American Horror Story Seasons Ranked

The First 4 Seasons Of 'American Horror Story' From Least To Most Horrifying, Ranked By A Fellow Scaredy Cat

Even though it was supposed to be scary, I found myself diving within the storyline rather than fearing it.


"American Horror Story" is groundbreaking for a multitude of reasons: never before has there been a television series that takes multiple storylines to appeal to the viewers. Drifting away from the classic "one long plot" television shows follow, each season begins and ends an entire set of surprises, leaving viewers on end and unable to predict the next plot twist. A classic device in horror-themed works, having that element of surprise drives in the fear factor.

Slowly throughout the different seasons and storylines, viewers are able to grow attached to characters before they are set into a whirlwind of nightmares, ranging anything from escaping a serial killer, escaping an asylum or surviving within a haunted house.

But I do caution, watching it is no walk in the park.

To help anyone else who may feel uneasy about starting to venture into the world of horror works as I once was, below is my own personal opinion about how well structured and scary each of the first four seasons were, rated from least to most scary!

1. Coven — Season 3

AHS: Coven

This season was one of the more easier and entertaining seasons! Putting the audience inside the house of an academy for witches, we followed a small group of young girls who are beginning to learn how to use their powers in hope to find the next "Supreme," or the best within the house, as determined by a deadly test about mastering all seven skills.

Touching on topics varying from the mistreatment of minorities, female power and racism, this season serves as a powerful reminder the individual power we all hold as humans, as well as a great scare. Unlike other seasons, this season lacks jump scares. Its fear factor thrives from rooting for your favorite character to survive the trials to become Supreme and survive outside forces. As it is not necessary to watch the seasons in order, this season is a great first start for easing into more scary works.

2. Murder House — Season 1

Only slightly more scary than "Coven," "Murder House" follows the classic theme of a family moving into a haunted house unknowingly, and suffering the consequences that ensue, such as the haunting of past owners ranging from a corrupt surgeon to a serial killer. With only a few notable jump scares and major plot twists, this season finds its scare factor in the vivid descriptions, harsh, unsettling topics and pictured gore.

I caution anyone who may be easily triggered, as this season touches on substance abuse, rape, divorce and suicide.

However, beyond the uneasy topics, this season does highlight and feature many important classic aspects of horror, including the veiled antagonist, use of music and use of light/dark imagery to foreshadow. It is in this season where the major characters that follow into succeeding seasons first appear, thus attachments to these characters are grown early and further emphasize the terror in not only what is happening plot-wise, but happening mentally and physically to these characters.

I do not recommend this season to be watched first however, as the topics are heavy, and the plot twists are arguably the most unsettling out of all four seasons.

3. Asylum — Season 2

When people first think of asylums, images of torture chambers, a jail-like regime and a strict, corrupt leadership emerge along with pictures of lunatics and the most mentally insane. Taking this stereotype, this season plays on this classic image, however, makes it its own through slight adjustments to a seemingly obvious plot line to create a whirlwind of a story.

An adequate amount of jump scares are seen within this season, with many being notable but similar to "Murder House," this season also does cover heavy topics, such as the objectification of women, killing for sport, purposeful false accusations, abortion, orphaning and religion.

Set within an insane asylum turned nunnery, this season plays into trying to heal the mentally ill through God. However, is met with a variety of obstacles, such as possession, a corrupt doctor, human experiments and surprisingly, aliens. Filled with plot twists, I found this season to be one of the more disturbing I've watched, thus being "scary" in that sense. Rather than being afraid of the plot, I was afraid for the characters in the moment, thus, was both a thrill and heart-stopping in times of distress. I definitely do not recommend this season for anyone first beginning to watch horror.

4. Freak Show — Season 4

As the title itself so demonstrates, this season is more than just a normal scare: it is a gut-wrenching, gore filled, horror show that covers a variety of topics that are both unnerving, unsettling and outright terrifying. Set within a small mid-western town, this season follows a plot line of a freak show passing through it; filled with oddities such as a woman without the bottom half of her body, a man with hands but no arms, the world's smallest women and two woman who share the same body and mind.

Along with the freak show, the town suffers from a series of killings by a serial clown named "Twisty" who wears a terrifying mask and travels around the town silently. Although this season may not have a large amount of jump scares, the ones that do appear are terrifying, thus, watching makes the viewer feel the need to be alert and ready and alert for the next one at all times. I had the most trouble getting through this season, as I found it both the most terrifying and heart-wrenching for the topics covered within it: killing for sport, kidnapping, mental illness, ghosts, abuse, etc.

One of the most notable: viewers are able to see and witness the mind of a rising serial killer from childhood to ultimate demise, a plot line so unsettling, I had to break up the season over a series of weeks. Without a doubt the most scariest season out of the first four, I highly do not recommend this season for first time watchers.

Although horror may present to be a threatening genre, there is beauty within the gore and scare-factor. Elements used by characters to enhance the story line, like facial expressions or the adjustment of body language, only add to the story and ultimate plot of their characters and the season. In a way, it is beautiful to see such a wide variety of factors fit within each other as if puzzle pieces and reflect about a season's end and admire the grander picture.

