Why Some Minority Students Want To End Affirmative Action
Start writing a post

The Current War On Affirmative Action Is Being Led By Minorities, Not Just White Students

...to Wang's dismay, he had been rejected to all but one Ivy League Universities that he had applied to.

View of Harvard University

College admissions are getting dicier every year, especially at prestigious institutions such as the Ivy Leagues. One university that has been clouded by controversy, however, is Harvard. Although many wouldn't expect this war over racial discrimination to be happening in Cambridge, Massachusetts, it has become the heart of the discussion on keeping or tossing Affirmative Action.

A case is being brought to court by a newly founded group called "Students For Fair Admissions" (SFFA) which is being led by Michael Wang, an Asian-American student from the Bay Area. He had a 4.67 GPA, an SAT score in the 99th percentile, and participated in a myriad of extracurriculars, one being in a choir group that sang at Obama's inauguration. Reading this, it sounds like the perfect variables in the college admissions equation, but to Wang's dismay, he had been rejected to all but one Ivy League Universities that he had applied to. When considering the factors behind this outcome, he saw his race as the outlier.

Michael began working with a conservative financial adviser, Edward Blum, who has been dedicating his life to ridding of race-conscious laws. Blum is infamous for his heading of a nonprofit project called Project on Fair Representation, where he backed Abigail Fisher, a white girl, in her case against the University of Texas at Austin. She had been rejected from the school and complained that the reason she did not get in was that admissions officers chose less-qualified students of color over her. Fisher sued the university, and Blum helped her do it. This is who Michael partnered with.

The important takeaways from this case are as follows:

Harvard's admissions rates for Asians have increased, just as the volume of their applications is increasing as well. Universities, including Harvard, do not use a student's race for a quota or to "balance" the race ratio of the university. It is used to holistically evaluate the applicant to get the whole picture of their circumstances.

Getting into Harvard is hard. Just because you didn't get it does not automatically translate to the stacks being held against you. There is some luck involved.

If we were to consider someone's wealth or socioeconomic status instead of their race, as the people suing are arguing to do, Harvard's population of Hispanics and African-Americans would decrease by over 1,000 students over 4 years.

There are problems in admissions, but it's not affirmative action. What about factoring legacy into admissions? And relatives of faculty? It was found through court filings that although children of Harvard alumni and faculty are only 5% if the applicant pool, they make up 30% of admitted students. Moreover, it clearly favors white and wealthy families with a longer lineage in the United States, thus stacking the odds against immigrants and their children. It also maintains the rigidity of our current economic mobility state. In other words, it makes it much harder to move up the wealth ladder, something that America prides itself on. That would be something bringing to a court.

If the SFFA wins this case against Harvard, affirmative action in higher education could end as we know it. And it will hurt everyone, not just Black and Hispanic students. The promotion of diversity through programs such as affirmative action has nothing to do with giving spots to less qualified candidates, and everything to do with giving all qualified people a fair shot.

Report this Content
This article has not been reviewed by Odyssey HQ and solely reflects the ideas and opinions of the creator.
14 of the Most Revolutionary Short Films of All Time

Today's society places a ridiculous amount of importance on social media and what we see on our computer screens. Some of these short films you might have seen shared on Facebook. Some of them you may have never even heard of. Whatever the case may be, these productions have used thier position of power in our world today to spread a message. The messages vary from domestic violence, LGBTQ acceptance, self-love, the role of men in society to end the unfair treatment towards women and even the promotion of the furtherence of medical discovery in our country. Regardless of the message, each film advertises something that needs far more screen time than Victoria's Secret Fashion shows or Keeping Up With The Kardashians. Here are 14 of the best and most revolutionary short films to date:

Keep Reading...Show less


Because the best part of flying isn't the flying.

Google Images

I’m not sure that many would consider their airport experience to be “fun.” It is either boredom or panic, layovers so long that you forget what the outside world looks like or connections that are made by the skin of your teeth. It is the decision between buying expensive food and starving; it is hunting for outlets (because the airports I’ve been in seem to have about five); it is the stress of making it through security without being that person who holds up everyone else. In short, it is stressful and time-consuming.

Keep Reading...Show less
blair waldorf and chuck bass

New millennial jargon seems to arise everyday, one of the newest being “daddy." While people have always said things like “sugar daddy" or “come to daddy" (which sounds a tad creepy to me...okay, a lot creepy), now just referring to an attractive man or one's boyfriend/husband as simply “daddy" has become the norm. *Gag*

Keep Reading...Show less
Student Life

Clarity To Confusion

How I lost my certainty of the future.

Clarity To Confusion

Last year, I knew exactly what I would be doing with my life. Not just what major I wanted, although, I did know exactly what I was going to major in during college. I went further, though, and knew exactly what I wanted to do with it. I aimed to be a book editor and use my French and English majors to go into technical editing after going to grad school. Yet this semester, disenchantment hit. I had no clue what I wanted to do with my life anymore. I still loved the idea of being a book editor. I still loved reading. I just couldn't feel any passion towards the courses I had to take this semester. They were amazing, but they didn't excite me the way courses I would love should. They didn't inspire feelings of amazement at how awesome my major is. It was then I realized maybe my major wasn't for me.

Keep Reading...Show less

The Procrastination Station At College

We all have checked into "Procrastination Station" more than once..

The Procrastination Station At College
Achieve Center - Wendy Loewen

In high school, being a procrastinator wasn't that big of a deal in my own opinion. But coming from a school that didn't really have strict deadlines on things, meaning you basically got points for turning it in be it exactly on or before the deadline, or 4 weeks later when you realize your grade needs to be raised up. So, when I came to college, I knew it would be different. It hasn't really been hard transitioning into a good student when it comes to out of class work and projects, but it hasn't been that easy either. I will use myself for example. I am enrolled in Introduction to Public Speaking, and it's not that is a hard class, because it isn't, but I just get lost in other things and before I knew it, I had to present a persuasive speech the next day. I also realized this at about 11:15 the night before, and had about half of my outlines done, and my visual aid hadn't been started on. Though I got it done, I promised myself that I would not ever just wait until the last minute with specifically this class, but with any other class also. After that little dilemma, I decided to look for ways that I could get things done in a timely manner. So, here I have listed a few things that I now use in order to get things done before the deadline so that I do not have to rush and worry about it the night before:

Keep Reading...Show less

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Facebook Comments