squat my bodyweight
    28. Eat my bodyweight in French fries
    29. Hibernate until Christmas
    30. Cuddle my body pillow (unless you have a boo)
    31. Think about all the work I’m not doing
    32. Wash my bed sheets
    33. Vacuum my apartment
    34. Play mini golf
    35. Go swimming
    36. Tan in this Texas heat
    37. Sing like I’m about to win American Idol
    38. Blow up balloons
    39. Pop the balloons
    40. Make lists
    41. Write an Odyssey article
    42. Pet a puppy
    43. Adopt a puppy
    44. Pay my rent
    45. Order a pizza
    46. Start a garden
    47. Cook a turkey
    48. Find new music
    49. Clean my waffle iron
    50. Learn to make jam
    51. Jam to music
    52. Play scrabble
    53. Volunteer anywhere
    54. Celebrate a birthday
    55. Watch a makeup tutorial I’ll never use
    56. Go through old pictures on my phone
    57. Make a playlist
    58. Take a shower
    59. Clean my room
    60. Curl my hair
    61. Climb a rock wall
    62. Get a massage
    63. Play with Snapchat filters
    64. Roast a chicken
    65. Go fishing
    66. Chug some Snapple
    67. Ride in a cart around Walmart
    68. Count the days until the semester is over
    69. Overthink about my future
    70. Think of my future baby’s names
    71. Pin everything on Pinterest
    72. Text anybody
    73. Pray about life
    74. Watch a sunset
    75. Watch a sunrise
    76. Have a picnic
    77. Read a book (that’s not for school)
    78. Go to a bakery
    79. Snuggle a bunny
    80. Clean my apartment
    81. Wash my dishes
    82. Rearrange my furniture
    83. Physically run away from my problems
    84. Make some meatballs
    85. Learn to make bread
    86. Google myself
    87. Ride a Ferris wheel
    88. Get stuck on a Ferris wheel (that way, it’s not my fault I’m not studying)
    89. Wash my car
    90. Get on a plane to Neverland
    91. Find Narnia in my closet
    92. Jump on a trampoline
    93. Learn to ice skate
    94. Go rollerblading
    95. Ride a rollercoaster
    96. Carve a pumpkin
    97. Restore water in a third world country
    98. FaceTime my family
    99. Hug my mom
    100. Tell my friends I love them

    The Basics Of The United Nations

    As the General Assembly convenes, here is the United Nations 101


    For an organization that literally unites the nations, it amazes me how little is taught about the United Nations in schools, or at least where I went to school. It wasn't until I went to college and got a higher education that I learned the basics of the United Nations. I believe that every American should know at least the basics of what the United Nations does, especially since our country is one of the 5 permanent members. So here are the main "organs" of the United Nations.

    Keep Reading... Show less

    Subscribe to Our Newsletter

    Facebook Comments