I do hope this article helps anyone wary about beginning to watch horror, but I also hope they are able to loose their fear and find the beauty within this genre of art as I have as well.

Popular Right Now

15 Reasons Your Grandma Is Probably The Strongest Woman In Your Life

Love. Unconditional love.


Grandma's are so much more than just a grandma.

They are there for you through it all.

They are there to be your best friend, to be the shoulder to cry on and to be there for you through it all. They go through so much to make sure that you have all that you want. But what happens when they forget who you are? When they aren't sure what day it is and where they are?

What happens when your grandma gets Alzheimer's?

You learn the true strength that she has.

You remember that she has always indeed been the strongest women that you know.

1. She never gives up

2. She helped to raise you

3. She was part of the generation that went through so much

4. She doesn't care what she says and will let you know how it is

5. She will always be there to help you

6. She puts everyone else's needs before her own

7. She loves everyone around her

8. She will always have your back

9. She can cook, even when its only hot dogs

10.  No matter what time throws at her, she thrives

11.  She ALWAYS has a smile on her face

12.  She always knows how to have fun

13.  She ALWAYS looks her best

14.  She taught us the true meaning of strength

15.  Even with losing her memories, she still shows you her love

Related Content

Connect with a generation
of new voices.

We are students, thinkers, influencers, and communities sharing our ideas with the world. Join our platform to create and discover content that actually matters to you.

Learn more Start Creating

11 Underrated Lana Del Rey Songs You Should Listen To When You Get Tired Of Listening To "Summertime Sadness"

"Summertime Sadness" is a classic, but it gets old.


As a Lana Del Rey fan, I love her mainstream songs like "Blue Jeans", "Born To Die" and "Summertime Sadness", but I prefer her less popular songs because I feel they have more substance.

1. "Bel Air"

lana del rey, singing

"Bel Air" is the epitome of beauty and grace. The soft piano background and the angelic vocals by Lana gives me chills. Surprisingly, this song has only 54k views on Lana's channel and 37 comments*. For reference, her song "Born To Die" has 412 million views 113,000 comments.

2. "Hope Is A Dangerous Thing For A Woman Like Me To Have - But I Have It"

singing, live performance

If you are not familiar with Lana Del Rey songs, not all her songs have sixteen word titles. This single was released only 5 months ago, and unfortunately it has not gotten much attention from anyone other than Lana fans. Regardless, it is one of my favorite songs by Lana.

3. "Honeymoon"

lana del rey, bubbles

The violin music in the intro is enough to pull on your heartstrings. "Honeymoon" is a slow tune with simple yet powerful vocals. Something about the song makes me feel a sense of nostalgia. This song can be found on Lana's album also called "Honeymoon".

4. "Blackest Day"

singing, live performance

This song contains vocals enriched with raw emotions. The lyrics reflect Lana's distressing experience with heartbreak. Lana sings "Ever since my baby went away, it's been the blackest day. "Blackest Day" can be found in Lana's 4th studio album "Honeymoon".

5. "This Is What Makes Us Girls"

lana del rey

This is one of Lana's most upbeat songs, but it has a dark backstory. The song reflects a recollection of events during Lana's troubled teenage past right before she got sent to boarding school for her disobedient behavior.

She sings "They were the only friends I ever had. When I got into trouble, and when stuff got bad I got sent away, I was waving on the train platform. Crying 'cause I know I'm never coming back."

6. "Without You"

lana del rey, singing

Lana sings about how all her fame, money and power are meaningless without her love. There is an eerie similarity between "Without You" and "Wildest Dreams" by Taylor Swift. There is speculation that Taylor Swift gets inspiration from Lana Del Rey.

7. "Cherry"

In this song, Lana explains what true love means to her based on passed experiences. Her haunting vocals along with the intriguing lyrics have her listeners pondering the meaning of the song.This song can be found on her newest album "Lust For Life".

8. "Lucky Ones"

lana del rey, singing, american flag

"Lucky Ones" is a song you fall in love with the first time you hear it. Lana's vocals are smooth and filled with genuine emotion. With only 24k views on YouTube, this song does not get the recognition it deserves. "Lucky Ones" appears on Lana's "Born To Die (Bonus Track Version)" album.

9. "Pretty When You Cry"

lana del rey, walking

"Pretty When You Cry" is a pleasant song with a catchy melody and a good instrumental. It's featured on Lana Del Rey's darkest album "Ultraviolence." It's surprising Lana recorded in one take and freestyled the song along with her guitarist Blake Stranathan

10. "Radio"

lana del rey, singing, live

Lana Del Rey wrote this song to throw shade at the people who came back into her life once her songs started playing on the radio. She describes the reentrance of people into her life once her fame started, and says it made her life "sweet like cinammon". "Radio" is one of her few upbeat songs. It can be found in the album Born To Die - The Paradise Edition.

11. "Million Dollar Man"

Even though the studio version of this song is good, her live performance of "Million Dollar Man" will leave you speechless. According to "The Sun", this is Lana's favorite song to perform live. "Million Dollar Man" can be found in her earlier album "Born to Die-Paradise Edition". It's surprising this song has only 300k views on her channel.

*Statistics are taken from the day this article was written.

Related Content

Facebook Comments